Email this article 
It is “Blasphemy to touch this burial”: how archaeologists can hurt the feelings of believers and strengthen the ethnic-religious identity in the North Ossetia - Alania
- Authors: Shtyrkov S.A1
-
Affiliations:
- European University at St. Petersburg
- Issue: No 2 (2023)
- Pages: 93-110
- Section: Articles
- URL: https://journals.rcsi.science/0869-5415/article/view/144871
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.31857/S0869541523020057
- EDN: https://elibrary.ru/QUYLTU
- ID: 144871
Cite item
Open Access
Access granted
Subscription Access
Abstract
In 2020, in the Republic of North Ossetia - Alania, excavations of a burial ground near the medieval chapel in the village of Nuzal started. This architectural object is very important for the historical memory of Ossetians, as it is considered the tomb of Os-Bagatar, the last king of an independent medieval state of Alans, ancestors of Ossetians. In addition, this small building is inscribed as a very important element in two competing narratives about the true ethnic religion of the Ossetians. The Orthodox view the chapel in the village of Nuzal as an ancient Christian shrine (since medieval church frescoes have survived there), and Ossetian religious nativists view it as a pre-Christian site illegally appropriated by Christian missionaries. When excavations began, some nativists claimed the works were blasphemy. The article examines how the discourse of “insulting religious feelings” works, where the act of transgression is generated by the creative imagination of offended people rather than by the deliberate actions of the alleged blasphemers. Moreover, these feelings can stimulate the reinforcement of ethnic-religious identities that remain weakly articulated beyond these dramatic events.
References
- Белецкий Д.В. Заметки о Нузальском храме // Историко-филологический архив. 2004. № 2. С. 22-57.
- Белецкий Д.В., Виноградов А.Ю. Нижний Архыз и Сенты - древнейшие храмы России. Проблемы христианского искусства Алании и Северо-западного Кавказа. М.: Индрик, 2011.
- Гольдштейн А.Ф. Средневековое зодчество Чечено-Ингушетии и Северной Осетии. М.: Наука, 1975.
- Джанайты С.Х. Три слезы Бога. Владикавказ: СОИГСИ им. В.И. Абаева, 2007.
- Кузнецов В.А. Реком, Нузал и Царaзонта. Владикавказ: Ир, 1990.
- Мужухоев М.Б. К вопросу об интерпретации некоторых культурных памятников Северной Осетии эпохи Средневековья // Вопросы историко-культурных связей на Северном Кавказе / Отв. ред. М.М. Блиев. Орджоникидзе: СОГУ им. К.Л. Хетагурова, 1985. С. 72-82.
- Панков И.А. Легенды об осквернении святынь как элемент структуры сакрального пространства мазара // Традиционная культура. 2020. Т. 21. № 2. С. 148-159. https://doi.org/10.26158/TK.2020.21.2.013
- Синанов Б.А. 1100-летие Крещения Алании в общественно-политическом и общественном дискурсе Северной Осетии // Kavkaz-Forum. 2022. № 11 (18). С. 108-128. https://doi.org/10.46698/VNC.2022.18.11.009
- Тменов В.Х. Древние верования осетин и ингушей и их отражение в памятниках материальной культуры // Вопросы историко-культурных связей на Северном Кавказе / Отв. ред. М.М. Блиев. Орджоникидзе: СОГУ им. К.Л. Хетагурова, 1985. С. 33-71.
- Шнирельман В.А. Ценность прошлого: этноцентристские исторические мифы, идентичность и этнополитика // Реальность этнических мифов / Отв. ред. М.Б. Олкотт, А. Малашенко. М.: Гендальф, 2000. С. 12-33.
- Alonso A.M. The Politics of Space, Time, and Substance: State Formation, Nationalism, and Ethnicity // Annual Review of Anthropology. 1994. No. 23. P. 379-405.
- Bhabha H.K. The Location of Culture. L.: Routledge, 1994.
- Brož L. Conversion to Religion? Negotiating Continuity and Discontinuity in Contemporary Altai // Conversion after Socialism: Disruptions, Modernisms and Technologies of Faith in the Former Soviet Union / Ed. M. Pelkmans. Oxford: Berghahn Books, 2009. P. 17-37.
- Brož L. Spirits, Genes and Walt Disney's Deer: Creativity in Identity and Archeology Disputes (Altai, Siberia) // The Archaeological Encounter: Anthropological Perspective / Eds. P. Fortis, I. Praet. St. Andrews: University of St. Andrews, 2011. P. 263-297.
- Davie G. Vicarious Religion: A Methodological Challenge // Everyday Religion: Observing Modern Religious Lives / Ed. N. Ammerman. N.Y.: Oxford University Press, 2007. P. 21-35.
- Day J. The Mummy's Curse: Mummymania in the English-Speaking World. L.: Routledge, 2006.
- Esders S. "Faithful believers": Oaths of Allegiance in Post-Roman Societies as Evidence for Eastern and Western "Visions of Community" // Visions of Community in the Post-Roman World: The West, Byzantium and the Islamic World, 300-1100 / Eds. C. Ganter, R. Payne, W. Pohl. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing, 2012. P. 357-374.
- Favret-Saada J.Rushdie et compagnie: Préalables à une anthropologie du blasphème // Ethnologie française. 1992. No. 22 (3). P. 251-260.
- Favret-Saada J. An Anthropology of Religious Polemics: The Case of Blasphemy Affairs // HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory. 2016. No. 6 (1). P. 29-45.
- Foltz R. The Ossetes: Modern-Day Scythians of the Caucasus. L.: Bloomsbury, 2021.
- Halemba A. "What does It Feel Like when Your Religion Moves under Your Feet?" Religion, Earthquakes and National Unity in the Republic of Altai, Russian Federation // Zeitschrift für Ethnologie. 2008. No. 133 (2). P. 283-299.
- Khodarkovsky M. "Not by Word Alone": Missionary Policies and Religious Conversion in Early Modern Russia // Comparative Studies in Society and History. 1996. No. 38 (2). P. 267-293.
- Kohl P.L. Nationalism and Archaeology: On the Constructions of Nations and the Reconstructions of the Remote Past // Annual Review of Anthropology. 1998. No. 27. P. 223-246.
- Kouznetsov V., Lebedynsky Y. Les Alains: Cavaliers des steppes, seigneurs du Caucase: Ier-XVe siècles apr. J-C. Paris: Errance, 2005.
- Mahmood S. Religious Reason and Secular Affect: An Incommensurable Divide? // Is Critique Secular? Blasphemy, Injury, and Free Speech / Ed. T. Asad et al. Berkeley: University of Berkeley, 2009. P. 64-100.
- Marchisio R., Pisati M. Belonging without Believing: Catholics in Contemporary Italy // Journal of Modern Italian Studies. 1999. No. 4 (2). P. 236-255.
- Plets G., Konstantinov N., Soenov V., Robinson E. Repatriation, Doxa, and Contested Heritages the Return of the Altai Princess in an International Perspective // Anthropology & Archeology of Eurasia. 2013. No. 52 (2). P. 73-98.
- Riis O. Religion et Identité Nationale au Danemark // Identités Religieuses en Europe / Eds. G. Davie, D. Hervieu-Léger. Paris: La Découverte, 1996. P. 113-130.
- Rosenwein B.H. Emotional Communities in the Early Middle Ages. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2006.
- Tadina N.A. A Native Anthropologist's View on Covering the "Altai Princess" Problem // Anthropology & Archeology of Eurasia. 2020. No. 59 (2). P. 112-127.
- Timothy D.J., Conover P.J. Nature Religion, Self-Spirituality and New Age Tourism // Tourism, Religion and Spiritual Journeys / Eds. D.J. Timothy, D.H. Olsen. L.: Routledge, 2006. P. 139-155.
Supplementary files
