Bioethical aspects of providing equivalent medical treatment for prisoners


Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

The article discusses the bioethical foundations and problems of ensuring the practical implementation of the principle of equivalence of medical care for prisoners. The urgency of the problem in question is conditioned by the need to improve the quality of medical care in prisons. Among the key problems can be identified socio-demographic characteristics of prisoners: a large proportion of representatives of the marginalized population, low level of medical literacy, risky behavior, gender specific structure of the prison population. These features determine a significant difference in the structure of morbidity, characterized by a wider prevalence of chronic and socially significant diseases and a higher need for prisoners in medical care. Another aspect under consideration is the prison conditions themselves, in which the implementation of the principle of equivalence is difficult due to the specifics of their activities, dictating the need for strict adherence to regime and restrictive measures, which manifests itself in a significant restriction on the free choice of a doctor or medical institution, the need to disclose the diagnosis of the prison administration and other. An important factor is the negative social factor deprivation of prisoners, which not only hinders the effective rehabilitation of patients suffering from mental illnesses, but also is the cause of their occurrence.Finally, the role of a doctor in the penitentiary health system plays a crucial role in ensuring the equivalence principle. On the one hand, this relationship is a doctor-administration, on the other hand it is a doctor-patient relationship. A departure from the principle of equivalence in these relationships can lead to the phenomenon of "double loyalty" and mutual distrust.

About the authors

A. M Tulenkov

Federal State Institution Research Institute of the Federal Penitentiary Service Russia

Email: filialniifsin@mail.ru
Branch Manager, Candidate of Medical Sciences

References

  1. ВОЗ. Устранить несправедливость на гендерной почве в области здравоохранения в местах лишения свободы // Охрана здоровья женщин в местах лишения свободы. -Копенгаген: ВОЗ, 2009. - 85 с.
  2. ВОЗ. Разумное стратегическое руководство охраной здоровья в местах лишения свободы в XXI веке: краткий аналитический обзор по вопросу организации пенитенциарного здравоохранения. - Копенгаген: ВОЗ, 2014. - 42 с.
  3. ООН. Принципы медицинской этики, относящиеся к роли работников здравоохранения, в особенности врачей, в защите заключенных и задержанных лиц от пыток и других жестоких, бесчеловечных или унижающих достоинство видов обращения // Официальный отчет Генеральной Ассамблеи, тридцать седьмая сессия. - Нью-Йорк: ООН, 1982. - Доп. № 51. - С. 305-307.
  4. ООН. Меры, связанные и не связанные с лишением свободы: альтернативы тюремному заключению: пособие по оценке систем уголовного правосудия. - Нью-Йорк: ООН, 2010. - 47 с.
  5. Пономарев С.Б., Половникова А.А., Тоцкий С.И., Чубаров А.Л. Синдром тюремной социальной депривации в молодом возрасте: монография. - Екатеринбург: УрО РАН, 2008. - 148 с.
  6. ЮНЭЙДС, УНП ООН. Женщины и ВИЧ-инфекция в местах лишения свободы. - 2009. - 8 с.
  7. Anno B.J. Correctional health care: guidelines for the management of an adequate delivery system. - Washington, DC: National Institute of Corrections, 2001. - 596 р.
  8. Birmingham L., Wilson S., Adshead G. Prison medicine: ethics and equivalence // Br. J. Psychiatry. - 2006. -Vol. 188. - Р. 4-6.
  9. Comparison of female to male and male to female transmission of HIV in 563 stable couples. European Study Group on Heterosexual Transmission of HIV // Br. Med. J. - 1992. - Vol. 304(6830). - Р. 809-813.
  10. Condon L., Hek G., Harris F. Public health, health promotion and the health of people in prison // Com. Pract. - 2006. - Vol. 79(1). - Р. 19-22.
  11. Council of Europe. Recommendation Rec(2006)2 of the Committee of Ministers to member states on the European Prison Rules [Электронный ресурс]. -URL:https://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=955747 (дата обращения: 16.01.2018).
  12. Delgado M., Humm-Delgado D. Health and health care in the nation’s prisons: issues, challenges, and policies. (6-nd ed.). - New York: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2009. - 300 р.
  13. Niveau G. Relevance and limits of the principle of «equivalence of care» in prison medicine // J. Med. Ethics. - 2007. - Vol. 33(10). - P. 610-613.
  14. Nurse J., Woodcock P., Ormsby J. Influence of environmental factors on mental health within prisons: focus group study // BMJ. - 2003. - Vol. 327. - Р. 480.
  15. Rusche G., Kirchheimer O. Peine et structure sociale: histories et «théorie critique» de regime penal. - Paris: Les éditions du Cerf, 1994. - 185 p.

Copyright (c) 2018 Tulenkov A.M.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies