No 6 (2025)
Articles
Soviet-Algerian Relations from 1968 to 1976 (Based on materials from the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs archive)
Abstract
The article presents the perspective of French diplomats on the evolution of relations between the USSR and the People's Democratic Republic of Algeria in the late 1960s and the first half of the 1970s. Despite Algeria gaining independence from France in 1962, Paris continued to view the young Arab country as within its sphere of interest and closely monitored the growing influence of Moscow in Algeria. The author consistently shows that the foundation of Soviet-Algerian relations was cooperation in the military sphere. Algeria was one of the African countries where Soviet military specialists worked on a permanent basis. Algerian military personnel, including the officer corps, underwent military training in the USSR. Moscow carried out large-scale arms supplies to Algeria. The article is based on documents from the French Foreign Ministry archives, a significant portion of which is introduced into scholarly circulation for the first time. It mainly concerns diplomatic reports and analytical notes prepared at the French embassy in Algeria. A notable intensification of Soviet-Algerian relations occurred in the mid-1970s in connection with the escalation of the conflict between Algeria and Morocco over Western Sahara and the onset of the Angolan conflict. The scale of Soviet arms supplies to Algeria significantly increased during this time. However, in the economic sphere, the USSR noticeably lagged behind Western countries in the competition for the Algerian market, which initially had stronger positions in the region and remained the main buyers of Algerian hydrocarbons. Overall, under conditions of limited economic capabilities, the USSR pursued a cautious and pragmatic policy in Algeria. The skillful use by Moscow of the mistakes made by Western countries with respect to Algeria, as well as the successful work of Soviet mass media in Algeria, allowed the Soviet Union to gradually develop its relations with the young Arab country.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):1-13
1-13
At the Origins of International Cooperation Among Geocryologists: From the History of the Formation of Connections Between Soviet Permafrost Researchers and North American Scientists in the 1960s
Abstract
This study is dedicated to creating a cohesive scientific representation of the initial stage of the development of contacts between scientists from the USSR, the USA, and Canada in the field of permafrost research and the exchange of scientific and practical experience in the development of territories located in the cryolithozone. In this regard, the purpose of the work is to reconstruct the history of the establishment of scientific ties between Soviet geocryologists and their colleagues from North American research centers in the 1960s, as well as to determine the main forms of development and results of this process. The relevance of this issue is emphasized, first, by the existing gap in historiography, and second, by the current geopolitical situation. It appears that the reconstruction of examples from the past, demonstrating the possibilities and role of scientific connections in establishing contacts between countries at odds in military-political and financial-economic relations, could serve as one of the drivers for the gradual "reset" of international relations in the modern world. The development of the topic is based on documents identified in the archives of the Russian Academy of Sciences and the Scientific Archive of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. In processing these documents, mainly historical methods of scientific knowledge were employed: the principle of historicism, historical-typological, historical-comparative, and historical-genetic methods. As a result of the conducted research, a coherent scientific representation of the history of the establishment of international ties among Soviet, American, and Canadian permafrost researchers in the 1960s has been created for the first time in historiography. In this context, the history of joint initiatives realized during this period has been reconstructed. It is noted that despite the limited nature of cooperation, the first experience of interaction demonstrated in this article was a significant step forward and subsequently led to a considerable intensification of international ties among permafrost researchers. During the examined period, this experience was represented by participation in international forums held in the USA and the USSR, as well as by reciprocal familiarization trips of geocryologists, which effectively took the form of internships, facilitating the exchange of scientific and practical experience regarding the consideration of the permafrost factor in the development of Arctic and Subarctic territories. The role of the director of the Institute of Permafrost Studies, P.I. Melnikov, in developing international scientific ties is also highlighted.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):14-23
14-23
Staffing the "Shock Therapy" Program in Russia in 1991
Abstract
This study examines how the specific principle of personnel selection for the reformist government influenced the development of Russia's "shock therapy" program in 1991. This principle was presented as technocratic, implying that individuals were chosen for managerial positions based on professional merit rather than political affiliation. In reality, the team of reformers was united by the idea of a rapid transition to a market economy, intended to lead the country out of an economic crisis. The research attempts to assess the administrative and managerial consequences of appointing a team of external specialists and the role of their economic views in designing the program of economic transformation. The theoretical framework aims to reveal the advantages and disadvantages of this personnel approach in forming government structures. The study employs formal logic and relies on a set of general scientific (analysis, synthesis) and historical (historical-legal and historical-systemic) methods. Its scholarly novelty is determined by the problem's formulation and the introduction of previously unused sources into academic discourse. An analysis of administrative documents, memoirs, and media materials has revealed significant internal processes and relationships within government structures and the professional community. It is shown that in recruiting personnel for the administrative and intellectual support of the reform, Gaidar could rely only on a relatively small number of research institutes and a narrow group of foreign advisors. The subsequent course of developing and implementing the reforms intensified conflict between the government team and the professional community, leading to the ideological isolation of the reformers. The associated labor shortage necessitated a focus on the most critical aspects of "shock therapy." Efforts to control its implementation were hampered by a lack of administrative-managerial experience, time, attention, and coordination between the government's economic bloc and other state bodies. While the ideological cohesion of the small circle of reformers facilitated the implementation of economic transformations amidst large-scale resistance, it simultaneously hindered the construction of a market economy in its intended form.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):24-33
24-33
Folklore as a Key to the Interpretation of Museum Objects: The Example of Costume Complexes of the Kryashens of Bashkortostan
Abstract
The subject of this article's research is a comprehensive study of the traditional costume of the Kryashens of Bashkortostan as a multilayered socio-cultural phenomenon, reconstructed through the analysis of song folklore. The focus is not only on the material component—cut, crafting techniques, typology, and decorative elements of clothing—but also on its symbolic code, reflected in the texts and contexts of folk songs. The study aims to identify the profound interconnections between the material world of the costume and its figurative-symbolic embodiment in musical and poetic creativity. Thus, the subject of research encompasses a wide range of questions at the intersection of material and spiritual culture, where the costume complex is analyzed not as a static artifact but as a dynamic component of the cultural system, whose meaning and semantics are revealed in the process of their verbal and vocal reproduction within the folk tradition. The work is based on an interdisciplinary approach utilizing principles of historicism, cultural studies, sociology, ethnology, art studies, folklore studies, and others. The following methods are employed in the study: comparative-historical, systemic, and typological. Among the general scientific methods, observation, analysis, and synthesis were used. Field research includes the method of participant observation as well as the survey method. The relevance of this topic is determined by the need for a comprehensive study of the cultural heritage of small peoples, as costume complexes, being a vivid manifestation of traditional culture, can serve as a key to understanding the worldview, religion, and ways of life of the Kryashens. Folklore sources provide valuable information about the forms, colors, decorations, and purposes of costumes, preserving the living memory of the culture of past generations. This work is the first step in scientific research on the formulated topic, and thus the task was set, firstly, to analyze the traditional costume complex of the Kryashens, and secondly, to trace how the objects of everyday and festive clothing are reflected in song culture. The scientific novelty of the presented research lies in the development and testing of an integrative methodology that synthesizes the tools of ethnography, folklore studies, and the semiotics of culture for a comprehensive analysis of the costume complexes of the Kryashens. Additionally, for the first time, a corpus of folklore texts (songs, ritual melodies) is introduced into scientific circulation, systematized and analyzed specifically as a source for reconstructing the semantics and functions of traditional clothing.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):34-47
34-47
The influence of the "guarantee agreement" issue on the dynamics of Soviet-Estonian relations in the 1920s-1930s
Abstract
The subject of the research is the characteristics of Soviet-Estonian relations in connection with the problem of ensuring the security of Northwestern Russia during the interwar period. Throughout the 1920s, the Soviet leadership regularly proposed to Estonia to discuss the issue of concluding a bilateral non-aggression pact (or "guarantee treaty," as this project was referred to until 1932), as well as ensuring mutual neutrality. The results of the Locarno Conference of 1925, which did not guarantee the borders of Germany's eastern neighbors, made this issue particularly important for the security of the northwestern borders of the Soviet state. On November 28, 1923, a draft of the relevant "guarantee" agreement was sent to the Estonian government through the Soviet envoy in Estonia, L.N. Stark. In May 1926, the Estonian government officially expressed its agreement with the USSR's proposal to conclude this treaty. However, due to pressure on Estonia from Poland, official negotiations only began in October 1926 and were accompanied by serious difficulties. As a result, in June 1927, the negotiations were interrupted. The Estonian side would only propose to resume them in December 1931, which took place on January 20, 1932. During the work, the author relied on a wide range of published and archival sources on the studied issue. The research employed the method of diachronic analysis and the historical-comparative method. The scientific novelty of the presented work lies in the systematic analysis of key aspects of Soviet-Estonian relations in the 1920s and 1930s, related to the issues of ensuring regional security in Northwestern Russia. The conclusion drawn is that the development of Soviet-Estonian relations occurred against the backdrop of increasing military-political tension in Europe, which directly affected the bilateral relations between the USSR and Estonia during the studied period. After the failure of the Eastern Pact idea, the danger of Nazi expansion to the east and northeast, including through the Baltic states, increased. In these conditions, taking into account the entire set of analyzed factors, the content of Soviet foreign policy towards Estonia changed.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):48-57
48-57
Contours of Little Tataria: On the Issue of the Formation of the Political Map of the Crimean Khanate in the XV – Mid XVI Century
Abstract
The article is dedicated to the study of the formation of the political map of the Crimean Khanate, often referred to in historical cartography as Little Tartary, which is why the title of the work is chosen. The research attempts to shed light on the process of establishing the political borders of the state in the context of military-diplomatic competition in the steppe and with diverse economic populations. The chronological framework is determined by the period from the mid-15th century to the mid-16th century, marking the time of the highest power of the Khanate. As a result, the core of the source base consists of materials from diplomatic documentation, Lithuanian metrics, and khan's decrees. In order to provide a detailed examination of the problem, data from narrative and cartographic sources were also included. Alongside this, publications by domestic historians were utilized. The work is built on the principles of historicism and complex analysis, including comparative-historical methods. The methods used enabled the comparison of data obtained from different sources. The scientific novelty primarily lies in the fact that, despite the general familiarity with the sources, their consideration and use within historical geography research have not been the subject of independent study. The documents are one of the most important sources, as cartographic materials provide only static information, whereas written sources allow for an attempt to reconstruct the borders of the Crimean Khanate. The dynamism and instability of borders are explained by military-diplomatic confrontations in the steppes of the Northern Black Sea region, as well as the very culture of nomadic society, where the border is not a line on a map but a specific controlled zone. During the study, we reached the following conclusions: 1. The assertion that borders effectively dissolved in the steppe, based on cartographic materials, does not entirely reflect reality. The reconstruction of borders based on written sources reveals a different model of border delineation. Instead of a demarcation line, it is a zone of interaction delineated by areas of influence, where the nomadic groups were located (Bujak, Kuban, and the Dnipro-Don forest-steppe). The next thesis concerns inconsistencies regarding territorial possessions; specifically, according to the titles of the Crimean khans, all power over the former territory of the Golden Horde was in their hands, which did not reflect actual military-political control.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):58-71
58-71
The archaeological collection of the Museum of Archaeology and Ethnography of the IEE RAS: history of formation from the 1970s to the 2020s
Abstract
The subject of this research is the archaeological collection of the Museum of Archaeology and Ethnography of the Institute of Ethnological Studies named after R.G. Kuzeyev of the Ural Federal Scientific Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences, which will celebrate its 50th anniversary in 2026. The focus of the study is the history of its formation through collections compiled as a result of archaeological field research (excavations and surveys) conducted in the Southern Ural region. The aim of the research is to systematize and summarize all available information about the history of the formation of the archaeological fund of the Museum of Archaeology and Ethnography from the founding of the museum to the present day. Special attention is given to the contributions of all Soviet and Russian archaeologists whose research has resulted in valuable materials on the history of the Southern Ural region from the Paleolithic era to modern times being deposited in the storage facilities of the Museum of Archaeology and Ethnography. A comprehensive approach was employed in the study, based on archival, historical-comparative, and quantitative methods. For the first time, based on existing literature, data from the Scientific Archive of the Ural Federal Scientific Center, and internal museum documentation of the Museum of Archaeology and Ethnography, the history of the formation of its archaeological fund has been examined, starting from the museum’s founding in the 1970s to the present day. The names of all researchers and archaeologists who contributed to its formation have been indicated. For the first time, information about the peculiarities of the replenishment of the fund from 2000 to 2020 has been introduced into scientific circulation. It has been established that until the end of the 20th century, the museum primarily received archaeological collections from employees of the Institute of Language and Literature History, while from the beginning of the 21st century, the main source of new acquisitions has been researchers from the Institute of Ethnological Studies named after R.G. Kuzeyev.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):72-81
72-81
Alexander Dunin-Gorkavich – member of the Imperial Russian Geographical Society
Abstract
The subject of the research is the scientific activity of the Siberian researcher A. A. Dunin-Gorkavich, a member of the Imperial Russian Geographical Society. For 30 years, he headed the Samara Forestry of the Tobolsk province, ending his career as an official for special assignments in the Main Directorate of State Property. He was a member of many Russian scientific communities. Dunin-Gorkavich is the author of works on ethnography, geography, economics, statistics, agriculture and shipping in Northwestern Siberia. In 1926, he was recognized by the USSR Academy of Sciences as a scientist of all-Union significance. The biographical method is used to describe, reconstruct, and analyze the circumstances of life and performance. A set of methods was used to analyze the sources, including historical-geographical, system-structural analysis, and others. There are no works in Russian historiography devoted to his cooperation with scientific societies, in particular, with the Imperial Russian Geographical Society. The purpose of this study is to fill in the gap in the biography of the scientist, based on archival documents published and introduced into scientific circulation for the first time. The first successful experience of Dunin-Gorkavich's cooperation with the scientific society was formed during the preparation and conduct of the northern expeditions at the turn of the XIX–XX centuries. In 1903, A.A. Dunin–Gorkavich was elected a member of the society. The article provides information about little-known expeditions to the lower reaches of the Ob River in 1908-1909, the results of which were highly appreciated by the government. Dunin-Gorkavich was awarded the Order of St. Vladimir, 4th degree. The society's assistance in studying the northern regions of the Tobolsk province played a positive role both in scientific activity and in the career growth of the official.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):82-93
82-93
State-Confessional Relations in the Ideology and Activities of Russian Liberal Parties in the Early 20th Century: Historical Sources
Abstract
The subject of the research is the state-confessional relations in historical sources. The object of the research is the liberal political parties of Russia in the early 20th century, as well as historical sources on the formation of their ideology and practical activities, such as legislative acts of the Russian Empire, party documents (programs, protocols of congresses and meetings of the Central Committee, etc.), stenographic reports of meetings of the State Duma of the Russian Empire, documentation of religious organizations (primarily the Russian Orthodox Church, as well as Muslim and Roman Catholic communities, as the three most numerous confessions in the state), personal sources, and materials from the archives of the Russian Federation and the Republic of Belarus (in particular, the State Archive of the Russian Federation, the State Archive of Vitebsk Oblast, and the Manuscript Department of the National Library of Belarus). The author employed problem-chronological and historical-comparative research methods. The problem-chronological method allows for the demonstration of the development of specific historical processes over time. The application of the historical-comparative method helped to identify the commonalities and differences in historical sources on the thematic problem. The relevance of the research topic is determined by the theoretical and practical significance of the ideological and theoretical views and practical activities of Russian liberals in the early 20th century concerning state-confessional relations. It is also driven by the growing public interest in religion and the church. The scientific novelty of the research lies in the author's examination of the extent to which issues of state-confessional relations are reflected in the ideology and activities of Russian liberal parties in the early 20th century through the lens of both political and church history. After reviewing the information on historical sources related to the stated problem, one may arrive at the following conclusions. A comprehensive analysis of various types of historical sources allows for the construction of an objective picture of reality that reflects issues of state-confessional relations in the theory of Russian liberalism and in the practical activities of liberal political parties in the early 20th century. Furthermore, the source base enables the formation of an understanding of the positions of representatives of both all-Russian and national liberal parties, primarily Tatar (Muslim) and Polish (Roman Catholic), regarding the relationship between the Church and the state in the pre-revolutionary period of Russian history.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):94-100
94-100
Results of the use-wear analysis of horse gear items from the excavation of the Chishminskoye settlement of the Late Bronze Age (Bashkir Ural region)
Abstract
The article presents the results of traceological study of bone items from horse harness – a spurless grooved psalia and an ornamented strap distributor from the excavations of the Chishmin settlement. The site is located in the Bashkir Pre-Urals. From 1980 to 1983, an expedition led by Yu.A. Morozov uncovered an area of over 700 square meters at the site. The main part of the archaeological material was associated with the log-built archaeological culture of the Late Bronze Age. Materials from the Abashevo, Alakul, Cherkaskul, and Mezhev cultures are represented to a lesser extent. The collection of bone artifacts from the settlement excavations consists of 28 items, among which the most notable are the examined psalia and strap distributor. The relevance of the research is dictated by the insufficient study of bone inventory from the Bronze Age in the territory of the Bashkir Pre-Urals. The main research method used was traceological analysis, which allows for the study of traces on the surface of the objects. The examination of the items was conducted using a MBS-10 stereo microscope and Altami MET 6T metallographic microscope with a digital camera. Although data on the mentioned finds had been previously published, the results of the traceological analysis are introduced into scientific circulation for the first time. Additionally, a comparison with a number of analogies from the Eurasian steppes was conducted. The examination of the collection revealed that the psalia has only been partially preserved to date. The upper part is lost. The research results confirm the active use of the grooved psalia and distributor, and also allow tracing the techniques of bone processing used in their manufacture: cutting, planing, carving, and drilling. All bone processing operations were carried out with metal tools, and there are no signs of abrasive processing. The wear trace complex has a pronounced character and indicates interaction with a soft elastic material – leather straps.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):101-112
101-112
Rural monument of the Russian old-settler population of the Tobolsk Priirtyshye: the village of Shishkina
Abstract
The article presents the results of a comprehensive study of one of the monuments of the Russian old-settler population of the Tobolsk Priirtyshya — the village of Shishkina on the Tobol River. Since this territory is one of the key areas in the exploration of Siberia, its study is considered relevant. At the same time, the history of Russian settlements in Tobolsk Priirtyshya has been insufficiently studied, which hampers a detailed characterization of the historical and cultural features of the region as a whole. The village of Shishkina is first mentioned in written sources from the early 17th century, and at present, it has almost completely ceased to exist. Due to the fragmentary nature of the information about the settlement, a comprehensive picture of the emergence and development of Shishkina has been absent until now. The conducted research aimed to fill this gap. A comprehensive approach was used in the study of Shishkina, drawing on various sources. Data from written and cartographic sources were utilized. The geomorphology of the Tobol River section was studied, along with its influence on the natural boundaries of agricultural lands. The data from archaeology allowed for an assessment of the material culture of the examined village. The research conducted showed that even small rural settlements, such as Shishkina, contain valuable information about the history of Siberian exploration, transport infrastructure, social composition, and everyday culture of the old-settler population of Tobolsk Priirtyshya. The comprehensive approach, which combined written and archaeological sources, not only made it possible to more fully reconstruct the history of a particular settlement but also to gain a deeper understanding of the features of land development, socio-economic processes, and everyday life of Russians in Siberia from the 17th to the early 20th centuries. Despite the relatively small volume of archaeological work, which does not allow for generalized conclusions about the peculiarities of the material culture of the residents of Shishkina, preliminary conclusions can be formulated. Although this settlement appeared quite early, in the early 17th century, and was an important point on the Moscow-Siberian tract near Tobolsk, this did not serve as an impetus for the growth of its residents' prosperity.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):113-130
113-130
"Atlas of the Tobolsk Province" by the surveyor V. E. Filimonov as a source on the medieval history of the Siberian Tatars
Abstract
The article is devoted to the role of cartographic materials in the study of the history of the Late Medieval Tatar states of Western Siberia. The subject of the study is the "Atlas" of the surveyor V. E. Filimonov, which presents a General map of the Tobolsk province with plans of 9 Siberian cities (Tobolsk, Tyumen, Tara, Berezov, Turinsk, Kurgan. Yalutorovsk, Omsk, Ishim) and 10 plans of "ancient fortifications". These medieval archaeological sites from the period of the Siberian Khanate are given by V. Filimonov with a detailed description of the events related to this area. The object of the research is the historical potential of the plans of medieval monuments presented in the Atlas. The relevance of referring to this Atlas is related to its weak introduction into scientific circulation, as well as the fact that the territory of the Tobolsk-Irtysh region remains poorly studied archaeologically. The paper uses such traditional methods for historical research as structural-descriptive, comparative and retrospective. Based on archival and other sources, the biography of the surveyor V. E. Filimonov is presented for the first time. Its role in the cartographic description of the region of the late XVIII – early XIX centuries is shown. Modern researchers especially note the high accuracy of the plans presented by the surveyor, which enhances the value of the Atlas as a historical source. The individual plans of the "ancient fortifications" presented in the Atlas are considered in detail from the point of view of their historical potential. It has been revealed that, despite some progress in the study of the medieval history of Siberia, there remains a significant number of "white spots" in its study. In this regard, further archaeological research of medieval monuments is necessary with the involvement of cartographic materials, including information from the Atlas of V. E. Filimonov.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):131-145
131-145
Swedish Livonia in the accounts of foreign travelers in the second half of the 17th century
Abstract
The publication examines the formation of the image of Swedish Livonia in the accounts of foreign authors from Western Europe who visited the region in person in the second half of the 17th century. During the period of Swedish dominance and the abolition of the old English privileges of the Muscovy Company, the Baltic region increasingly attracted the attention of the English and Dutch. Thanks to the accounts of Patrick Gordon, a Scottish officer in Russian service, and participants in the Earl of Carlisle's embassy to the courts of the Russian, Swedish, and Danish monarchs, it is possible to reconstruct the general perceptions of English subjects of Sweden's Baltic possessions. These accounts correlate with the accounts of Dutch diplomats who visited Swedish Livonia during the same period. Having visited the province, the authors compiled vivid and pithy descriptions not only of everyday life on the road and the region's natural environment, but also their thoughts on the customs of the local population, the prospects for trade development, and the defense capabilities of Swedish Livonia in the face of its eastern neighbor. A comparative analysis, by comparing the accounts of English and Dutch authors, allows us to create a relatively coherent image of the Swedish possessions in Livonia, as they were seen in Britain and the Republic of the United Provinces during the period of Swedish great power. The Baltic possessions of the Swedish crown are presented as a region that is relatively backward and unpopulated, but not without natural resources. The defenses of Swedish Livonia are weak, with Riga serving as the main fortress, simultaneously serving as the main center of trade and Swedish dominance in the region. It is Riga that the English and Dutch perceive as a truly European city, compared to the poor, semi-wild, and barbaric province. Despite the devastation of the Russo-Swedish War of 1656–1658, the region quickly recovered. However, it clearly lacks the attention it deserves, with road infrastructure development, the modernization of fortresses, and the construction of new fortifications neglected. The local population was subjugated by the Swedes and even economically leaned more toward the neighboring Russian state.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):146-164
146-164
Health and hygiene of the population of Tobolsk province in 1880-1914
Abstract
The subject of this study is the urban and rural population of the mentioned province during the period from 1880 to 1914. The research focuses on the health and hygiene of urban and rural residents of Tobolsk province. Based on extensive statistical data stored in the Russian State Historical Archive, as well as published medical reports from various departments, the study characterizes the prevalence of the most common infectious diseases, mortality rates of the inhabitants of Tobolsk province, and their sanitary-hygienic behavior. Changes in the organization of healthcare and hygiene education for the population are traced, key issues in providing medical assistance to urban and rural residents are identified, and the role of the intelligentsia and active segments of society in promoting and disseminating sanitary-hygienic knowledge is highlighted. The methodological basis for writing this work is the theory of modernization, according to which the study of health and hygiene culture of the population in the late imperial period is considered in the context of economic and sociocultural changes that led to the transformation of the traditional value system, perceptions of diseases and their treatment methods, and the development of new patterns of life-preserving behavior. The study details the structure of predominant infectious diseases ("epidemic diseases") among the population of Tobolsk province in the late imperial period, showing the outbreak nature of epidemics, and highlights peak stages of diseases and years of "calm". It concludes that there was a discrepancy between levels of mortality and birth rates in the described province, indicating the first signs of a crisis in the traditional type of generational reproduction. It is noted that despite the still low level of hygiene culture among the population of Tobolsk province, the 1880s–1910s witnessed the first shifts in the formation of new sanitary-hygienic habits and behavioral practices for health preservation, especially among urban residents. However, positive shifts in health indicators and hygiene culture in Tobolsk province were just beginning to take shape and had not yet become widespread.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):165-177
165-177
The importance of ship models in the history of the Russian Navy
Abstract
The Russian Federation is a maritime power for which the history of the Navy is of great importance and inseparable from the history of the state. Throughout the development of the Russian Navy, the creation and use of ship models has contributed to the effectiveness of maritime activities. This article examines the use of ship models in national practice – in shipbuilding, training of naval personnel, as well as in matters of patriotic education and the preservation of maritime historical and cultural heritage. This study is relevant, firstly, due to insufficient coverage of this topic in historical science, secondly, due to the significance of naval activities for the country as a whole, and thirdly, the importance of preserving the material and historical heritage of the Russian Navy. The purpose of this work is to identify the significance of ship models for the Navy. The subject of the study is to determine the role and place of ship models in the history of the Russian Navy. An analysis of specialized literature and a study of archival documents revealed that ship models accompanied the formation and development of the Russian Navy throughout its entire existence. The study utilizes traditional historical research methods: the principle of historicism, historical typology, and historical comparative methods. As a result of this study, the author presents for the first time a modern understanding of the importance of ship models for the Russian Navy. The significance of this work lies in the fact that the results obtained through analysis and generalization allow a wide range of historians and museum specialists to expand their understanding of ship models, qualitatively improve their application in science, education, and upbringing, and utilize such objects as historical sources on the history of shipbuilding, the Navy, and museum studies. The author concludes that ship models played a significant role in the history of the Russian Navy, made a significant contribution to shipbuilding, were widely used for training personnel for the Russian Navy, organically integrated into the system of patriotic education, and can be useful in the current stage of its development.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):178-191
178-191
Archaic elements in the cult of gods and keremet in the Eastern Mari of Bashkortostan according to sources from the 16th to the mid-19th centuries and in the light of modern data
Abstract
The subject of this article is the cult of gods and keremets (nature spirits and ancestral deities) among the Eastern Mari living in the territory of Bashkortostan, based on sources from the 16th to the mid – 19th centuries. The aim of the work is to identify archaic elements in the cult of gods and keremets during this time period and to compare them with contemporary data. The research tasks include an overview of the existing ethnographic literature on the beliefs of the Eastern Mari of Bashkortostan from the 16th century to the mid-19th century, analysis of the most ancient religious complexes related to specific gods and keremets, as well as associated cults and customs, and the extrapolation of historical data onto modern beliefs of the Mari to determine the direction of the evolution of Mari traditional religion. The methodological basis of the article includes a comparative-historical approach, the method of ethnographic parallels, and etymological analysis. Additionally, the author utilized materials from their own field research. The novelty and results of the study lie in the identification of certain archaic elements in the traditional ethnic beliefs of the Eastern Mari. In particular, the author proposed the existence during the 16th to the first half of the 19th centuries of an orgiastic cult of female deities involving prayers and sacrifices. The article also noted the presence in the past among the Mari of idols, fetishes, structures, and opposing keremets—evidence of a more ancient pantheon. The author of this work identified the existence of specific and subsequently vanished deities (including keremets), proposed etymologies for a number of theonyms, clarified the functions of these deities and the composition of sacrifices, revealing their connection to the elements of forest, water, wild animals, and birds. The article also uncovered the underlying beliefs of the solar-lunar cult of the goddess Kéche Ava (Tyltze Ava), who likely originally appeared in the form of a water nymph and an owl. When comparing historical data with contemporary information, the author noted that during the 20th and the first quarter of the 21st centuries, the role of women in prayers and sacrifices has increased: currently, men and women pray together in sacred groves, and women often become organizers of prayers. The cult of keremets demonstrates a certain resilience.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):192-217
