Comparative evaluation of percutaneous endoscopic and microsurgical lumbar discectomy


Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

The results of percutaneous endoscopic and microsurgical discectomy have been compared. It was established that the operative intervention time, bed-day medians and disability period were significantly shorter (p<0,001) in the percutaneous endoscopy group. The average effective dose of radiation exposure for a patient during transforaminal endoscopy was 4,4 mSv, for interlaminar endoscopic techniques and microsurgery - 0,8 mSv. The proportions of complications and repeated operations in both groups were comparable. The risk of recurrence was 10% for the endoscopic group, 4,8% for the microsurgical group. Significant differences in terms of local and radicular pain, quality of life and the physical component of health have not been established. The mental component of health was the best in the endoscopic group. Good and excellent results on the MacNab treatment satisfaction scale in the endoscopy group were observed in 78,2% of cases, after microdiscectomy - in84,9%. Lower invasiveness of percutaneous endoscopy affected the reduction in the period of hospitalization and disability. The effectiveness of percutaneous endoscopic discectomy methods was comparable to standard microsurgical techniques. A statistically insignificant increase in the risk of hernia recurrence after percutaneous endoscopic discectomy was noted. Infectious complications were not typical for percutaneous endoscopic discectomy. Differences in the frequency of complications and reoperations between percutaneous endoscopic and microsurgical lumbar discectomy are also not confirmed.

About the authors

M N Kravtsov

Военно-медицинская академия им. С.М. Кирова

Email: vmeda-nio@mil.ru
Санкт-Петербург

S D Mirzametov

Военно-медицинская академия им. С.М. Кирова

Email: vmeda-nio@mil.ru
Санкт-Петербург

V N Malakhovskiy

Военно-медицинская академия им. С.М. Кирова

Email: vmeda-nio@mil.ru
Санкт-Петербург

B V Gaidar

Военно-медицинская академия им. С.М. Кирова

Email: vmeda-nio@mil.ru
Санкт-Петербург

D V Svistov

Военно-медицинская академия им. С.М. Кирова

Email: vmeda-nio@mil.ru
Санкт-Петербург

References

  1. Амирджанова, В.Н. Популяционные показатели качества жиз- ни по опроснику SF-36 (результаты многоцентрового ис- следования качества жизни «МИРАЖ») / В.Н. Амирджанова [и др.] // Научн.-практ. ревматол. - 2008. - № 1. - C. 36-48.
  2. Бывальцев, В.А. Использование шкал и анкет в вертебрологии / В.А. Бывальцев [и др.] // Журн. невролог. и психиатр. им. С.С. Корсакова. - 2011. - № 9 (111). - С. 51-56.
  3. Волков, И.В. Результаты трансфораминальной эндоскопи- ческой дискэктомии при грыжах межпозвонковых дисков 36 4 (64) - 2018 ВЕСТНИК РОССИЙСКОЙ ВОЕННО-МЕДИЦИНСКОЙ АКАДЕМИИ Клинические исследования поясничнокрестцового отдела позвоночника / И.В. Волков [и др.] // Травматол. и ортопед. России. - 2017. - № 3 (23). - С. 32-42.
  4. Зорин, Н. А. Сравнительная оценка эффективности эндоско- пической трансфораминальной микродискэктомии и от- крытой микродискэктомии в лечении грыж межпозвонковых дисков поясничного отдела позвоночника / Н.А. Зорин [и др.] // Укр. нейрохір. журн. - 2014. - № 3. - С. 61-65.
  5. Контроль эффективных доз облучения пациентов при меди- цинских рентгенологических исследованиях: методические указания МУ 2.6.1.2944- 11. // М.: Роспотребнадзор. - 2011. - С. 32.
  6. Chen, Z. Percutaneous transforaminal endoscopic discectomy compared with microendoscopic discectomy for lumbar disc herniation: 1-year results of an ongoing randomized controlled trial / Z. Chen [et al.] // Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine. - 2018. - № 3 (28). - P. 300-310
  7. Choi, G. Percutaneous endoscopic interlaminar discectomy for intracanalicular disc herniations at L5-S1 using a rigid working channel endoscope. / G. Choi [et al.] // Operative Neurosurgery. - 2006. - № 1 (58). - P. 59-68.
  8. Dezawa, A. Percutaneous endoscopic translaminar approach for herniated nucleus pulposus in the hidden zone of the lumbar spine / A. Dezawa, H. Mikami, K. Sairyo //Asian journal of endoscopic surgery. - 2012. - № 4 (5). - P. 200-203.
  9. Gibson, J.N.A. A randomised controlled trial of transforaminal endoscopic discectomy vs microdiscectomy / J.N.A. Gibson, A.S. Subramanian, C.E.H. Scott. // European Spine Journal. - 2017. - № 3 (26). - P. 847-856.
  10. Iprenburg, M. Transforaminal endoscopic surgery - technique and provisional results in primary disc herniation / M. Iprenburg // Eur. Musculoskelet Rev. - 2007. - № 2. - P. 73-76.
  11. Kim, M. A Comparison of Percutaneous Endoscopic Lumbar Discectomy and Open Lumbar Microdiscectomy for Lumbar Disc Herniation in the Korean: A Meta-Analysis / M. Kim [et al.] // BioMed research international. - 2018. - P. 623-630.
  12. Lee, S. Percutaneous endoscopic lumbar discectomy for migrated disc herniation: classification of disc migration and surgical approaches / S. Lee [et al.] // European Spine Journal. - 2007. - № 3 (16). - P. 431-437
  13. Lee, Y.S. et al. Analysis of radiation risk to patients from intra- operative use of the mobile X-ray system (C-arm) / Y. S. Lee [et al.] // J. Res Med Sci. - 2015. - № 1 (20). - P. 7.
  14. Liu, X. Comparison of percutaneous endoscopic transforaminal discectomy, microendoscopic discectomy, and microdiscectomy for symptomatic lumbar disc herniation: minimum 2-year follow- up results / X. Liu [et al.] // Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine. - 2018. - № 3 (28). - P. 317-325.
  15. Ruetten, S. An extreme lateral access for the surgery of lumbar disc herniations inside the spinal canal using the full-endoscopic uniportal transforaminal approach-technique and prospective results of 463 patients / S. Ruetten, M. Komp, G. Godolias // Spine. - 2005. - № 22 (30). - P. 2570-2578.
  16. Ruetten, S.A New Full-Endoscopic Technique for the Interlaminar Operation of Lumbar Disc Herniations Using 6-mm Endoscopes: Prospective 2-Year Results of 331 Patients / S. Ruetten, M. Komp, G. Godolias // MIN. - 2006. - № 2 (49). - P. 80-87.
  17. Ruetten, S. Use of newly developed instruments and endoscopes: full-endoscopic resection of lumbar disc herniations via the interlaminar and lateral transforaminal approach / S. Ruetten [et al.] // Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine. - 2007. - № 6 (6). - P. 521-530.
  18. Ruetten, S. Full-endoscopic interlaminar and transforaminal lumbar discectomy versus conventional microsurgical technique: a prospective, randomized, controlled study / S. Ruetten [et al.] //Spine. - 2008. - № 9 (33). - P. 931-939.
  19. Schubert, M. Endoscopic transforaminal nucleotomy with foraminoplasty for lumbar disk herniation / M. Schubert, T. Hoogland // Oper Orthop Traumatol. - 2005. - № 6 (17). - P. 641-661.
  20. Wang, H. Effect of percutaneous transforaminal lumbar spine endoscopic discectomy on lumbar disc herniation and its influence on indexes of oxidative stress / H. Wang, Y. Song, L. Cai // Biomedical Research. - 2017. - № 21 (28) - P. 9464-9469.
  21. Yeung, A.T. Posterolateral endoscopic excision for lumbar disc herniation: Surgical technique, outcome, and complications in consecutive cases / A.T. Yeung, P. M. Tsou // Spine (Phila Pa 1976). - 2002. - № 7 (27). - P. 722-731.

Copyright (c) 2018 Kravtsov M.N., Mirzametov S.D., Malakhovskiy V.N., Gaidar B.V., Svistov D.V.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies