Vol 8, No 2 (2025)
- Year: 2025
- Articles: 25
- URL: https://journals.rcsi.science/2658-5693/issue/view/25757
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.58224/2658-5693-2025-8-2
Full Issue
ARTICLES
Comparative analysis of surrogacy in the Russian Federation and France
Abstract
the relevance of the topic is beyond doubt, as the birth rate is falling all over the world and the number of couples suffering from infertility is increasing every year. Modern medical technologies (test tube conceiving) allow spouses to become holders of parental rights in relation to a child born by a surrogate mother, who is expected to abandon the child in favor of the spouses-customers. The authors conduct a comparative analysis of surrogacy in the Russian Federation and France and draw appropriate conclusions. The article provides statistical data on the birth of children and problems associated with conception and bearing a child both in Russia and in France. It should be noted that modern family legislation pays almost no attention to the institution of surrogacy, therefore, in our opinion, it is necessary to amend the Family Code of the Russian Federation and add a chapter devoted to surrogacy, including the Civil Code of the Russian Federation naming the surrogacy agreement, and also to determine the forms and methods of protecting the rights of the embryo.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):5-10
5-10
The place and role of procedural duties in the mechanism of civil proceedings
Abstract
the article examines the theoretical and practical aspects of the place and role of procedural duties in the mechanism of civil proceedings. The author focuses on the fact that procedural duty is one of the key categories of civil procedure law, ensuring the implementation of the principles of fairness, equality of the parties and legality in the consideration and resolution of disputes in court. The research is based on an analysis of the norms of the Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, judicial practice, as well as the scientific works of leading procedural scientists. The paper reveals the content of procedural duty as a legal phenomenon, defines its types, subject composition and functional purpose. Special attention is paid to the relationship between the procedural duties of participants in legal proceedings and their rights, as well as the consequences of failure to fulfill such duties for ensuring the effectiveness of justice. The author emphasizes that procedural duties play an important role in the structure of civil proceedings, as they are aimed at creating conditions for a comprehensive, complete and objective investigation of the circumstances of the case. At the same time, it is noted that improper performance or evasion of procedural duties can significantly complicate the implementation of the tasks of justice, including the protection of violated or disputed rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of citizens and organizations.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):11-17
11-17
Comparative and legal analysis of prohibitions and restrictions applied in the execution of a preventive measure in the form of house arrest and prohibition of certain actions under Russian and foreign legislation
Abstract
a comparative legal analysis of the choice of preventive measures in the form of house arrest and prohibition of certain actions in countries with different legal systems has allowed us to draw conclusions about the need to modernize national legislation in terms of improving the approach to the enforcement of prohibitions of certain actions. Thus, now there are conditions for the further development of this procedural norm, its improvement and the possibility of more thorough and scrupulous regulation of the lawful behavior of the persecuted person during the preliminary investigation and trial. Firstly, it seems advisable to expand the legislative list of prohibitions by including a ban on approaching in such a list. The enforcement of such a ban can be ensured by the use of electronic tracking devices. Secondly, it will be relevant to introduce rules into legislation that allow courts, at their discretion, taking into account the data on the identity of the suspect or accused, the actual circumstances of the criminal case and the information provided by the parties, to establish other measures against the persecuted person to ensure his proper behavior and isolation from society, which will allow for more effective criminal proceedings.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):18-24
18-24
Some features of traditions and their influence on the legal basis of society
Abstract
the article is devoted to the doctrinal approach to the essence of traditions, their classification and features. The role of legal tradition as one of the elements of the civilizational and cultural foundations of society and its recognition by the state is revealed. The author argues that in modern society, the creative and educational nature of national traditions is deepening, modernizing, and increasingly being integrated into public life. They are considered to be a reflection of the moral, ethical side of people's lives, their social practices, which do not contradict the generally recognized norms of universal morality.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):25-30
25-30
Legal status of climate refugees
Abstract
in the context of global climate change, accompanied by an increase in extreme weather events and rising sea levels, the problem of forced displacement is becoming increasingly urgent. Millions of people around the world are forced to leave their homes due to the consequences of climate change, such as droughts, floods, desertification, and other natural disasters. This article is devoted to a comprehensive study of the complex and multifaceted problem of the legal status of climate refugees, which requires immediate attention and coordinated action by the international community. The purpose of the article is to analyze the existing legal framework governing the status of climate refugees and to identify its gaps and shortcomings. The objectives of the study are: to examine the problem of the lack of a single definition of the concept of "climate refugee"; to analyze the debatable issue of the applicability to climate migrants of the provisions of the 1951 Refugee Convention; to assess the effectiveness of existing international legal regulation in the field of protection of persons forcibly displaced as a result of climate change; to analyze the practical measures taken by states to address the problem of climate migration. Particular attention is paid to the analysis of real measures taken by states, including the development of national climate change adaptation strategies, resettlement programs, and assistance systems. The practical significance of the study lies in the possibility of using its results to develop effective legal mechanisms for the protection of climate refugees, as well as to formulate national and international strategies for managing climate migration.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):31-36
31-36
Philosophical and legal ideas of antiquity as a source of law
Abstract
the article is devoted to the analysis of the formation of natural law theories in antiquity. This approach is due to the fact that at present the concept of natural law, on the one hand, is the most popular among researchers, on the other hand, it has not been sufficiently studied. There are many scientific approaches in modern philosophy of law regarding the origin of natural law concepts. When analyzing this phenomenon, they turn to the Enlightenment, which is a tradition of scientific research in the study of this concept. But it should be noted that in the era of antiquity, the first philosophical theories, considering natural law, filled it with a broader ideological meaning than in the Enlightenment. The concept of natural law, developed by the thinkers of the Enlightenment, was prepared by the philosophy of antiquity, and such as Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Cicero and many others. The object of the study is the philosophy of law, the subject of the study is the origins of natural law in the philosophical and legal concepts of antiquity.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):37-41
37-41
Classification of issues and tasks solved by judicial construction and technical expertise
Abstract
the article is devoted to a systematic analysis of the range of issues and tasks solved by the judicial construction and technical expertise. In order to establish a unified approach to the variety of categories of issues resolved by such an expert, the author, based on the analysis of scientific literature and materials of judicial practice, develops a classification of issues and tasks that are most often the subject of construction and technical expertise in practice. In particular, the author suggests dividing such issues into three large classification groups depending on the direct object of the study – expertise of construction works, expertise of construction facilities and expertise of phenomena, actions and processes in the construction sector. The paper substantiates the essential features and differences of these categories of issues (tasks) solved by construction and technical expertise, and also suggests their additional classifications into smaller subgroups. Based on the results of the analysis, the author was able to propose a holistic and logically coherent classification of the types of tasks and issues resolved by forensic construction and technical expertise.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):42-46
42-46
The concept of a transaction: difficulties of theoretical definition
Abstract
transactions occupy an important place in the system of civil legislation and law enforcement practice, since they are the main instrument that ensures the regulation of both property and personal non-property relations between various subjects of civil law, including both individuals and legal entities. Transactions can be considered as a specific form of expression of will, which leads to the emergence, change or termination of civil rights and obligations. Transactions are legal facts related to the category of "actions". This means that they are the result of active actions of subjects, it can entail various legal consequences.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):47-52
47-52
Organizational and legal foundations of the modern cadastral land valuation system
Abstract
cadastral valuation of land is a system of interrelated elements (norms, concepts, tools, methods) that operate according to established principles for determining value. The state cadastral valuation is a complex process of establishing the cadastral value of real estate registered in the Unified State Register of Legal Entities on a specific date. This mechanism is carried out in strict accordance with the provisions of Federal Law No. 237-FZ dated 07/03/2016 "On State Cadastral Valuation", the standards set out in Rosreestr Order No. P/0336 dated 08/04/2021, which approved guidelines for its implementation, as well as other applicable legal acts of Rosreestr regulating this area. Current aspects of legislative regulation directly in the field of cadastral valuation of land are subject to constant changes, which necessitates a dynamic revision of methodological approaches and organization features of practical algorithms for land valuation. This article discusses the main features of the organizational and legal support for the state cadastral assessment of the lands of settlements and its disadvantages.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):53-58
53-58
Grounds for choosing a preventive measure in the form of detention and their proof
Abstract
the problem of the correct choice of preventive measures by the courts in modern criminal proceedings is very relevant. At the same time, the problems associated with the choice of such a preventive measure as detention, which is the strictest of all provided for by the norms of criminal procedure legislation, become particularly important. Despite the fact that the current legislation contains an exhaustive list of general and special grounds for choosing detention as a preventive measure, the process of proving such necessity takes place formally. As law enforcement practice shows, the authorities of the preliminary investigation base their choice of a preventive measure in the form of detention on unsubstantiated assumptions regarding the possibility of the persecuted person committing one of the actions listed in Article 97 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and therefore the courts choose this measure in the absence of the necessary grounds. The existing trends undermine the positive attitude of society towards the Russian justice system, the impartiality of which, as well as the right to freedom, is guaranteed by constitutionally declared principles. Hence, the only solution to the problem may be to ensure the adversarial nature of the parties in the judicial process on petitions for the election of preventive measures, since the adversarial nature of the parties to ensure an objective examination of all the circumstances of the committed unlawful act, taking into account the identity of the person accused (suspected) of its commission, must be carried out when assessing all the grounds necessary to make a decision on the election of the strictest all preventive measures provided for by legislative norms, including taking into account the gravity of the committed act. This approach will not only ensure transparency of the decision-making process on the part of the court, but also ensure respect for constitutionally declared human and civil rights, taking into account the balance of public (state) interests and private (individual) interests in criminal proceedings.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):59-64
59-64
Crimes related to various manifestations of extremism on the Internet, including in social networks
Abstract
the article is devoted to the prevention and crimes committed related to extremism on the Internet, including in social networks. The younger generation makes up the lion's share of Internet users, actively consuming information from the Internet, often uncritically assessing its reliability and potential danger. This makes them particularly vulnerable to manipulation and recruitment by extremists. Extremist ideologies are often based on intolerance, discrimination, and hatred of certain groups of people. They use propaganda and manipulation to attract new supporters and create an atmosphere of fear and hostility. On the Internet, these methods become effective due to the possibility of instant information dissemination and targeted advertising. Combating extremism on the Internet is a complex task that requires an integrated approach. Law enforcement agencies face difficulties related to the anonymity of users, the transnational nature of extremist activities, and the constant improvement of methods for circumventing blockages and controls. When initiating a criminal case, the prosecutor's office and judicial authorities should take into account not only the fact of posting materials containing signs of extremist activity, but also the broader context, which includes the content and motives of these materials. A system of typical methods of crimes against life and health committed by minors and youth motivated by political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity, or motivated by hatred or enmity against any social group, and their impact on the mechanism of trace formation.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):65-70
65-70
Protection of the rights of minor citizens of the Russian Federation by the prosecutor's office: implementation problems
Abstract
prosecutor's supervision is one of the most important functions of the prosecutor's office, aimed at ensuring the rule of law in the state. It includes the systematic activities of prosecutors to identify and suppress violations of the law. The effectiveness of the prosecutor's office in observing the rights of minors is the most important condition for their well-being and full development. The areas of activity of the prosecutor's office in the field of protecting the rights and interests of minor citizens of our country are multi-vector, however, the key ones are assistance to minors and their families who find themselves in a difficult life situation, as well as the protection of property and housing rights of minors. In this article, the author examines the key areas of activity of prosecutors in the above areas. The factual basis of the study is drawn by the author from the materials of the Khabarovsk Territory Prosecutor's Office in 2024. Study of official certificates and decisions on specific cases considered in the Khabarovsk Territory. The author, having studied the regulatory legal acts on the activities of the prosecutor's office in the Russian Federation, scientific research of various scientists, came to the conclusion that the effectiveness of the prosecutor's office in observing the law and protecting the interests of minor citizens depends on interaction with other law enforcement agencies.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):71-75
71-75
Lawmaking and the development of Russian legal thought at the turn of the XVI-XVII centuries
Abstract
the article is devoted to the analysis of legislative and political processes that took place in the Russian state at the turn of the XVI-XVII centuries from the point of view of assessing their significance as factors that influenced the development of the state and legal structure of Russia and, ultimately, the form of government. In particular, the paper reveals the impact of the results of the Time of Troubles on further stabilization legislative changes aimed at increasing the level of legal protection of a person, socio-economic well-being, as well as strengthening the central government around the figure of the monarch. At the same time, one of the key features of the development of legal thinking in the period under study is the revision of views on the unlimited nature of state power, which from now on changes to ideas about limiting the power of the monarch, which cannot be arbitrary, and must also respect the rights and interests of the population.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):76-80
76-80
Personal funds: problems of the civil law situation and proposals for the modernization of existing legislative norms
Abstract
in the article, in order to identify the problems of the civil-legal status of personal funds and develop proposals for the modernization of legislative norms of civil law, the legal structures and mechanisms of functioning of these funds are studied. Improving the legal mechanism of action of personal funds is important for the formation of law enforcement practice. Despite the fact that in theory proposals have been developed to reduce the problems of the legal status of funds as non-profit unitary organizations (§ 7 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation), the conceptual question of the conformity of the form and content of a personal fund remains open. On the one hand, the introduction of personal funds into the legal field of Russia has led to an expansion of the dispositivity of civil law, on the other hand, it has created new problems. To eliminate the identified shortcomings, additions to the regulatory legal acts on personal funds are proposed. It is proposed to narrow the optional norm for managing a personal fund by supplementing the current legislation with norms on the mandatory creation of a board of trustees, a supervisory body, a collegial executive body headed by an executive director who acts under a power of attorney from the sole executive body for the said funds (clause 3 of Article 123.20-7 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). Identification of problems in the civil-legal status of personal funds made it possible to formulate proposals for modernizing legislative norms. The proposed changes to the legislation, its development, in the opinion of the author of the article, will open up new opportunities in the activities of personal funds and business protection.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):81-86
81-86
Problems of legislative regulation of criminal liability for exercise illegal influence on the result of a sports competition
Abstract
in the context of the increasing commercialization of sports and the associated risk of corruption, the problem of ensuring the integrity and transparency of sports competitions is becoming particularly relevant. Criminal liability for exerting unlawful influence on the outcome of a sports competition is one of the key tools in the fight against this negative phenomenon. However, the existing legislative regulation of this area suffers from a number of significant shortcomings that require detailed analysis and improvement. This article examines the specifics of the qualification of an act that is committed by bribing participants and organizers of professional sports competitions and spectacular commercial contests. The results of the study can be used in the process of improving criminal legislation regulating liability for exerting unlawful influence on the outcome of a sports competition, as well as in the law enforcement practice of courts and law enforcement agencies.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):87-93
87-93
Purpose and motives for entering into a prenuptial agreement
Abstract
this scientific article attempts to identify the main purpose of concluding a prenuptial agreement, as well as to present a typology of motives that induce spouses to enter into these contractual relations. It is presumed that the main and actually the only purpose of the conclusion of the prenuptial agreement is the desire of its subjects to settle important aspects of their property relations. At the same time, the opinion is consistently presented according to which it is appropriate to subdivide the specific motives for concluding a prenuptial agreement into legal and unlawful ones: the first group of motives is based on any lawful inducements of the subjects of marital legal relations, while the second group of motives is based on some intents contrary to the letter and spirit of the law. The most common, typical unlawful motives for concluding the prenuptial agreement are given and characterized in detail, among which are presented the fraudulent motive of obtaining property benefit in the absence of collusion between the spouses, the fraudulent motive of obtaining property benefit in the presence of collusion between the spouses and the violent motive of obtaining property benefit. It is noted that despite the external diversity of various legal and even more illegal motives that induce future or current spouses to conclude a prenuptial agreement, all of them have a common semantic «core» – obtaining certain property satisfaction.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):94-99
94-99
Sanctions bans and restrictions on maritime transportation of cargo with participation of Russia
Abstract
this article is devoted to the analysis of sanctions restrictions imposed on international maritime transportation with an emphasis on their impact on the Russian shipping sector. The key aspects of international law governing maritime logistics are considered and the main types of sanctions applied to Russia are described in detail, specifically from the point of view of international maritime cargo transportation, including port entry bans, restrictions on ship insurance, blocking of participation in tenders and asset freezes. The impact of sanctions on global logistics in particular on supply chains and rising cost, is also being investigated. Special attention is being paid to Russia's retaliatory measures, such as the closure of ports for foreign vessels, increased port fees, the development of domestic transport infrastructure and the promotion of domestic shipping. The article presents an assessment of the adaptation measures of Russian shipowners including reorientation to eastern markets, creation of their own insurance system, use of transit ports and flag change of ships. The proposed strategies and a review of legislative acts form a comprehensive picture of the current situation in the industry, reflecting both the challenges and opportunities for Russian maritime transport in the face of increased sanctions pressure.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):100-118
100-118
The legal nature of subsidiary liability in bankruptcy
Abstract
in this article, the author examines the legal nature of subsidiary liability of KDL provided for by the Bankruptcy Law, analyzes the views of scientists on the source of origin of this type of liability, taking into account changing judicial practice, and draws conclusions based on the analysis. The purpose of this study was historical materials, regulatory legal acts, and the opinion of scientists, which made it possible to identify the main ideas of the institute of subsidiary liability, as well as statistical data, on the basis of which it was concluded that the institute of subsidiary liability at the current stage of development of bankruptcy legislation is dynamically developing and solving legal issues related to compensation for damage in in general, for bringing to bankruptcy. The findings of the study can be applied in practice for a more in-depth understanding of the behavior of the person controlling the debtor on the subject of illegality and guilt, which will allow participants in the proceedings to more fully disclose the presence or absence of grounds for bringing subsidiary liability to the KDL in each specific bankruptcy case.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):119-126
119-126
Children's rights in cyberspace: in search of a regulatory model and legal protection
Abstract
the purpose of the study is to identify mechanisms for implementing children's rights in cyberspace, focusing on issues such as protecting personal information, combating online bullying, combating child pornography, ensuring access to safe content and other aspects. The authors note that legislation must comply with the changing digital environment and take into account the rights and interests of children. It is shown that with the advent of the Internet, social networks, mobile devices and online games, children spend more and more time on the Internet. In this regard, many problems and risks arise, including online cruelty, cyberbullying, access to inappropriate content, cybercrimes and violations of privacy. The authors conclude that legal norms in the field of combating cybercrime must certainly form an organic structure that combines national and international laws in the field of the legal status of minors and minors. Threats to children's safety in the information space are unpredictable, so it is extremely important, on the one hand, to form traditional spiritual and moral values in children in order to counteract the spread of fake information flow, and on the other hand, it is necessary to control illegal forms of behavior in cyberspace.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):127-131
127-131
Current issues of reforming the customs authorities of the Russian Federation in the context of Eurasian interstate integration
Abstract
the article examines the processes of reforming the customs authorities of the Russian Federation in the context of the introduction of modern customs control technologies and the transition to a service administration model. The directions and prospects of reforming the customs authorities of the EAEU countries through the prism of the processes of Eurasian interstate integration are proposed. The authors analyze the current challenges associated with the strengthening of integration processes within the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU), and consider the need to adapt customs services to new conditions. Special attention is paid to the analysis of strategic documents aimed at changing customs regulations. Attention is focused on the special strategic nature of the development of interstate integration processes in the post-Soviet space for the Russian Federation in terms of ensuring economic priorities, mutually beneficial foreign economic activity, and the public and private interests of the Russian state, society, citizens, and legal entities. The study examines the reasons that influenced the change in the structure of customs authorities, analyzes the organization of the work of the customs authorities of the Russian Federation in the context of building an integration model of customs administration within the EAEU. Special attention is paid to the issues of digitalization of customs procedures, harmonization of legislation, improvement of control efficiency and simplification of trade operations. Recommendations are offered on optimizing the work of customs authorities to strengthen economic security and promote international trade in the region.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):132-140
132-140
From gang crimes to modern banditry
Abstract
the article considers a retrospective analysis of the development of criminal responsibility for organizing and participating in a gang. The author notes the increased public danger of acts related to joint organized criminal activities, the functioning of which is typical for different eras of the existence of the Russian state. Joint criminal activity in the framework of its development has evolved from simple group crimes, robber gangs, gangs of the imperial period and gangs, in its modern sense. The study analyzes not only the provisions of the legal monuments of the past historical stages, but also the current domestic criminal legislation, highlights common features and differences in the design of gangs and banditry. In addition, separate problems of regulating the crimes under consideration, as well as shortcomings of both previously existing and modern legislation, are highlighted.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):141-148
141-148
Current problems and prospects for the development of apartments in housing relations
Abstract
the development of the real estate market in Russia is accompanied by an increase in demand for new forms of residential facilities, one of which is apartments. Apartments occupy a special place in the structure of residential and non-residential real estate, as they are located on the border of these two categories. In legal and law enforcement practice, there are a significant number of controversial issues related to the legal regulation of apartments, which makes this topic relevant for both researchers and legislators. This article analyzes the current problems of the legal regulation of apartments in housing relations in Russia, conducts a comparative study with foreign legal systems and develops proposals for improving domestic legislation.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):149-154
149-154
The system of countering recidivism in Russia
Abstract
this article begins by stating the great importance of the issue of anti-crime measures. The self-determinative nature of reciprocal criminality is pointed out. It is noted that measures to combat recidivism in Russia are fragmented and sometimes contradictory. All the main stages of the system of countering recidivism are listed. The essence of the term countering recidivism is revealed. The particularly important role of the prevention of recidivism in the system of measures aimed at combating this type of crime is noted. Prevention and prevention of recurrent pregnancy are distinguished. The content of the prevention of recurrent pregnancy is defined more specifically. It is established that the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation is of great importance in the mechanism of preventing recidivism. The suppression of recidivism is defined as the interruption of the objective side of newly committed recidivism. The utopian nature of the complete elimination of recidivism in modern Russian society is shown, but the possibility of taking control of its qualitative and quantitative characteristics, as well as minimizing the harm caused by this type of crime, is noted. There are two main components to minimizing the consequences of recidivism: 1) compensation for property, physical and moral damage caused by recidivism (if, of course, it can be fully compensated); 2) the fact of conviction of a repeat offender, which is expressed in the application of punishment to him, as well as in some cases other measures of a criminal-legal nature. It is noted that the system of countering recidivism has three mandatory elements: 1) object; 2) subject; 3) content. The object of countering recidivism is specified. All the main types of subjects of recurrent pregnancy are listed. The content of recidivism is briefly disclosed. A set of principles is highlighted on which activities to combat recidivism should be based.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):155-161
155-161
On the problem of application of certain types of criminal punishments in Russia
Abstract
the relevance of the article is determined by the constant development of criminal justice, the desire of the state to humanize punishment. The article analyzes the problems of application of various types of criminal punishments in Russia, with an emphasis on punishments related to imprisonment and restriction of rights, in particular arrest and deprivation of the right to engage in certain activities. Based on general and special legal methods of scientific research, an analysis of the theoretical basis and practice of sentencing in the Russian Federation at the present stage is carried out. The article examines the problems of implementing arrest as a punishment measure associated with the lack of the necessary infrastructure for its execution, and also suggests solutions, including reducing the term of arrest and using existing facilities for its detention. It also examines the feasibility of using punishment in the form of deprivation of the right to engage in certain activities for minors. The author argues that, despite the rarity of its use, this punishment should be preserved and reformed, with clarification of the terms and conditions of its application. As a result, amendments to the criminal legislation are proposed aimed at improving law enforcement practice and increasing the effectiveness of punishments.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):162-167
162-167
Formation and development of the institute of proof in the Ancient Russian state
Abstract
the history of the formation of currently valid legal structures is of interest to specialists, since the history of the development of legal institutions is important for their further transformation. Currently, the institution of evidence in the Russian legal system is undergoing another reform process. In the context of the digitalization of society and legal proceedings, evidence is also being transformed into other methods available at present. The investigation of crimes also currently largely depends on the use of digital platforms in the process of proof. In this regard, it is relevant to recall the origins of the formation of proof in the domestic legal system. In the presented article, based on the analysis of the normative acts of the Old Russian state, the authors consider various methods of proving the circumstances of the case under consideration. The research methodology is based on both general scientific and specific scientific research methods, such as formal-legal and comparative-legal research methods. The material of the study was the legal acts of the period of the Old Russian state reflecting the process of proof without dividing into civil and criminal proceedings. In conclusion, the authors come to the conclusion about the transformation of the process of proof during the period of the Old Russian state, show its characteristic features.
International law journal. 2025;8(2):168-173
168-173
