Vol 17, No 2 (2025)
- Year: 2025
- Articles: 8
- URL: https://journals.rcsi.science/2312-8127/issue/view/21287
Full Issue
Ideas and politics in history
The three faces of caliphatism: ideas of the caliphate among islamic thinkers of the late 19th - early 20th centuries
Abstract
The study undertakes a rigorous examination of the process of shaping the image of the caliphate and caliphal institutions in the central and peripheral regions of Islamic world in the late 19th century and the first third of the 20th century. To this end, it provides a look at specific examples of creative and political thought, drawing upon the works of prominent Muslim intellectuals and ideologists - Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi (1855-1902), Abd al-Aziz Javish (1876-1929) and Abul Kalam Azad (1888-1958). The Ottoman Empire decline accompanied by successful colonization of Muslim lands by Europeans compelled Arab, Turkish, and Indian thinkers to refer to the Ottomans’ experience in the caliphal capacity. Discussions around the duties of the Caliph and conditions for his legitimacy raised a wide range of political, cultural, and philosophical issues. They revealed contradictions in the interpretation of unity within Muslim community (umma), on the question on whether the caliphate and the secular model of social development could coexist, and on the prospects of overcoming the dependence of Muslim peoples on foreign colonial powers. The study sheds light on generational and regional features in the way Muslim intellectual elite regarded the tasks and legitimacy of the rule of the last Ottoman sultans. It reveals historical arguments and ideological attitudes of those who supported and opposed the concept of the ‘Arab caliphate’ (‘caliphate of the Quraysh’), while the concept itself is evaluated in the light of geopolitical change that followed the Young Turk revolution of 1908-1909 and the Ottoman decline after the First World War. This study makes it possible to question the widespread view of caliphatism as a comparatively systematic, logically sound and non-evolving worldview system.



The bases of Sultan’s power in Alawi Morocco during XVII-XVIII centuries: the triumph of military force or the search of consensus?
Abstract
The actual problem of state-building and legitimization of power in the Middle East and North Africa in the precolonial period on the example of Morocco is of particular interest, as it allows us to examine a political model that was formed in the western periphery of Arab-Muslim world. The purpose of this research is to analyse the concept of power that developed during the rule of Alawi dynasty (since 1631), which is still in power in Morocco. Based on the Arab chronicles, the article examines the major elements of legitimating ideologies used by Alawi monarchs during the XVII-XVIII centuries. Moroccan sultans were sharifs - descendants of the Prophet Muhammad, and were the object of veneration in Moroccan society. The Sharifi baraka (a hereditary blessing power) and noble origin thus became the main factors in the legitimacy of their rule. The study shows how the idea of sacred power of the Sharifi sultans was combined with elements of the Sunni political doctrine which did not recognise the divine nature of power. The study also gives the author’s assessment of the discussion about the role of military force and coercion in Sultan’s domination which has been taken in Moroccan historiography. It is concluded that Alawi sultan used violence in dealings with his subjects but it wasn’t the only base of his power. Moreover, the Alawis have managed to legitimise this violence and make it a part of the Sharifi concept of power.



China’s policy in the Arctic: ambitions and realities
Abstract
The relevance of the research topic is due to the increasing interest of the PRC in Arctic issues. Despite the fact that China is not one of the Arctic and sub-Arctic states, it plays an active role among non-Arctic players in the issue of internationalization of Arctic governance, seeking to strengthen its voice in Arctic affairs. The purpose of the research is to study the ambitions of Chinese policy in the region. The range of tasks includes issues of the historical, regulatory and legal framework of China’s Arctic policy, discourse in the Chinese scientific community. Based on the results of the study, it was concluded that the Chinese side will actively promote the narrative of the need to transform the Arctic into an important artery of international logistics through the implementation of the Polar Silk Road project, and will focus on the need to internationalize the Arctic region and also expand opportunities for access to natural resources as an attractive asset in the Arctic. In view of the increasing fragmentation of international relations and the “blocking” of the Russian Federation’s activities during its chairmanship of the Arctic Council, the Chinese side is gaining greater opportunities to be involved in the Arctic agenda due to expanded cooperation with the largest Arctic power - Russia.



Military, informational and psychological conflict in Rakhine: past, present and prospects for resolution
Abstract
The study examines the causes of Myanmar’s domestic problems related to the ethnoconfessional contradictions in Rakhine as well as international intervention in the country’s internal affairs through the use of modern methods of warfare in the global information field. The analysis is implemented in the context of the history of the issue, the current level and possible prospects for resolving the conflict. It is concluded that starting from 2021-2022, the intensity of the conflict as well as the West’s informational, political and other engagement in supporting the Rohingya, began to decline. This, of course, had a positive effect on the Tatmadaw’s (Myanmar army and border guards) potential to counter separatism and terrorism in Rakhine. The author draws attention to the fact that any state (using Myanmar as an example) that has a rich and eventful historical past, its own political culture and spiritual values but does not fit into the modern “democratic” system of the Global West, has every right to solve its own internal problems using the methods available to it. Political, economic or information pressure on it is not a method for solving problems, especially if it is carried out under the guise of falsely interpreted democratic principles.



Imagined communisms: the Argentine new left and the construction of “Real socialism” in the 1960s/1970s
Abstract
This research analyzes the readings and interpretations produced by an Argentine political organization, the Partido Revolucionario de los Trabajadores - Ejército Revolucionario del Pueblo (PRT-ERP), regarding the construction of socialism in countries such as the Soviet Union, China, and various locations in Eastern Europe during the 1960s and 1970s. Our objective is to trace the impact produced by these experiences on the revolutionary horizon adopted by the party, examining how they were incorporated into its intervention platform over time. We observe how everyday life, development projects, and different political, diplomatic, and cultural initiatives led by countries associated with the “real socialism” universe were represented in the PRT-ERP’s periodicals, Estrella Roja and El Combatiente, and debated in its internal documentation. The analysis of documentary sources indicates that, despite being associated with the universe of the so-called “new lefts”, which emerged globally throughout the second half of the 20th century, the PRT-ERP was particularly interested in understanding what it called “the construction of socialism” in Eastern countries. This finding allows for a review of some definitions about the expectations that guided the actions of young people, women, and workers involved in Southern Cone (Brazil, Chile, Argentina, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay) revolutionary organizations during the 1960s and 1970s. Far from being an exception, the PRTERP was one of the most notable expressions of the phenomenon of political radicalization that crossed the regional landscape during that period.



Oriental Studies
Early attempts to establish Korean diplomatic representation in Europe in the late 19th century
Abstract
The opening of Korea (Chosŏn) for modern diplomacy in the late XIX century not only had a signifi impact on the geopolitical balance of power in the Northeast Asian region, but also largely determined the future of the Korean Peninsula. Chosŏn’s immediate neighbors, China, Japan, and the Russian Empire, played a particularly important role in the regional rivalry surrounding the Korean peninsula in the late XIX and early XX centuries. First two powers had a long history of traditional diplomatic communications with Chosŏn and the states that preceded it. However, the Russian Empire, which expanded its territory in the Far East in the mid-19th century, was a new force in the region. Its diplomatic line followed Western, rather than Sinocentric, standards. It was precisely this unique position of the Russian Empire that determined its key role for Korea in establishing its diplomatic representation in Europe. This study describes several attempts by the Chosŏn government to establish its permanent diplomatic representation in Europe (headquartered in St. Petersburg) in the mid-1880s to late 1890s. These episodes in the history of Russian-Korean relations still remain poorly understood. The author focuses on the balance of power surrounding the Korean Peninsula during these events and analyzes the reasons for the failure of mentioned Korean government’s initiatives in the context of the geopolitical situation of that time. Despite the negative outcome, these early attempts to establish a Korean diplomatic representation in Europe (and Russia) had a signifi impact not only on the dynamics of domestic political processes in Chosŏn, but also on the balance of power surrounding it at the end of the XIX century.



The rise of modern China based on the magazine “China reconstructs”
Abstract
The significance of the research topic is determined by the relevance of the problem of soft power in China’s foreign policy and foreign economic policy at present. The purpose of this research project is to trace the origins of the concept of soft power , based on the materials and articles of the international Chinese magazine China Reconstructs (1952-1990). During the historical period under study, China was transitioning from the model of a closed state to positioning itself as one of the world leaders; the gradual transition to an open country required the activation of soft power policy in order to recognize legitimacy and strengthen its role on the world stage. The main stages of the history of New China’s development were not only reflected in the pages of the magazine, but also changed the magazine itself and its ideological content, which was broadcasting to the outside world. The authors conclude that soft power began to emerge since the formation of the People’s Republic of China and dates back to the reign of Mao Zedong. The authors consider the China Reconstructs magazine as an important tool of China’s soft power of that period, which is confirmed by the editorial guidelines of the magazine and the content of the articles.



Antique world
Interpretatio Romana: Egyptian religious and cultural toposes outside Egypt
Abstract
In order to compile an objective picture of the features of the spread of Egyptian cults in the territory of Rome and Italy (as far as possible from surviving sources), it is necessary to understand how the Romans adapted their knowledge of Egypt to form their own religious models. It should be taken into account that consideration of the characteristics of Egyptian religious practice on the territory of Italy should occur through the prism of the social context, as well as taking into account the specifics of the integration of these beliefs into the Roman cultural and religious environment. Rejecting traditions that were unacceptable to them, the Romans, nevertheless, willingly accepted those that had already been adapted by the Greeks. However, if we proceed from the postulate that the history of cultures is a history of borrowings, then we must admit that the readiness to introduce something new in Roman culture was by no means absolute, and Egyptian religious and cultural characteristics became the subject of appropriation only to the extent that this was necessary (and acceptable) for the Romans themselves.


