№ 12 (2025)

Мұқаба

Бүкіл шығарылым

ARTICLES

From the concept of financial security by I.I. Kucherov to the modern paradigm of the financial sovereignty of the state: risk management as a key element

Lapina M.

Аннотация

The evolution of the doctrinal foundations for the protection of national financial interests in the context of modern geo-economic challenges has been revealed. The subject of the study is the transformation of the concept of financial security, developed by Professor I.I. Kucherov, into the modern paradigm of financial sovereignty, as well as the key role of risk management as a systemic element ensuring this transformation. The object of the study is the sphere of financial security and the financial sovereignty of the state as interrelated and sequentially developing paradigms. The work analyzes the shift in focus from a protective model aimed at neutralizing threats to a sovereign model affirming the independence of the financial system through the lens of I.I. Kucherov's scientific works, particularly his concept of financial security risks. It is argued that risk management serves as a linking element and transformational mechanism between these two models. The methods and methodology include: comparative analysis for comparing concepts of financial security and financial sovereignty, systemic analysis for studying financial security as a complex phenomenon, structural-functional method for analyzing the interconnections between elements of financial security and financial sovereignty, and a formal-legal method for analyzing regulatory legal acts governing financial security. For the first time, the evolution of I.I. Kucherov's scientific views on financial security risks has been analyzed in the context of their transformation into financial sovereignty risks. The transition from the paradigm of protection to the paradigm of sovereignty has been justified, where risk management becomes a key systemic element. Risk management serves as a linking element between the models, transforming identified threats (for example, the risk of disconnection from SWIFT) into an incentive for creating sovereign instruments (national payment systems and financial messaging systems). A three-stage algorithm for sovereign risk management has been formulated and detailed, which includes predictive assessment, the creation of sovereign neutralization mechanisms, and sovereign legal regulation. An author's concept of a sovereign risk model, adapted to modern geo-economic realities, is introduced into scientific circulation. The practical significance lies in the fact that the proposed algorithm serves as a methodological basis for developing specific measures to strengthen Russia's financial sovereignty in the context of sanctions pressure, and can also be used in the process of strategic planning and the establishment of resilient national financial institutions.
Legal research. 2025;(12):1-9
pages 1-9 views

Traditional Nature Management and Environmental Protection of the North (Part 2)

Kudelkin N.

Аннотация

The subject of this research comprises legal norms pertaining to Indigenous peoples and traditional nature management. The study aims to formulate conclusions and proposals for improving legal regulation in this field, based on an analysis of federal and regional legislation. The research employed general scientific, specific, and specialized methods. The relevance of the study is underscored by the fact that preserving the traditional nature management of Indigenous peoples, and consequently their unique culture, requires not only enhancing legislation on Indigenous peoples but also implementing measures, including legal ones, aimed at environmental protection in the areas where traditional nature management is practiced. The study presents a number of theoretical and practical conclusions and proposals. To enhance the protection of the rights and interests of Indigenous peoples and the environment in territories of traditional nature management (TTNM), it is proposed to elaborate in more detail the legal regime of such territories in Federal Law «On Territories of Traditional Nature Management of Indigenous peoples of the North, Siberia, and the Far East of the Russian Federation» Specifically, the law should specify which types of economic activities are permitted there. Furthermore, the aforementioned law should stipulate the mandatory functional zones to be designated within TTNM boundaries. Given that TTNM can be located in areas with diverse natural characteristics and depending on the main type of traditional nature management practiced, it seems logical to categorize TTNM based on the stringency of their protection regimes. Concurrently, from the standpoint of safeguarding the right to traditional nature management and environmental protection, establishing a legislative priority for traditional nature management over other forms of economic activity appears highly effective. This priority is particularly crucial for types of traditional nature management such as reindeer and horse husbandry, which require vast territories for their practice.
Legal research. 2025;(12):10-20
pages 10-20 views

Transformation of the legal understanding of the tourist product: from unification to differentiated regulation

Sergienko S.

Аннотация

The aim of this study is a methodological analysis of the draft law that changes the concept of "tourist product." In accordance with the chosen goal, the following tasks have been set: to conduct a historical and legal analysis of the formation and development of the concept of "tourist product" and to investigate the content of the draft law aimed at differentiating the concept of "tourist product." The object of the study is the legal regulation of tourism activities in the Russian Federation, in particular – the regulatory framework defining the concept and content of the tourist product (including the Federal Law "On the Basics of Tourism Activities in the Russian Federation" from 1996), as well as draft law No. 918087. The subject of this article is the legal nature of the concept of "tourist product," its evolution, problematic aspects of interpretation and application, as well as the proposed differentiation of the concept with respect to different types of tourism (outbound, domestic, inbound) in the context of current transformational processes in the industry. The methodological basis of the study is formed on the basis of general scientific and special methods of cognition, including historical-legal, systematic, formal-legal, comparative-legal, dialectical methods, as well as the method of legal modeling. The scientific novelty of the research is confirmed by a comprehensive analysis of the legal nature of the tourist product, the development of a methodology for assessing the effectiveness of the differentiation of legal regulation, the identification of potential risks when implementing changes, the formation of a model for improving legal regulation, and the development of practical recommendations for minimizing legal risks. The theoretical significance of the work lies in the development of new approaches to understanding the legal nature of the tourist product in the context of its differentiation. The practical significance of the research consists in determining directions for minimizing legal risks when implementing a differentiated approach and creating a methodological basis for further research on the problems of legal regulation in the tourism sector. The results of the study can be used in the development of new regulatory legal acts in the field of tourism, in the law enforcement practice of government authorities, and in scientific research activities.
Legal research. 2025;(12):21-31
pages 21-31 views

The role of public procurement in financial law

Golomidov Y.

Аннотация

This article is devoted to the examination of the legal regulation of public procurement, namely state and municipal procurements, as well as procurements carried out by certain types of legal entities, and to the theoretical understanding of the place of public procurement in the science of financial law. The object of the research is the social relations that arise during the procurement procedures carried out by state and municipal bodies, organizations operating under public control, and other entities. The subject of the research is the provisions of regulatory legal acts that govern procurement activities. The article thoroughly discusses the categories of public interests and public finances, which served as criteria for defining the types of procurements that fall within the scope of financial law regulation. Special attention is given to the issue of the role of certain public procurements, specifically those carried out by entities with significant public authority participation in their charter capital, within the system of financial law. This research is based on a methodology that includes methods of analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction, as well as the formal-legal method. As a result of the research, the place of public procurements in the legal system and in the system of financial law was determined. The novelty of the research lies in the fact that based on the understanding of doctrinal positions regarding the subject of financial law and its expanded interpretation, as well as the analysis of norms governing the management of legal entities, the inclusion of procurement activities of organizations that operate under the control of public-law entities into the system of financial legal regulation was justified, which will subsequently allow the development of legal regulation of public procurements in this area to enhance the efficiency of public financial expenditures. Additionally, the circle of entities participating in relations arising from procurement procedures and simultaneously falling within the scope of financial law regulation was outlined.
Legal research. 2025;(12):32-45
pages 32-45 views

Legal expertise of regulatory acts in ensuring constitutional-legal communication

Bleshchik A.

Аннотация

The subject of this article is the relationships arising within the system of public authority in connection with the functioning of its individual institutions, also covered by the concept of "constitutional-legal communication." The author proposes to examine the issues of constitutional-legal dialogue within the system of public authority using the example of normative activity, more specifically legislation. Constitutional-legal communication in the system of public authority is carried out using a variety of legal and political instruments, among which legal expertise of regulatory legal acts occupies a special place, representing a stable established legal practice aimed at determining the quality of adopted legal acts. The aim of the research is to describe the parameters of this instrument, to show what functions public authorities can perform by applying legal expertise, and to answer the question of how legal expertise can influence the effectiveness of constitutional-legal communication between public authority institutions. The methodological approach chosen for studying the stated topic is the communicative concept of law, according to which legal reality can be interpreted communicatively. The proposed approach allows for the consideration of familiar legal instruments in a communicative context, revealing the functional characteristics of legal expertise as a tool that ensures constitutional-legal dialogue and communication among legal subjects within the system of public authority. The study of the role of legal expertise in ensuring constitutional-legal communication led to the conclusion that legal expertise serves as a means for public authorities to fulfill various functions, including, in particular, the control (supervisory) function; jurisdictional function; qualifying function; blocking function; and advisory function. Furthermore, it was demonstrated how the practice of legal expertise acts as a way to prevent and resolve disputes arising within the system of public authorities, manifesting itself in four main aspects. 1. By applying legal expertise, subjects of constitutional-legal relations can reasonably express their own legal positions on contentious issues. 2. The tools of legal expertise allow for formulating proposals to overcome constitutional conflicts. 3. The formulation of contradictions occurring during legal expertise is a means of conflict prevention. 4. Legal monitoring and analysis of expert practices enable public authorities to identify and signal potentially conflict-generating areas in advance.
Legal research. 2025;(12):46-55
pages 46-55 views

The use of artificial intelligence systems in the criminal procedure activities of the prosecutor: advantages and disadvantages

Arzumanyan A.

Аннотация

The relevance of this study stems from the growing contradiction between the rapid introduction of artificial intelligence systems into prosecutorial criminal proceedings and the lack of a coherent theoretical and legal model regulating the use of such innovations. This imbalance creates significant risks in the implementation of such fundamental principles of criminal proceedings as legality, adversarial proceedings, and the right to defense. The subject of this study is the complex social relations that develop as prosecutors use artificial intelligence systems in criminal proceedings, as well as the associated legal and organizational issues. The goal of this study is to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of prosecutors' use of artificial intelligence systems in criminal proceedings and, on this basis, to develop scientifically sound proposals for the formation of legal regulation that ensures a balance between technological efficiency and guarantees of individual rights. The author uses comparative legal analysis of international experience, an empirical analysis of the implementation of an AI assistant in the Saratov Region Prosecutor's Office, and a systems and predictive analysis of various aspects of prosecutors' use of artificial intelligence systems in criminal proceedings. The scientific novelty and practical significance of the study are determined by the nature of the conducted analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of using artificial intelligence systems in the prosecutor's work. The conclusions and proposals are based not only on theoretical research, but also on direct experience in using AI assistants in law enforcement practice. Based on the results of the study, proposals are presented for integrating into the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation the norms on the legal status of the results of the use of artificial intelligence, the procedure for recording and appealing them. The need to consolidate special requirements for the processing, storage, and transmission of data used for training and in the operation of artificial intelligence systems in criminal proceedings is noted. It is proposed to adopt a law on the use of AI by government agencies, which would establish requirements for the presence of a detailed logical report function in AI systems developed for criminal proceedings; on training government AI systems on verified and up-to-date national databases; on the implementation of mandatory state control.
Legal research. 2025;(12):56-71
pages 56-71 views

The transformation of the right to informational self-determination in the era of artificial intelligence and other digital technologies: challenges and prospects

Chereshneva I.

Аннотация

The purpose of the study is to examine the transformation of the right to informational self-determination, first articulated in the practice of the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, into the right to digital self-determination as one of the new generation digital human rights, the provision of which requires legal mechanisms in line with the spirit of the times, including institutional ones. In the context of the development of artificial intelligence and other digital technologies that are taking on the nature of de facto coercion (the concept of "code is law"), the issue of ensuring the right to digital self-determination becomes particularly relevant, as autonomy, freedom, and human dignity are "at stake." In this regard, the paper presents the main challenges faced in the implementation of the right to digital self-determination and outlines potential ways to overcome them. The study employs the following methods of scientific cognition: analysis, synthesis, generalization, analogy, and others; and applies a systemic approach, as well as specialized legal and comparative legal methods. During the research, the author arrives at the following conclusions: 1) the right to informational self-determination, based on the idea of dignity and personal autonomy, undergoes a qualitative restructuring under the conditions of digitalization, transforming into the right to digital self-determination—a new generation digital human right; 2) the key challenges to the realization of the right to digital self-determination include information asymmetry, the limited informed consent of data subjects, the paradox of confidentiality, insufficient levels of digital literacy, and the increasing manipulative potential of algorithmic systems; 3) considering the data subject as the economically and technologically weaker party in information interactions with digital platforms requires the state to provide additional guarantees to protect the rights and legitimate interests of data subjects; 4) ensuring the right to digital self-determination implies the formation of a comprehensive system of legal mechanisms, including regulation of algorithmic systems based on principles of algorithmic transparency and accountability; restriction of manipulative technologies and surveillance; expansion and specification of the rights of data subjects, as well as the establishment of additional obligations for large digital platforms.
Legal research. 2025;(12):72-82
pages 72-82 views

Scope of application as a criterion for classifying the principles of civil procedural law

Pleshanov A.

Аннотация

The subject of the research is one of the key problems in the theory of principles of civil procedural law – the problem of their classification. The novelty of the study lies in the fact that the classification of principles by scope of action is considered through the prism of justifying civil procedural law as an independent branch, which includes three sub-branches: civil procedural law, arbitration procedural law, and administrative procedural law. The research focuses on the works of scholars in the field of civil procedure dedicated to the theory of principles of civil procedural law, as well as the norms of procedural (civil, arbitration, and administrative) legislation, through which the principles of civil procedural law are directly and indirectly enshrined. Special attention is paid to analyzing the state of procedural doctrine regarding principles that express the legal uniqueness of the branch of civil procedural law, principles that determine the specifics of individual institutions of this branch, as well as the correlation of these principles with each other. The methodological framework of the research consists of the following methods: analysis, synthesis, systemic-structural, formal-logical, theoretical-forecasting, comparative-legal, interpretation of legal norms. The main conclusions drawn from the research are as follows. The scope of action retains its significance as a central criterion for classifying principles, through which the principles expressing the specificity of the subject of regulation, such as civil procedure, are brought into a legally and logically coherent system. From the perspective of the identification function of principles, the scope of action, as a classification criterion, has three aspects (forms of expression): 1) procedural law as a collection of two fundamentally different in legal nature procedural branches (criminal procedural law and civil procedural law); 2) civil procedural law as a kind of mega-branch, the subject of regulation of which is the administration of justice in civil matters in the broadest sense (civil, administrative, and economic dispute cases), that is, civil procedure; 3) the institution of civil procedural law.
Legal research. 2025;(12):83-101
pages 83-101 views

The use of artificial intelligence in crime prevention through forensic means

Zhuzhlov I.

Аннотация

The subject of the research is the methods and techniques for applying artificial intelligence (AI) as a forensic tool in crime prevention. The object of the research is the activities of law enforcement agencies and departments aimed at preventing criminal activities. The objective of the article is to analyze the possibilities of applying AI as a forensic tool for crime prevention, as well as to develop recommendations for optimizing and integrating AI-based systems into Russian law enforcement practice. The article examines various approaches to defining artificial intelligence, its key features, and characteristics. It analyzes the potential for implementing methods and techniques based on AI technologies for crime prevention. Special emphasis is placed on technologies such as predictive analytics, natural language processing, facial and image recognition systems, decision support systems, and digital evidence analysis. The research is accompanied by practical examples illustrating the capabilities of AI technologies in the process of crime prevention. The article considers both foreign and Russian experiences in using AI technologies for crime prevention. General scientific and specialized scientific methods of cognition were used in the research. The comparative law method was applied to study the experiences of foreign countries. The formal-legal method was utilized to examine the main approaches to defining the concept of AI and its characteristics. The method of state and legal modeling was used to mentally create models for the use of AI technologies. The relevance of the research is justified by the fact that modern AI technologies, including machine learning, big data analysis, natural language processing, and computer vision, provide new opportunities for analyzing criminal patterns, predicting potential threats, and improving the efficiency of law enforcement agencies. All these technologies are currently being actively implemented and have significant potential for enhancing the activities of law enforcement in crime prevention, as well as for the development of forensic science as a whole. As a result of the research, approaches to understanding AI were examined, the methods and key AI-based technologies used or potentially usable for crime prevention purposes were studied, and the ways of application and prospects of using AI-based technologies in the practical activities of law enforcement agencies were described.
Legal research. 2025;(12):102-119
pages 102-119 views

The historical rationale for the norm of justified risk in the criminal legislation of Russia

Alhaeva T.

Аннотация

The subject of this study is the genesis of justified risk in the legal system of Russia as a circumstance excluding the criminality of an act. The underutilization of the norm of justified risk in investigative and judicial practice throughout the entire period of its establishment in criminal law, the lack of statistical reporting, as well as the overview of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on the application of the provisions of Article 41 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, combined with the historical events of the early 1990s that had a direct impact on the legal system of Russia, underscores the relevance of this research. The goal of the study is to determine the justification for supplementing the criminal law with the norm of justified risk through studying and understanding its genesis in the criminal law legislation of Russia. The author examines the main stages in the formation of the risk institute in direct correlation with the historical events accompanying each particular stage. The methodological foundation is presented by universal dialectics, as well as a combination of general scientific methods (analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction) and specific scientific methods (historical-legal, formal-legal, structural-functional). As a result of the conducted research, the author substantiates the following conclusion: the legislative recognition and establishment of justified risk in the list of circumstances excluding the criminality of an act is not the result of a fundamental revision of the legal system of Russia due to the change of government in the early 1990s; the genesis of justified risk was accompanied by a prolonged process of its emergence and development within social relations, investigative and judicial practice, and criminal law doctrine. The reason for the underutilization of this legal norm is not the absence of actions to which the provisions of Article 41 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation should apply, but rather the accumulation of a significant array of theoretical and practical problems that hinder the "free" reference to the provisions of the studied criminal legal norm in the process of law enforcement activities.
Legal research. 2025;(12):120-128
pages 120-128 views

Jurilinguistic convergence in the analysis of manipulative speech strategies of pseudo-healers: suggestive potential and legal risks

Asadov R.

Аннотация

The subject of the research is manipulative speech strategies used by quacks during suggestive influence on citizens, as well as their legal consequences in the context of contemporary Russian practices against fraud. The analysis focuses on the mechanisms of suggestion that create a distorted picture of reality for the recipient and subordinate their behavior to models constructed by the performer. The study covers lexical, semantic, and pragmatic characteristics of the relevant texts that determine the structure of speech influence. Special attention is given to the legal assessment of such impacts, including the complexity of proving intent, establishing a causal link between verbal pressure and property damage, and identifying markers significant for qualifying actions under Article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. The subject of the research integrates linguistic, psychological, and normative aspects, allowing for a multidimensional understanding of the nature of quackery as a socially dangerous phenomenon. The methodology of the research relies on jurilinguistic analysis, which includes a cognitive-discursive approach, elements of psycholinguistics, comparative-legal method, and linguo-pragmatic description of suggestive strategies identified in judicial and communicative practices. The scientific novelty of the research lies in justifying jurilinguistic convergence as an effective tool for analyzing the manipulative speech strategies of quacks, based on suggestive mechanisms that create a cognitively distorted perception of risk and opportunities for the recipient. The study proposes a comprehensive typology of linguistic and pragmatic markers relevant for qualifying actions under Article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation for the first time, as well as identifying criteria that allow for the distinction of suggestive impact from traditional forms of deception. It concludes that it is necessary to consider the dynamics of verbal pressure and emotional-psychological factors when assessing intent and the social danger of actions. The practical significance of developing jurilinguistic expertise and improving legal regulation aimed at identifying and suppressing pseudo-medical activities that use suggestion as a means of obtaining material benefits is emphasized.
Legal research. 2025;(12):129-143
pages 129-143 views

Legal regulation of restrictions on the amount of success fees as a method of determining the cost of legal services

Vyimow I.

Аннотация

The article is devoted to a comprehensive analysis of the issue of possible limitations on the amount of success fees as a way to determine the cost of legal services. It explores the genesis of legal regulation regarding quantitative limits on the cost of legal services and identifies two approaches of responsible judicial practice concerning the possibility of reducing the success fee stipulated in a legal services contract. From the perspective of the need to protect the interests of the weaker party, the question of the legal necessity to depart from the principle of freedom of contract regarding the introduction of any limitations on the amount of success fees is considered. In the context of foreign experience and doctrine, possible ways to address the problem of establishing and paying success fees that are clearly excessive are analyzed. The subject of the study is the methods of protecting the weaker party in the contract from paying success fees that are excessive and obviously unjustified. The aim of the research is to form a comprehensive scientific understanding of the legal regulation of quantitative limits on success fees. The research employs general scientific methods such as analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction, and systematization, as well as specific legal methods of cognition, including legal interpretation, comparative legal method, and historical-legal method. The scientific novelty of the study is expressed in the systematic generalization of possible ways to solve the problem of payments of success fees in clearly unreasonable amounts. The effectiveness of potential consolidation of such methods has been analyzed. The necessity of introducing into Russian practice a method allowing courts, in exceptional cases, to reduce success fees is justified. A critical analysis is conducted on the possible borrowing of foreign experience regarding the establishment of specific quantitative limits on success fees, as well as merely stipulating the obligation of the performer not to accept fees in unreasonable amounts. The author proposes to directly enshrine in legislation the authority of courts to reduce the amount of success fees to realize the formulated approach. At the level of the position of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, it should be clarified how and in what cases the court can implement such a possibility. Thus, the court should have the right to reduce the success fee in cases where it is obvious that any reasonable participant in the transaction would not agree to the success fee established in the contract and only upon the request of the client.
Legal research. 2025;(12):144-160
pages 144-160 views

The history of risk development in the civil process (from ancient Rus to the Soviet period)

Suleimanov A.

Аннотация

Currently, proceduralists are showing a growing interest in complex and multifaceted concepts, one of which is the category of "risk." However, the lack of due attention to its historical development prevents a full assessment of this category. This circumstance influences the choice of the subject and method of research. The subject of this article is to identify the essence of the category of "risk" in civil procedure, as well as to analyze its reflection and application in the history of Russian legislation with the principle of optionality. To reveal the subject of the study, the author refers to the opinions of ancient philosophers, according to which the approach to risk can be expressed both subjectively (awareness of future consequences and the ability to influence circumstances before they occur) and objectively (the occurrence of consequences regardless of the will of the person). The research method is a comprehensive historical and legal analysis, covering the period of legislative provisions from the Russian Pravda to the norms of Soviet codes, since the development of the doctrine of risk, in particular its historical aspect, forms the basis of this study. The value of this study lies in clarifying the relationship between the category under study and the principle of optionality. The importance of consolidating this conclusion is necessary to explain the reasons for the courts' application of this category when shifting risk to one of the parties in both adversarial and inquisitorial proceedings. Consequently, the significance of confirming this conclusion is aimed at studying the emergence of risk factors and the expected negative consequences of this category in the history of legal proceedings. In the course of this study, the author concludes that the process of legislative improvement has contributed to a shift in the primary approach to risk from an objective to a subjective one. This is reflected in the fact that, during the period of Old Russian legislation, means of proof (trials by fire, water, and the "field" competition) influenced the occurrence of the corresponding result. However, subsequent legislative statutes partially or fully reflected the impact of the subjective approach on risk. The subjective approach is reflected in norms devoted to concluding a settlement agreement, bad faith behavior of a party when filing a claim or during court proceedings, judicial notice, and other matters over which a person could influence. By determining that subjective risk could exist in both investigative and adversarial proceedings, the author confirms the conclusion that the category of “risk” is associated with the principle of discretion, according to which a person could influence the occurrence of the desired result for him.
Legal research. 2025;(12):161-178
pages 161-178 views

Согласие на обработку персональных данных

 

Используя сайт https://journals.rcsi.science, я (далее – «Пользователь» или «Субъект персональных данных») даю согласие на обработку персональных данных на этом сайте (текст Согласия) и на обработку персональных данных с помощью сервиса «Яндекс.Метрика» (текст Согласия).