192-217
«Bely Ugol'»: The Firstborn of Russian Hydropower Industry
Abstract
The research is devoted to technical aspects of the formation of the Russian hydropower industry using the example of the history of the construction and operation of the "Bely Ugol'", one of the first hydroelectric power plants in pre-revolutionary Russia. The station was designed to provide electricity to the resort towns of the Caucasian Mineral Waters. This project was implemented in 1901–1903 by "Siemens and Galske". The authors consider the history of the development of the technical project and the construction of the Bely Ugol hydroelectric power station. Special attention is paid to the role of technology transfer in the development of energy engineering, construction and operation of hydroelectric power plants in Russia. The research is based on the materials of the Mining Department of the Ministry of Trade and Industry, stored in the Russian State Historical Archive, as well as on published sources. The authors rely on methodological approaches of science and technology studies, focusing on the relationship between technological and economic development of the region. The analysis of the revealed materials showed that during the operation of the "Bely Ugol'" station, significant design and constructive flaws were revealed, made by "Siemens and Galske" engineer S. M. Friedman. The successful elimination of the technical problems was the merit of the Russian electrical engineers M. A. Chatelain and P. D. Voynarovsky. It is noted that a comprehensive technical adaptation of the "alien" project to Russian conditions was carried out. The parallel connection of the Pyatigorsk HPP and the CHP into a single energy system has become a vivid testimony to the high level of the Russian engineering school. The authors conclude that the "Bely Ugol'" hydroelectric power station played a significant role in the development of hydropower in Russia in the early twentieth century.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):218-227
218-227
Environmental protection activities in the Komi ASSR in the 1940s and 1950s: from resource use to conservation and restoration
Abstract
In light of the implementation of the national project "Environmental Well-being" in Russia starting in 2025, as well as the return to discussions in 2025 of a Soviet-era project concerning the diversion of the flows of northern and Siberian rivers, the historical experience of academic science's participation in the country's and regions' environmental protection activities takes on special significance. The aim of this work is to analyze and summarize the activities of the scholars from the Komi branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences, which contributed to the formation of a scientific and practical direction in environmental protection in the mid – 1940s to 1950s. The object of study is the problems of organization and the main directions of environmental protection activities in the regions of the USSR (using the example of the Komi ASSR). The subject of research includes the areas of work, forms, methods, and results of the activities of the scholars from the Komi branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences in the field of nature conservation. The implementation of the main methodological principles was achieved through the application of methodological techniques: comparative-historical, specific and logical analysis, methods of periodization and prospectivity. All political, cultural, scientific-technical events are revealed in historical sequence against the backdrop of general history. Analysis of documents from the Scientific Archive of the Komi Scientific Center of the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences and published sources has shown that during the 1940s–1950s, the scientific works of the scholars from the Komi branch of the Academy of Sciences predominantly focused on topics related to the study of the characteristics of the natural resources of Komi and the impact of economic activities on the republic's nature: "Forests of the Komi ASSR, their use and restoration," "Wildlife of the Komi ASSR, its changes under human influence and ways of rational development of hunting economy in the republic," "Fish resources of the Komi ASSR and ways of their most rational use," "Kama-Vychegda-Pechora water management complex," among others. The key results of the institution's work included: a systemic analysis of the productive forces of the Komi ASSR, the setting of environmental protection problems and the initial stage of their resolution, and a comprehensive analysis of the impact on the economy and nature of the region of the grand project for diverting northern rivers into the Caspian Sea basin. Scholars in the 1940s–1950s made a significant contribution to the identification of regional environmental protection problems and laid the groundwork for subsequent research and management decisions in the field of nature conservation.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):228-244
228-244
Post-war collectivization and "dekulakization" in Soviet historiography of the mid-1960s to 1970s
Abstract
The object of study is the evolution of Soviet historiography and the main driving factors during the specified chronological period, while the subject is the scientific contribution of domestic historians to the understanding of the processes of collectivization and "dekulakization" in the western regions of the USSR. The aim is to identify the key factors in the development of Soviet historiography on this topic, as well as their impact on the content of research and the scientific achievements of Soviet historians. The author examines in detail the evolution of themes and assessments compared to the preceding period, as well as the contradictions in the evaluations of collectivization and the statistics on the maturation of preconditions and the pace of collectivization in Western regions and republics. Special attention in the article is given to the specific factors influencing the development of historiography on post-war collectivization, under-researched topics, and the reasons for the persistence of little-explored issues. The analysis of Soviet historiography of post-war collectivization employs methods of periodization and a genetic approach to determine the nature of changes in historiographical positions and assess the degree of their influence; a systemic comparative analysis is used to compare the thematic development of research; as well as a problem-chronological method combined with the principle of historicism to structure the obtained results. The scientific novelty is due to a comprehensive study of the dynamics of Soviet historiography on post-war collectivization through the lens of modern concepts of the school of V. P. Danilov, which studied the collectivization of the 1930s. The author draws several conclusions. During the examined period, a significant number of documents were published, expanding the source base. Within ideological frameworks, Soviet historians were able to study in more detail the preconditions and mass post-war collectivization. Historians differentiated the measures applied to kulaks into economic actions and "dekulakization." For the first time, the number of kulaks by regions and those exiled to the PMSSR was provided, along with cautious critical remarks about the immaturity of the preconditions for collectivization. The methods of kulak resistance were studied in greater detail, and doubts were raised about the necessity of "dekulakization" due to the small number of kulaks in the PMSSR. A special contribution of the article's author is the examination of the specific factors affecting the development of the Soviet historical paradigm based on works about post-war collectivization, highlighting the contradictions in statistics and ideological settings. The results of the research can be applied in the scientific study of the evolution of Soviet historiography, as well as for educational and enlightening purposes.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):245-269
245-269
Current issues of the political history of Chechnya in the late 1920s - first half of the 1930s
Abstract
The subject of this article is the paucity of research into the complex and contradictory processes of Chechnya's political history, particularly the formation and functioning of its political system, particularly in the 1920s and 1930s. Given the complexity and multifaceted nature of the topic under consideration, we have chosen the universal principle of historicism as our primary research method. We proceed from the premise that a political system is a set of structures (institutions) whose primary functions are the exercise of state power and public administration, at various levels, both vertically and horizontally. We believe that a problem-based, chronological analysis of events within their systemic connections allows us to objectify the historical search for its specific forms and their subsequent transformation. By examining the processes under study within individual stages (largely arbitrary), defined by specific chronological boundaries, we believe we have successfully reconstructed the logic of events, their historically consistent connection, and their multifaceted nature. At the same time, such historical and comparative analysis was updated by the tasks of clarifying individual nuances that took place in the historical practice of Soviet construction, especially during the period of formation and strengthening of the foundations of socialism in our country (1917–1936). The main conclusions of the conducted research are: disclosure of the initial principles of formation of the Soviet political system of Chechnya; analysis of the complex process of Soviet construction in Chechnya in the 1920s and 1930s; objective scientific study of the history of the Chechen people, Russian-Caucasian relations, national and federal policy of the Soviet state in Chechnya during this period; study of the issues of formation and activities of the party and Soviet apparatus of Chechnya in the 1920s and 1930s. The problem of Soviet construction in Chechnya, in our opinion, is of great scientific and practical significance. The study of this issue helps to recreate a more complete and objective picture of the complex, contradictory political life of the Chechen people, to show the essence of the policy of the central government, carried out in the region in the first and subsequent years of Soviet construction, its role in optimizing the paths and methods of economic, political and cultural development of Chechnya, its Soviet national autonomy.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):270-281
270-281
The history of the study of settlements from the Middle Bronze Age in mountainous Dagestan
Abstract
The article is dedicated to the history of the study of settlements of the Middle Bronze Age in mountainous Dagestan. Researching these settlements will shed light on issues of local specificity and the patterns of cultural-historical, socio-economic, and ethno-cultural development in areas with a high intensity of contact among various cultures. The article focuses on the historiography of the study of Middle Bronze Age settlements in the mountainous Republic of Dagestan, highlighting stages of research and summarizing the results. The first stage – pre-Soviet – from 1880 to 1917; the second stage – from 1918 to 1941; the third stage – from 1945 to 1951; the fourth stage – from 1951 to 1973; the fifth stage – from 1974 to 1991; the sixth stage – from 1992 to 2024. There are prerequisites for a detailed study of Bronze Age settlements in mountainous Dagestan. These are based on significant materials obtained and comparative data from other regions of Dagestan and the Caucasus. A large amount of material has been accumulated from settlements and cemeteries. An important circumstance is the presence of substantial research in the archaeology of Dagestan and the Caucasus, the data of which are analyzed in the article. The article analyzes perspectives on issues related to the study and interpretation of materials from Middle Bronze Age settlements in mountainous Dagestan. In summary, it should be noted that domestic monuments of Dagestan have been studied variably. Among the settlements in the mountainous region, the Upper Gunib and Irganay No. I settlements stand out due to the scale of research. The materials from the Upper Gunib and Irganay No. I settlements are a valuable source for studying the local culture, but unfortunately, they require summarization and complete publication. To fully address the issues related to the study of settlements from the Middle Bronze Age, new explorations and large-scale excavations are necessary. The settlements in mountainous Dagestan remain relatively poorly studied, particularly in Southern Dagestan, which remains a blank spot on the archaeological map of Dagestan. There is a pressing need to conduct large-scale excavations of settlements from the Kayakent-Khorochoyev culture.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):282-298
282-298
Ethnic processes among the Taz people at the beginning of the 21st century in connection with ethnic history
Abstract
The aim of this work was to characterize the state of the culture of the Taz peoples (an indigenous, numerically small nation of Primorsky Krai) at the turn of the 20th to the 21st century. Starting from the 1990s, the peoples of the Russian Federation actively manifested their culture in the mass media and public spaces. While the Taz peoples did engage in such activities in the administrative sphere (resulting in their recognition as a small-numbered indigenous people of Primorye), they very minimally popularized their culture. Key research directions included the problems of the "invisibility" of Taz culture, clarity of self-awareness and representation of ethnic boundaries, as well as gold identity. Taz representatives do not engage in active activity on social media or other media outlets, publishing articles that would allow representatives of other peoples to familiarize themselves with their culture. At the same time, they possess a clear self-awareness and a representation of "their" and "foreign" rituals, holidays, dishes, etc., contrasting themselves with the Udege, Chinese, Russians, Koreans, Nanai, and others. Gold identity acts as an intra-Taz identity, characteristic of the activists of this movement. The study included two parts. The first was conducted using content analysis of the community page of the Association of Indigenous Small-Numbered Peoples of Primorye on VK (March-May 2024); the second involved semi-structured interviews during a field trip to the Olgin District of Primorsky Krai (July 2025). The main conclusions of the study describe the state of Taz culture based on the results of the 2024 field season. The culture retains features of "invisibility," which is partly explained by its ethnic history (strong sinicization of the Taz, which led to their identification with the Chinese) and partly by the special status of activists who possess a gold identity. At the same time, gold identity is opposed to Nanai identity (officially: gold is an outdated name for the Nanai), but is considered related to Taz identity. Thus, Taz identity is clearly recognized by its bearers; however, it does not fit within the frameworks established by ethnographer researchers. The authors see their contribution to the discussion as showing the complex composition of Taz culture, which is not merely a fusion of Chinese and Udege cultures, but also includes Korean, gold, and possibly Manchurian elements.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):299-311
299-311
The image of the ideal colonial administrator in the views of Spanish statesmen in the first half of the 18th century
Abstract
The article examines the views of Spanish administrators in the 18th century regarding the transformation of the colonial administration system. The development of reform projects for overseas policy began in the 1720s and actively evolved in the 1740s during the Anglo-Spanish War over the Asiento from 1739 to 1748. In the opinion of bureaucrats, the main tool for reform was administrative activity, and the key figure in this process was the administrator. The purpose of this work is to reconstruct the characteristics of the new manager in Spanish America. The report analyzes three so-called colonial treatises from the 1720s to 1740s – “A General Representation of the State of the Royal Treasury” from 1725, “A New System of Economic Management for America” from 1743, and “Secret Reports on America” from 1748 – which describe the problems of the crown's possessions in the New World. By utilizing the method of the Cambridge School of intellectual history, it is possible to determine the common views of members of the Spanish administration regarding the necessary characteristics of the ideal administrator in the governed overseas territories. The use of historical sociology and postcolonial imagology methods allows for a comprehensive exploration of the topic, defining both the image and character of power and the rulers themselves. The novelty of this study lies in the use of materials from “A General Representation,” a little-studied source in modern domestic and foreign historiography, as well as the identification of new aspects and themes in the well-known work “A New System.” The examination of assessments of American administrators’ activities allows for the identification of new requirements for the administrator: concerning their social status, skills, duties, and ethos. Additionally, the criteria for selecting candidates for colonial positions at various levels are analyzed. Based on this, a conclusion is drawn about the evolution of qualitative requirements for the representative of metropolitan interests in the colonial environment: concerning the existence of estate restrictions and elements of vassal ethos on one hand, and the crown's striving for professionalization of the administration in the New World on the other.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):312-320
312-320
"The Skopets-Molokan-Jewish sect" of the Tula province in the context of political relations in the 19th century
Abstract
Questions of state policy regarding various religious communities in the Russian Empire have been repeatedly raised in academic literature. However, their study remains highly uneven. While the issue of the relationship between the authorities and the Old Believers is considered from both all-Russian and regional perspectives, the problem of the authorities' relationship with "sects" is currently more peripheral. This article examines the policy of the authorities towards the "Skoptsy-Molokans-Jewish sect" that existed in the 19th century in the village of Nizhnye Zalegoschi in the Novosil district of Tula province. The research addresses the following questions: when and in what context did this religious group emerge? What was the reaction of various participants in power relations to its appearance? What difficulties did the authorities face in interacting with this sect? Our research is based on unpublished sources that are being introduced into scholarly discourse for the first time. The methodology includes primarily historical-systemic and historical-genetic methods. In this work, we will use the term "sect," as it was the most commonly used term in relation to the religious movement we are studying. Throughout the research, the author reaches several conclusions. It is noted that this religious movement represented a variant of Skoptsy, syncretically incorporating elements from other religious directions. The participants of this religious movement were characterized by adherence to all external prescriptions of the Orthodox Church, refusal of meat, alcohol, and coitus, special reverence for the Sabbath, the practice of castration, conducting night rituals similar to those of Khlysty or Skoptsy, among others. A particular emphasis is placed on the fact that the representatives of this sect did not separate themselves from the Orthodox Church, which created additional problems for the authorities. It is noted that the "Skoptsy-Molokan-Jewish sect" existed within a Cossack-peasant environment. It is underscored that the authorities, confronted with incomprehensible practices, could not develop a comprehensive strategy for interacting with the newly emerged sect. Against this backdrop, conflicts arose between the church and the secular authorities, as well as within the clergy itself, which could not be resolved through compromises.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):321-330
321-330
Northeast Siberia in the travel notes of official D.I. Melikov (late 19th century).
Abstract
The main source for the article is the travel notes of the official of the regional administration of the Yakut region, D.I. Melikov, compiled during his review of the northern districts in 1893. The territorial framework covers the Northeast Siberia, part of the Arctic Circle. The relevance of this research is determined by the ongoing broad interest in the history of the Arctic regions of Russia. Personal sources represent a valuable and unique layer of historical information. Such interest contributes to a deep study of the region and expands the understanding of its historical and cultural heritage. Melikov's notes contain impressions of the nature of the northern region, characteristics of local officials, Cossacks, priests, and indigenous people, the occupations of the northern peoples, descriptions of the animal world, as well as ethnographic notes with simple drawings. Additionally, they include brief comments on official activities. The author writes about his conversations with representatives of the northern peoples. The analysis is based on the principles of the historical method, which involves a systematic and objective consideration of the data in the context of historical-genetic, comparative, and typological approaches, allowing the identification of key features and interconnections that are essential for a multifaceted understanding of the historical process of the studied region. The scientific novelty of the research is determined by the fact that some of the information presented in the examined source has not been the subject of detailed study and is introduced into scientific circulation for the first time. This source allows for the reconstruction of the past through the personal observation and impressions of an educated official, containing information that was not recorded in official documents, such as aspects of everyday life, relationships between people, and social issues. As part of the research, a comprehensive assessment of the information contained in the source was conducted to determine its significance for cultural, social, political, and economic aspects of studying the history of the Far North. The value of this historical source is confirmed by the materials contained within it and critical remarks about the everyday life of the peoples of the Far North.
Historical Journal: Scientific Research. 2025;(6):331-342
331-342
