Vol 1, No 2 (2020)
PHILOSOPHY
Functioning of the P. Ricoeur's mimetic circle in the various narrative representations of the past
Abstract
Scholar’sand mythological historical narratives coexist independently, but now they have been increasingly confused. To find ways to compare them and highlight the properties which distinguish them, weturn to P. Ricoeur'sconcept of triple mimesis. Narratives are cognitive tools, so they are almost omnipresent. Since there is nothing in the narrative that would distinguish one type from another, it is necessary to pay attention to how they function, to the ways of representing reality that use different types of narratives. For this, the article uses the concept of P. Ricoeur'smimetic circle, which takes into account not only the narrative dimension itself, but also its “depth”, the degree of approximation to reality.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):5-19
5-19
The First Philosophy of E. Husserl in the Context of Phenomenology as a Science
Abstract
The article examines the problem of the relationship between critical and dogmatic types of thinking in the context of the project of scientific philosophy created by Husserl. The point of view is expressed according to which the program of science teaching of Husserl was not completed at the end of the descriptive stage, but, on the contrary, was continued and expanded at the stage of transcendental phenomenology. Based on the material of the firs part of the lectures “First Philosophy” belonging to this stage, it is demonstrated how Husserl, with the helpo historical-eidetic reduction and the concept of the unity of motivation, outlines the way for the “naïve” philosopher to master the principles of critical thinking. These principles, coupled with phenomenological reduction, form a specia disposition of the dogmatic and the critical in the project of phenomenology as a rigorous science, where the dogmatic and the critical merge into the fundamental requirement of the philosopher'sself-reflection and responsibility.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):20-27
20-27
A Feature of the Conception Inheritance in the Eleatic School of Philosophy
Abstract
The purpose of the paper is to identify common theses supposedly shared by Parmenides and Zeno of Elea. In order to achieve this goal, weshow that an alternative interpretation of the aporia from 29 B 1 DK is possible, in which wedon’tdeal with an infinite division of an extended being, butwe deal with a regression of relations of an arbitrary type. These relations are connecting an arbitrary type of constituents of a complex object. In this case, the aporia proves the impossibility of a complex object of any type, not just the impossibility of an extended object. Finally, weshow that interpreted in this way Zeno’sreasoning from 29 B 1 DK, and appropriately interpreted Parmenides’ proofs of the unity of being in 28 B 8 DK can be treated as based on a holistic assumption. This enables usto assert that Zeno was the successor of Parmenides, not only in the sense that hewas indirectly proving Parmenides’ thesis of the unity of being, but also in the sense that hewas using a statement that Parmenides could imply.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):28-51
28-51
Form and Formal Approaches in the History of Philosophy and Today
Abstract
The concept of form and its derivations belong to the most important concepts of Antiquity and Middle Ages. Modern formal approaches in logic, semantics etc. depend on this problematics, rarely exposing it to scientific scrutiny. The article deals with a way medieval discussions on form and essence are reflected in contemporary approaches to formalisation, resulting in the confrontation between substantialist and constructivist paradigms.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):52-59
52-59
In favour of analytic phenomenology of time
Abstract
The article considers analytic phenomenology of time as a most hopeful way for studying temporal structure of consciousness. In order to demonstrate advantage of this area webriefly outline the main methods of research of time consciousness and time perception, clarify connection between analytic philosophy and phenomenology and turn to contemporary research of temporal consciousness structure. We can mention F. Varela, S. Gallagher, E. Pöppel, H. Maturana, E. Knyazeva as proponents of analytic phenomenology, who have already performed outstanding results. Thus, it is through the analytic phenomenology of time wecan study temporal structure of consciousness using logical methods, system and analytical approach without excluding phenomenological and neurophenomenological researches.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):60-69
60-69
Pairs of Arguments (Dissoi logoi)
Abstract
The paper is a Russian translation of the first three chapters of a sophistic text, conventionally called the Pairs of Arguments (Dissoi logoi). Transmitted as an appendix to the works of Sextus Empiricus, this collection of short treaties seeks to show the sophistic (Protagorean) way of argumentation. They address such opposite notions as bad and good, ugly and beautiful, unjust and just, and explore the possibilities of arguing pro and contra a given position.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):70-78
70-78
Foundations of Relativism by J. Margolis in the Polemic of R. Rorty and H. Putnam
Abstract
The polemic about the realism of H. Putnam and R. Rorty is a remarkable event of the 20th century for a number of reasons. Forming within the analytical philosophy, and using the most relevant concepts and ideas of this direction as arguments, this polemic for almost three decades of its existence balanced on the border with relativism, the least popular and admited direction of philosophy of the 20th century. Putnam'sarguments against metaphysical realism reject any "point of view of God", entail "internalism", accept the concept of incommensurability of conceptual schemes and the relativization the reality described by the epistemic agent to his experience. Rorty'sarguments reject not only relativism, but also realism, but his concepts of ethnocentrism and solidarity also take the view that the standards of truth correlate with the conceptual schemes, are "sociologized" and meet the interests of the majority. J. Margolis find in this polemic not only a retreat into relativism, but also recognized its pragmatistic potential, which gave him the opportunity to defend relativism, proposing its reliable (robust) version and building a neo-pragmatist philosophy on the development of the arguments of both sides.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):79-87
79-87
Wittgenstein on Intention and Theory of Action
Abstract
In the articlewe examine Wittgenstein'snotes on several action theories in general context of intentional states. We show (based on the articles of Michael Scott) that the kinesthetic theory of action and theories of innervation, which were the object of criticism of Wittgenstein, donot play an essential role for understanding Wittgenstein'stexts and therefore in this case the influence of historical and philosophical reconstruction on the understanding of Wittgenstein'scorresponding notes can be considered insignificant. Late Wittgenstein'stexts are directed against comparatively universal methodological and metaphysical principles. And therefore, criticism of theories of action can only serve as an optional illustration and an optional precondition for interpretation and understanding.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):88-94
88-94
Institutionalization of a philosophical school: the origins of Justus Lipsius’ neostoicism
Abstract
The article is devoted to the consideration of the neostoicism of Justus Lipsius (1547–1606) in order to show that there is a set of reasons for the renovation and institutionalization of any philosophical school: the historical context, education, community, personality and biography of its leader. As for Justus Lipsius, a philologist and publisher of ancient texts (Tacitus, Seneca), the following factors influenced. Since Lipsius lived in turbulent times (the 16th century was marked by the Reformation and religious wars), hecould not help but pay attention to Stoic philosophy, designed to give peace of mind in an unsettled world. Lipsius received an excellent education at a Jesuit college and at two universities – Cologne and Louvain. He was instilled in a love of ancient literature during his education, which predetermined his work. He was an outstanding person by nature and was formed in the university environment and in the intellectual circles of his time. He was, for instance, a member of the Familists, whose founder taught, among other things, the permissibility of changing denominations. Lipsius’sinterpretation of the Stoic doctrine suggests that the Stoics came closest to Christianity, unlike other ancient philosophers. All these factors determined the revival of Stoicism in the 16th century.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):95-101
95-101
Prodicus of Ceos. Fragments and Testimonia
Abstract
Prodicus of Ceos was rightfully considered one of the most famous sophists of his time. His interest in language learning, which resulted in a method of comparing synonymous words to determine their exact meaning and identify differences, may have been due to the skepticism of his contemporaries about what can be considered real as well as a form of moral relativism, arising from such views. One may say that Prodicus had a profound influence on Socrates, and his insistence on identifying differences between words of almost identical meaning prompted Socrates to adopt his own approach to philosophy, centered on precise definitions of various moral issues. The present publication contains a collection of scant doxographic evidence about Prodicus’ life and writings.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):102-119
102-119
SOCIOLOGY
Formation of life support systems for rural ethno-local communities in the context of modernization (on the example of ethno-local communities of Tatars in the Novosibirsk region)
Abstract
Based on the materials of field research of ethnolocal communities of Tatars living compactly in rural areas of the Novosibirsk region the features of their economic adaptation to the processes of social modernization are considered. The characteristics of the main elements of the modern life support system are given, and the regularities of its transformation are revealed. It is concluded that the basic principle of formation of life support systems in rural ethno-local communities of Tatars at the present stage is the diversification of economic practices. It manifests itself as a combination of the maximum number of available modern and traditional practices, which allows the community to adapt to regularly changing conditions. At the same time, the entire structure of economic practices is in the process of continuous transformation.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):120-132
120-132
The present and the future of Russian higher education shown through university typology
Abstract
In the article, through the study of various typologies of universities, the current state and the future of Russian higher education are assessed. There are different approaches to the classification of higher education institutions: classical, which views the university through the history; an approach that systematizes higher education institutions by belonging to a particular cultural tradition; economic approach. The authors of the typologies offer two opposite points of view regarding the future of the Russian university. According to the first point of view, the existing university system must be completely reformed. Supporters of the second one suggest adjusting the existing system to the requirements of modern society. Due to the analysis, weconcluded that a hybrid option is more suitable for Russia, in which gradual changes allow preserving the advantages of Russian education and minimize the disadvantages.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):133-140
133-140
Private universities and elite formation in Russia: Yakut case
Abstract
The article is devoted to the problem of functioning of private universities in society, determining their place in the educational process. A parallel is drawn with the work of private educational institutions in the United States, which have a glorious history of development dating back to the XVII century. The author of the article relies on the analysis of special literature on this issue, identifies success factors of American universities and “failure factors” of private universities in Yakutia, and also refers to a large-scale sociological study of graduates of the M. K. Ammosov North-Eastern Federal University. Research conducted under his leadership (Yakutsk, 469 respondents, 2016, 2017, 2018). The Author concludes that the history of private universities in Russia, which began in the 90s of the twentieth century, is quite dramatic. Branches of the capital'sprivate universities operating in the province are at the greatest disadvantage today. The current situation requires a detailed sociological analysis, a comparative analysis of the performance of public and private universities and identification of the pros and cons of non-state universities on this basis, in order to develop recommendations for correcting the situation.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):141-149
141-149
INTERDISCIPLINARY RESEARCH
Tengrism and Dual Faith of the Turkic-Mongolian Peoples
Abstract
The article is dedicated to the analysis of the spread of Buddhism, Christianity and Islam among the Turkic-Mongol peoples that have originally professed Tengrism. Contemporary revival of Tengrism manifests itself both institutionally (via state and public support) and in everyday practice as the continuation of a living cultural tradition that has been passed down from generation to generation for a millennia and has been seen as a worldview, a way of life and a life guidance. The author concludes that Tengrism has ensured preservation of identity, stability and integrity of the Turkic-Mongolian world within the phenomenon of dual faith, while the spread of Buddhism, Christianity and Islam have set the dynamics of its development on the basis of intercivilizational interaction.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):150-165
150-165
The Invisible Opponent: A Hidden Discussion in a Linguistic Popular Science Article
Abstract
This article is devoted to the description of the linguistic means by which the author of a popular science article introduces into it the position of an “inexperienced reader”. Six popular science articles on linguistic topics were used as a source of material for the research. With the methods of studies of reference, semantic syntax and poetics of a literary text, the techniques of introducing an ordinary worldview of the “invisible opponent” of the author-scientist (or a knowledgeable journalist) were analyzed, in which the author represents a potential inexperienced reader of the article. As a result of the study, it was found that the authors use various means of implicitness, including presuppositions, implicit change of point of view, games with the reference of pronouns and nouns, in order to solve a complex collision of the “addressee factor”: criticizing the views that form the reader'severyday picture of the world, donot present explicit the reader himself as his opponent.
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):166-183
166-183
Articles
Requirements for Article Design
Respublica Literaria. 2020;1(2):184-194
184-194

