Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Access granted  Restricted Access Subscription Access

No 2 (2023)

Cover Page

Full Issue

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Articles

Ritual agency and moral panics: toward the anthropology of blasphemy and sacrilege

Panchenko A.A.

Abstract

The introduction to the journal issue's special theme on “The Icon and the Axe: Discourses on Blasphemy and Sacrilege in the Russian Culture” deals with some theoretical aspects of anthropological research focusing on blasphemy, sacrilege, and desecration. The history of religious, secular, and post-secular cultures from the Middle Ages to the present day involve different types of discourses on blasphemy and sacrilege. Local cults of sacred sites, miraculous images and objects employ the concept of desecration to articulate the rules and norms of communication between humans and supernatural agents. Organized forms of sacrilege, like Reformation iconoclasm or Soviet anti-religious campaigns, aim at transformation of habitual ritual activities along with formation of new types of human and non-human agency. Present day “blasphemy panics” produce new identities and ideas of the moral order. The Russian history and culture of the recent centuries provides examples of coexistence and evolution of all these types.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):5-20
pages 5-20 views

Peasants, icons, and obscenities

Panchenko A.A.

Abstract

The article examines religious, ritual, and moral contexts in the history of semantics and social trajectories of the Russian obscene vocabulary and phraseology known as “mat”. Transhistorical representations of the “Russian mat” as a steady set of lexemes and formulae do not seem to be correct. Moreover, it is possible to discuss not only historical transformations of the concept, but its genealogy and, so to speak, invention. One of the few concepts explaining religious and mythological meanings of “mat” was formulated in the 1980s by Boris A. Uspenskii who argued that pre-Christian Slavic obscenities were related to agrarian magic of fertility. This article presents an alternative hypothesis and argues that the “invention” and religious interpretation of the “Russian mat” as a specific and blasphemous type of obscenities took place in Muscovy in the 16th and 17th century as a part of attempted “disciplinary revolution” aimed at popular religious and ritual culture. Local “visionary epidemics” in the 17th century that involved condemnation of “mat”, tobacco, and drunkenness can be viewed as moral panics stimulated by the state and church elites. At the same time, the panics led to the establishment of new cults of miracle working icons and sacred sites. Popular beliefs and prohibitions related to “mat” in the 19th and 20th centuries were informed by a number of different factors and did not go back to any single pre-Christian source.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):21-51
pages 21-51 views

Defiling the portraits of state leaders in the soviet culture of the later half of the 1950s - early 1960s

Senina I.N.

Abstract

The article deals with the topic of violation of the boundaries of the secular sacral in the late 1950s and early 1960s - namely, the cases of damage to symbols sacred to the Soviet ideology, such as portraits of the state leaders. I discuss why these symbols acquired a special semiotic status and their damage was punished not as hooliganism but as a kind of ritual defilement, the punishment for which was provided for by the Criminal Code of the Russian Federal Socialist Republic. Among the main sources of information about individual cases of such “sacrilege” were the archives of the supervisory proceedings of the USSR Prosecutor's Office. It is on the basis of the surviving case files that one can analyze acts of “grassroots” anti-government actions and learn about those who committed them, since most of these people did not leave behind memoirs or other records that would talk about their personal history.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):52-65
pages 52-65 views

The sacralization of the secular in contemporary Russia: the “desecration” of the eternal flame

Petrov N.V., Peigin B.S.

Abstract

The article examines more than 100 cases of “desecration” of the Eternal Flame in Russia in the 2010s-2020s. In the context of criminal cases involving blasphemy and desecration of holy places, starting with the “Pussy Riot case”, the cases of the “desecration” of the Eternal Flame allow us to see, first, how the arguments and language used by the media and law enforcement in the legal discussion regarding the secular sacred are shaped; and second, how the shift from the symbolic to the material occurs in relation to symbols of memory in contemporary Russian society. The article shows how and on what grounds perpetrators of such behavior are prosecuted in contemporary Russia, and what penalties are imposed on them. Despite the presence of special norms on such deeds in the Russian criminal law, they are in some cases qualified by law enforcers with their use, in others as vandalism or desecration of the bodies of the dead and their burial places, in still others as administrative offences. Law enforcers in all cases clearly read their meaning (as an attempt on the sacred), but the Russian law lacks a legal definition of “desecration” (if the term itself exists), which apparently leads to the use of different norms to punish those responsible. Since these actions are interpreted by law enforcers as sacrilegious, it seems appropriate for us to propose for them the general term “memorial sacrilege”, by which we mean unconventional actions with memorial complexes and their elements, in particular the Eternal Flames, entailing the use of repression.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):66-92
pages 66-92 views

It is “Blasphemy to touch this burial”: how archaeologists can hurt the feelings of believers and strengthen the ethnic-religious identity in the North Ossetia - Alania

Shtyrkov S.A.

Abstract

In 2020, in the Republic of North Ossetia - Alania, excavations of a burial ground near the medieval chapel in the village of Nuzal started. This architectural object is very important for the historical memory of Ossetians, as it is considered the tomb of Os-Bagatar, the last king of an independent medieval state of Alans, ancestors of Ossetians. In addition, this small building is inscribed as a very important element in two competing narratives about the true ethnic religion of the Ossetians. The Orthodox view the chapel in the village of Nuzal as an ancient Christian shrine (since medieval church frescoes have survived there), and Ossetian religious nativists view it as a pre-Christian site illegally appropriated by Christian missionaries. When excavations began, some nativists claimed the works were blasphemy. The article examines how the discourse of “insulting religious feelings” works, where the act of transgression is generated by the creative imagination of offended people rather than by the deliberate actions of the alleged blasphemers. Moreover, these feelings can stimulate the reinforcement of ethnic-religious identities that remain weakly articulated beyond these dramatic events.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):93-110
pages 93-110 views

The “sorrystan”: public apologies and moral order in today’s Dagestan

Kapustina E.L., Khonineva E.A.

Abstract

The article deals with the moral implications of the practice of public apologies, based on the case of modern Dagestan. Unlike most studies in linguistics and political science, in this article, we are interested not in the structure of official apologies as speech acts and the conditions of achieving their communicative effect, but rather in the variability of pictures of the moral order that may stand behind the need for public apologies in a particular cultural context, and the type of moral subject that can be constructed through such public acts. The material for the analysis included the public apologies that are relevant within Dagestani society, the apologies by Dagestani people living outside the republic, and the cases of apologies to Dagestanis themselves. The article demonstrates how the spread of the practice of public apologies has problematized the boundaries of collective responsibility in Dagestani society, the notions of the subject, its qualities and agency associated with the institution of reputation, as well as the possibility of subordination and resistance to the social structure.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):111-133
pages 111-133 views

Non diis curae: the rhetoric and practices of natural punishment for sacrilege

Drozdov S.T.

Abstract

The article analyzes situations in which punishment for sacrilege is carried out by natural actors without the intervention of the supernatural ones. Such actors include the state represented by lawmakers and law enforcers, religious specialists, as well as religious activists and ordinary believers. The configurations of agency of the three types of actors described in the article, which have their own specifics and tools for natural (as opposed to supernatural) retaliation for sacrilege, cause violent or non-violent resolution of conflicts in which representatives of either type see blasphemy and sacrilege. The article also analyzes the boundaries of actor agency related, on the one hand, to perceptions of the right to the sanctuary and, consequently, to anger over its desecration, and, on the other hand, to the real possibility to carry out this punishment. In the case of the latter, the notion of conditional agency of the “accused” by “prosecutors” is also discussed, and the ways and reasons for its reduction are considered.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):134-152
pages 134-152 views

Ancestors against order: two models of Immortal regiment

Kirziuk A.A., Arkhipova A.S., Gavrilova M.V., Kozlova I.V., Belyanin S.V.

Abstract

The paper focuses on the two most common models of organization of the Immortal Regiment. We call the first the “social order” model. Its aim is to demonstrate the local community in its ideal condition. Such a procession is clearly structured, its participants are often uniformed, and the place of each participant depends on his or her belonging to one or another professional/age group. The second type of organization of the procession is called the “cult of ancestors” model. In this case, the order of the columns and the appearance of the portrait bearers do not matter, since the main participants in the procession are not the living, but the dead. The success of the procession organized according to this model is measured by the strength of its emotional effect: ideally, participants and spectators cry in catharsis. Describing these two models in detail, we examine the conflicts between their adherents, as well as analyze the motivations of the organizers and ordinary participants in the processions.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):153-175
pages 153-175 views

The people that survived by a miracle: on ethnic self-presentation of the kashubians

Vasiukov O.D.

Abstract

The article focuses on the discursive strategies of presenting ethnicity that are employed by the present-day Kashubians of Poland. Kashubians are a West Slavic minority ethnic group which was legally recognized as a regional linguistic community in 2005. Drawing on the materials of anthropological fieldwork conducted in areas inhabited by ethnic Kashubians, I describe some of the practices of ethnic and national self-definition of the locals and address the ways in which Kashubians experience otherness and use the rhetoric of otherness. Analyzing a range of themes and topics related to the ethnicity of the informants, I show how Kashubians of different generations reflect on the ethnic and linguistic specificity of their community, construct, maintain, and cross the traditional and new social boundaries, as well as ponder over the issue of preserving their group identity within the framework of the Polish national state.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):176-198
pages 176-198 views

Men who practice risky hobbies are more physically masculine

Butovskaya M.L., Adam Y.I., Mezentseva A.A., Rostovtseva V.V.

Abstract

The aim of the study was to investigate specific morphological and psychological characteristics of representatives of leisure communities focused on taking high risks, compared to the control group of men. We studied facial and body anthropometric parameters - presumable markers of prenatal androgenization and masculinization - as well as the tendency to search for sensations and aggression in race car drivers (n=36), alpinists (n=52) and students (n=56). We were also interested in possible associations between the studied morphological and psychological parameters. It was revealed that the faces of the representatives of all three groups differed significantly in the facial shape. All three groups differed from each other in the fWHR index (the bizygomatic width/the height of the middle part of the face), with the race drivers having the lowest values and the highest for the controls. Race drivers differed significantly from controls in the relative lower jaw height. The maximum average values for the handgrip strength on both hands were noted in the race drivers, and the minimum in the control. We did not find significant differences in the digit ratio on the right and left hands between the groups. The result of the analysis of psychological profiles showed that alpinists are more prone to risk and sensation seeking, as well as more sensitive to the monotonous daily activities compared to race drivers and the control group, while the maximum level of hostility was found for the control group.
Ètnografičeskoe obozrenie. 2023;(2):199-221
pages 199-221 views
pages 222-226 views
pages 227-231 views
pages 232-237 views
pages 238-242 views

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies