After psychotherapy

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

The article analyzes the problem of long-term psychotherapy from the point of view of the criteria of expediency and effectiveness. Options for termination and continuation of psychotherapy by clients/patients and their consequences are considered. The question is raised about the need to develop a strategy for moving from face-to-face psychotherapy to methods of supporting self-regulation, in particular using mobile applications. Data on the demand and effectiveness of these approaches are provided. As a supportive psychotherapy, the possibility of using the Master Kit technique, designed for the independent work of a person with his/her beliefs, settings, emotional states (fears, offense), unknown qualities, self-esteem, is assessed. It is concluded that the development of a strategy of supporting digital self-regulation is promising.

About the authors

Darya  R.  Trutneva

Research Institute for Self-Regulation

Email: info@risr.institute
Russian Federation, 420012, Kazan, Professor, 3

Vladimir D. Mendelevich

Kazan State Medical University

Author for correspondence.
Email: mend@tbit.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-8489-3130
Scopus Author ID: 6602765981
ResearcherId: O-4908-2016

MD, PhD, head of Department of Medical Psychology

Russian Federation, 420012, Kazan, Butlerova Str., 49

References

  1. Холмогорова А.Б., Гаранян Н.Г., Никитина И.В., Пуговкина О.Д. Научные исследования процесса психотерапии и её эффективности: современное состояние проблемы. Часть 2. Социал. и клин. психиатрия. 2010; 1: 70–79. [Holmogorova A.B., Garanyan N.G., Nikitina I.V., Pugovkina O.D. Nauchny`e issledovaniya processa psixoterapii i eyo e`ffektivnosti: sovremennoe sostoyanie problemy`. Chast` 2. Social`naya i klinicheskaya psihiatriya. 2010; 1: 70–79. (In Russ.)]
  2. Менделевич В.Д. Доказательная психотерапия: между возможным и необходимым. Неврологич. вестн. 2019; 2: 4–11. [Mendelevich V.D. Dokazatel’naya psihoterapiya: mezhdu vozmozhnym i neobhodimym. Nevrologicheskij vestnik. 2019; 2: 4–11. (In Russ.)]
  3. Каган В.Е. Дистантная психотерапия: вызовы и границы. 2019. https://psy.su/feed/7644/ (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Kagan V.E. Distantnaya psixoterapiya: vy`zovy` i granicy. 2019. https://psy.su/feed/7644/ (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  4. Сахновская О.С. Окончание терапии и постаналитический период. http://psychoanalitiki.ru/q-q.html (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Sahnovskaya O.S. Okonchanie terapii i postanaliticheskij period. http://psychoanalitiki.ru/q-q.html (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  5. Lorentzen S., Strauss B., Altmann U. Process-outcome relationships in short- and long-term psychodynamic group psychotherapy: Result from a randomized clinical trial. Group Dynamics: Theory, Res. Pract. 2018; 22 (2): 93–107. doi: 10.1037/gdn0000084.
  6. Lemmens L.H.J.M., van Bronswijk S.C., Peeters F. et al. Long-term outcomes of acute treatment with cognitive therapy v. interpersonal psychotherapy for adult depression: follow-up of a randomized control trial. Psychol. Med. 2019; 49 (3): 465–473. doi: 10.1017/S0033291718001083.
  7. Wucherpfennig F., Boyle K., Rubel J.A. et al. What sticks? Patients perspectives on treatment three years after psychotherapy: a mixed-methods approach. Psychother. Res. 2019: 27: 1–14. doi: 10.1080/10503307.2019.1671630.
  8. Steinert C., Hofmann M., Kruse J., Leichsenring F. Relapse rates after psychotherapy for depression — stable long-term effects? A meta-analysis. J. Affect. Disord. 2014; 168: 107–118. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2014.06.043.
  9. Иванова Т.Н. Уход клиента и завершение терапии: размышления о чувствах терапевта. https://www.b17.ru/article/uxod_klienta_chuvstva_terapevta/ (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Ivanova T.N. Uhod klienta i zavershenie terapii: razmy`shleniya o chuvstvax terapevta. https://www.b17.ru/article/uxod_klienta_chuvstva_terapevta/ (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  10. Van Bronswijk S.C., Lemmens L.H., Keefe J.R. et al. A prognostic index for long-term outcome after successful acute phase cognitive therapy and interpersonal psychotherapy for major depressive disorder. Depress. Anxiety. 2019; 36: 252–261. doi: 10.1002/da.22868.
  11. Knekt P., Virtala E., Härkänen T. et al. The outcome of short- and long-term psychotherapy 10 years after start of treatment. Psychol. Med. 2016; 46 (6): 1175–1188. doi: 10.1017/S0033291715002718.
  12. MacLeed M., Martinez R., Williams C. Cognitive behaviour therapy self-help: who does it help and what are its drawbacks? Behav. Cog. Psychother. 2009; 37 (1): 71–72. doi: 10.1017/S1352465808005031.
  13. Результат и длительность психотерапии как процесса. Размышления клиента. http://my-self.ru/stati/samorazvitie/rezultat-i-dlitelnost-psixoterapii-kak-processa.-razmishleniya-klienta.html (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Rezul`tat i dlitel`nost` psixoterapii kak processa. Razmy`shleniya klienta. http://my-self.ru/stati/samorazvitie/rezultat-i-dlitelnost-psixoterapii-kak-processa.-razmishleniya-klienta.html (access data: 23.11.2019). In Russ.]
  14. Ялом И. Дар психотерапии. М.: ЭКСМО. 2015; 250 с. [Yalom I. Dar psixoterapii. Moscow: E`KSMO. 2015; 250 р. In Russ.]
  15. Денисова И. Житейские истории, или психотерапия как жизнь, а жизнь как психотерапия. Просто о сложном. М.: Издательские решения. 2019; 61 с. [Denisova I. Zhitejskie istorii, ili Psihoterapiya kak zhizn`, a zhizn` kak psixoterapiya. Prosto o slozhnom. Moscow: Izdatel`skie resheniya. 2019; 61 р. (In Russ.)]
  16. Балабанова Е.А. Конец терапевтических отношений, или почему мы боимся ухода клиентов. Клин. и мед. психол.: исследования, обучение, практика. 2014; 2 (4). http://medpsy.ru/climp (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Balabanova E.A. Konec terapevticheskih otnoshenij ili pochemu my boimsya uhoda klientov. Klinicheskaya i medicinskaya psihologiya: issledovaniya, obuchenie, praktika. 2014; 2 (4). http://medpsy.ru/climp (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  17. Гарфильд С. Достижения краткосрочной психотерапии. СПб.: Питер. 2-е издание. 2002; 256 с. [Garfil`d S. Dostizheniya kratkosrochnoj psixoterapii. St.Petersburg: Piter. 2-e izdanie. 2002; 256 р. (In Russ.)]
  18. Иванова Т.А. Как долго длится психотерапия? 2017. http: //psykonsultacii.ru/psikhologicheskie_uslugi/kak_dolgo_dlitsja_psikhoterapija. (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Ivanova T.A. Kak dolgo dlitsya psixoterapiya? 2017. http://psykonsultacii.ru/psikhologicheskie_uslugi/kak_dolgo_dlitsja_psikhoterapija. (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  19. Менделевич В.Д. Психотерапия на грани иррационализма. Проф. психотерапевтич. газета. 2005; 4 (31). [Mendelevich V.D. Psixoterapiya na grani irracionalizma. Professional`naya psixoterapevticheskaya gazeta. 2005; 4 (31). (In Russ.)]
  20. Трутнева Д.Р., Менделевич В.Д. Психотерапия без психотерапевта. Неврологич. вестн. 2019. 3: 20–27. [Trutneva D.R., Mendelevich V.D. Psixoterapiya bez psixoterapevta. Nevrologicheskij vestnik. 2019. 3: 20–27. (In Russ.)]
  21. Meinischmidt G., Tegethoff M. Psychotherapy: Quo vadis? Fortschr. Neurol. Psychiatr. 2017; 85 (8): 479–494. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-113131.
  22. Iakimova G., Dimitrova S., Bune T. Can we do therapy without therapist? Active components of computer-based CBT for depression. Encephale. 2017; 43 (6): 582–593. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2016.08.006.
  23. Castle-Clarke S., Imison C. The digital patient: transforming primary care. London. 2016; 69.
  24. Kumar V., Sattar Y., Bseiso A. et al. The effectiveness of internet-based cognitive therapy in treatment of psychiatric disorders. Cureus. 2017; 9 (8): e1626. doi: 10.7759/cureus.1626.
  25. Hirano M., Ogura K., Kitahara M. et al. Designing behavioral self-regulation application for preventive personal mental healthcare. Health Psychol. Open. 2017; 1: 1–9. doi: 10.1177/2055102917707185.
  26. Zwerenz R., Becker J., Knickenberg R.J. et al. Online self-help as an add-on to inpatient psychotherapy: efficacy of a new blended treatment approach. Psychother. Psychosom. 2017; 86 (6): 341–350. doi: 10.1159/000481177.
  27. Wasil A.R., Venturo-Conerly K.E., Shingleton R.M., Weisz J.R. Areview of popular smartphone apps for depression and anxiety: assessing the inclusion of evidence-based content. Behav. Res. Therap. 2019; 123: 103498. doi: 10.1016/j.brat.2019.103498.
  28. Bakker D., Kazantzis N., Rickwood D., Rickard N. A randomized controlled trial of three smartphone apps for enhancing public mental health. Behav. Res. Therap. 2018; 109: 75–83. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2018.08.003 (access date: 23.11.2019).
  29. Colombo D., Fernández-Álvarez J., García Palacios A. et al. New technologies for the understanding, assessment, and intervention of emotion regulation. Front. Psychol. 2019. 10: 1261. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01261.
  30. Kenter R.M.F., Cuijpers P., Beekman A., van Straten A. Effectiveness of a web-based guided self-help intervention for outpatients with a depressive disorder: Short-term results from a randomized controlled trial. J. Med. Intern. Res. 2016; 18 (3): e80. doi: 10.2196/jmir.4861.
  31. Geraedts A.S., Kleiboer A.M., Twisk J. et al. Long-term results of a web-based guided self-help intervention for employees with depressive symptoms: Randomized controlled trial. J. Med. Intern. Res. 2014; 16 (7): e168. doi: 10.2196/jmir.3539.
  32. Нестик Т.А. Развитие цифровых технологий и будущее психологии. Вестн. Московского гос. обл. ун-та. Серия: Психологические науки. 2017; 3: 6–15. [Nestik T.A. Razvitie cifrovy`h tehnologij i budushhee psihologii. Vestnik Moskovskogo gosudarstvennogo oblastnogo universiteta. Seriya: Psihologicheskie nauki. 2017; 3: 6–15. doi: 10.18384/2310-7235-2017-3-6-15. (In Russ.)]
  33. Barak A., Gronol J.M. Current and future trends in internet-supported mental health interventions. J. Technol. Human Services. 2011; 29: 155–196. doi: 10.1080/15228835.2011.616939.
  34. Fleming T., Bavin L., Lucassen M. et al. Beyond the trial: Systematic review of real-world uptake and engagement with digital self-help interventions for depression, low mood, or anxiety. Med. Intern. Res. 2018; 20 (6): e199. doi: 10.2196/jmir.9275.
  35. Fairburn C.G., Patel V. The impact of digital technology on psychological treatments and their dissemination. Behav. Res. Therap. 2017; 88: 19–25. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2016.08.012 (access date: 23.11.2019).
  36. Byambasuren O., Sanders Sh., Beller E., Glasziou P. Prescribable mHealth apps identified from an overview of systematic reviews. Digital Med. 2018; 1: 12. doi: 10.1038/s41746-018-0021-9.
  37. Bell S., Wood C., Sarkar A. Perception of chatbots in therapy. CHI’19 Extended abstracts, May 4–9, 2019. Glasgow, Scotland UK. https://doi.org/10.1145/3290607.3313072 (access date: 23.11.2019).
  38. Lui J., Marcus D.K., Barry C.T. Evidence-based apps? A review of mental health mobile applications in a psychotherapy context. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice. Advance online publication. 2017; Feb. 20. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/pro0000122 (access date: 23.11.2019).
  39. Carlbring P., Andersson G., Cuijpers P. et al. Internet-based vs. face-to-face cognitive behavior therapy for psychiatric and somatic disorders: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Cognitive Behav. Therap. 2018; 47 (1): 1–18. doi: 10.1080/16506073.2017.1401115.
  40. Иванов В.Г., Лазарева Е.Ю., Николаев E.Л. Применение современных информационно-коммуникационных технологий в психотерапевтической и психологической практике (обзор зарубежных исследований). Пробл. соврем. педагогич. образования. 2017; 57: 321–329. [Ivanov V.G., Lazareva E.Yu., Nikolaev E.L. Primenenie sovremenny`h informacionno-kommunikacionny`h tehnologij v psihoterapevticheskoj i psihologicheskoj praktike (obzor zarubezhny`h issledovanij). Problemy` sovremennogo pedagogicheskogo obrazovaniya. 2017; 57: 321–329. (In Russ.)]
  41. Хоффман X. Целительная виртуальная реальность. В мире науки. 2004; 11: 36–43. [Hoffman H. Celitel`naya virtual`naya real`nost`. V mire nauki. 2004; 11: 36–43. (In Russ.)]
  42. Bakker D., Kazantzis N., Rickwood D., Rickard N. Mental health smartphone apps: Review and evidence-based recommendations for future developments. JMIR Mental Health. 2016; 3 (1). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4795320 (access date: 23.11.2019).
  43. Kauer S.D. Self-monitoring using mobile phones in the early stages of adolescent depression: Randomized controlled trial. J. Med. Intern. Res. 2012; 14 (3). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3414872/ (access date: 23.11.2019).
  44. Morris M.E., Kathawala Q., Leen T.K. et al. Mobile therapy: case study evaluations of a cell phone application for emotional self-awareness. J. Med. Intern. Res. 2010; 12 (2): e10. doi: 10.2196/jmir.1371.
  45. So M. Is computerised CBT really helpful for adult depression? A meta-analytic re-evaluation of CCBT for adult depression in terms of clinical implementation and methodological validity. BMC Psychiatry. 2013; 13: 113. doi: 10.1186/1471-244X-13-113.
  46. Watts S., Mackenzie A., Thomas C. CBT for depression. A pilot RCT comparing mobile phone vs. computer. BMC Psychiatry. 2013; 13: 49. doi: 10.1186/1471-244X-13-49.
  47. Сучилина Д. Цифровая психотерапия: как новые технологии меняют индустрию психологической помощи. http: //posta-magazine.ru/psychology/digital-psychology (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Suchilina D. Cifrovaya psihoterapiya: kak novy`e tehnologii menyayut industriyu psihologicheskoj pomoshhi. http://posta-magazine.ru/psychology/digital-psychology (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  48. Arnberg F.K., Linton S.J., Hultcrantz M. et al. Internet-delivered psychological treatments for mood and anxiety disorders: A systematic review of their efficacy, safety, and cost-effectiveness. PLoS ONE. 2014; 9 (5): 45–52. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0098118.
  49. Граница А.С. Компьютерные технологии в психотерапии и саморегуляции. Саморегуляция. 2019; 2: 17–37. [Granicza A.S. Komp`yuterny`e tehnologii v psihoterapii i samoregulyacii. Samoregulyaciya. 2019; 2: 17–37. (In Russ.)]
  50. King R.J., Orr J.A., Poulsen B. et al. Understanding the therapists contribution to psychotherapy outcomes: a meta-analytic approach. Adm. Polocy. Ment. Health. 2017; 44: 664-680. doi: 10.1007/s10488-016-0783-9.
  51. Renn B.N., Hoeft T.J., Lee H.S. et al. Preference for in-person psychotherapy versus digital psychotherapy options for depression: survey of adults in the U.S. Digital Med. 2019; 6. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41746-019-0077-1 (access data: 23.11.2019).
  52. Zwerenz R., Baumgarten C., Becker J. et al. Improving the course of depressive symptoms after inpatient psychotherapy using adjunct web-based self-help: follow-up results of a randomized controlled trial. J. Med. Intern. Res. 2019; 21 (10): e13655. doi: 10.2196/13655.
  53. Digital Health: Evaluating the Evidence, Identifying Gaps, Producing Better Science. The Growing Value of Digital Health. IQVIA Institute. 2018. https://www.ispor.org/docs/default-source/presentations/1371.pdf?sfvrsn=8d6d3e24_1 (access data: 23.11.2019).
  54. Раевский С., Милушина Е., Никитина О., Бабенко А. «АНТИПАНИКА» — мобильная таблетка, мобильный психотерапевт — миф или реальность? http://mental-health-russia.ru/news2/323/116/antipanika-mobilnaya-tabletka-mobilnyj-psihoterapevt-mif-ili-realnost/. (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Raevskij S., Milushina E., Nikitina O., Babenko A. “ANTIPANIKA” — mobil`naya tabletka, mobil`ny`j psihoterapevt — mif ili real`nost`? http://mental-health-russia.ru/news2/323/116/antipanika-mobilnaya-tabletka-mobilnyj-psihoterapevt-mif-ili-realnost (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  55. Дьяков Д.Г., Слонова А.И. Метод mindfulness как центральное направление «третьей волны» когнитивно-поведенческого подхода. Актуал. пробл. гуманитарных и социал.-экономич. наук. 2017; 11: 160–163. [D`yakov D.G., Slonova A.I. Metod mindfulness kak central`noe napravlenie «tret`ej volny`» kognitivno-povedencheskogo podhoda. Aktual`ny`e problemy` gumanitarny`h i social`no-e`konomicheskih nauk. 2017; 11: 160–163. (In Russ.)]
  56. Ковпак Д.В. Использование отдельных видов когнитивно-поведенческой терапии «третьей волны» и концепта майндфулнесс в терапии хронической боли и депрессии. Психосоматика и психорегуляция. 2016; 1 (5): 30–42. [Kovpak D.V. Ispol`zovanie otdel`ny`h vidov kognitivno-povedencheskoj terapii “tret`ej volny`” i koncepta majndfulness v terapii hronicheskoj boli i depressii. Psihosomatika i psihoregulyaciya. 2016; 1 (5): 30–42. (In Russ.)]
  57. Champion L., Economides M., Chandler C. The efficacy of a brief app-based mindfulness intervention on psychosocial outcomes in healthy adults: A pilot randomized controlled trial. PLoS ONE. 2018; 13 (12): e0209482. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0209482.
  58. Moberg Ch., Niles A., Beermann D. Guided self-help works: Randomized waitlist controlled trial of pacifica, a mobile app integrating cognitive behavioral therapy and mindfulness for stress, anxiety, and depression. J. Med. Internet. Res. 2019; 21 (6): e12556. doi: 10.2196/12556.
  59. Spijkerman M.P.J., Pots W.T.M., Bohlmeijer E.T. Effectiveness of online mindfulness-based interventions in improving mental health. A review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Clin. Psychol. Rev. 2016; 45: 102–114. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2016.03.009.
  60. Van Emmerik A.A.P., Berings F., Lancee J. Efficacy of a mindfulness-based mobile application: a randomized waiting-list controlled trial. Mindfulness. 2017; 6 (1): 189–112. doi: 10.1007/s12671-017-0761-7.
  61. Методическое пособие по методике Master Kit. Казань: НИИ саморегуляции. 2018; 43 с. [Metodicheskoe posobie po metodike Master Kit. Kazan’: NII samoregulyacii. 2018; 43 р. (In Russ.)]
  62. Трутнева Д.Р. Изменение психологических особенностей пользователей Master Kit в зависимости от длительности использования методики и количества проработок. Казань. НИИ саморегуляции. https://risr.institute/publication/25 (дата обращения: 23.11.2019). [Trutneva D.R. Izmenenie psihologicheskih osobennostej pol’zovatelej Master Kit v zavisimosti ot dlitel’nosti ispol’zovaniya metodiki i kolichestva prorabotok. Kazan’. NII samoregulyacii. https://risr.institute/publication/25 (access data: 23.11.2019). (In Russ.)]
  63. Тимиргалеев А.Р. Исследование компонента осознанности пользователей программы-тренажёра Master Kit. Саморегуляция. 2019; 2: 47–56. [Timirgaleev A.R. Issledovanie komponenta osoznannosti pol`zovatelej programmy`-trenazhyora Master Kit. Samoregulyaciya. 2019; 2: 47–56. In Russ.]

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download
2. Fig. 1. The distribution of "healing" mobile applications by nosology (%) [53]; ENT - ENT; GIT - gastrointestinal; SS - Cardiovascular

Download (110KB)
Indexing metadata
3. Fig. 2. The dynamics of the number of scientific publications devoted to “healing” mobile applications [53]; 1 - observational study; 2 - a randomized controlled trial; 3 - a systematic review or critically evaluated topics; 4 - meta-analysis

Download (60KB)
Indexing metadata

Copyright (c) 2020 Trutneva D.R., Mendelevich V.D.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies