Is the “human capacity” formula categorical?
- Authors: Kleandrov M.I.1
-
Affiliations:
- Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences
- Issue: No 10 (2025)
- Pages: 70-82
- Section: Discussions and debates
- URL: https://journals.rcsi.science/1026-9452/article/view/327960
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.31857/S1026945225100054
- ID: 327960
Cite item
Abstract
The article analyzes the formula of legal capacity, proclaimed in Part 2 of Art. 17 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation: “The legal capacity of a citizen arises at the time of his birth and ends with death”. The author considers the categorical nature of this legislative postulate to be incorrect, moreover, in both postulates. The first substantiates the situation in which a person in his development goes through two stages: from the moment of his conception to the moment of his birth, and from the moment of his birth to his death. And at both stages it must be regarded as a bearer of subjective rights. Moreover, if the second stage has always and everywhere been in the center of attention of the legislator, then the first, with minor exceptions, is outside legal support. Nevertheless, the human embryo in the womb of a pregnant woman is, together with her, in the legal field of criminal, labor, family, inheritance, housing, and civil legislation. In the second, taking into account the achievements of modern biological (and other industries) science, the author believes that a cryonized, terminally ill person, who is considered, in the legal sense, dead, after a hundred, for example, years, can be thawed and cured. It is noted that there are, including in Russia, clinics specializing in this. The author considers it necessary to expand accordingly, in both directions, the concept of legal capacity.
About the authors
M. I. Kleandrov
Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences
Author for correspondence.
Email: mklean@bk.ru
Moscow
References
- Afanasyev I. V., Mashkov A. V. The status of a human embryo in hereditary law and the legal problems arising from it // Modern law. 2022. No. 1 (in Russ.).
- Belobragina N. A. Legal status of the embryo // News of TulSU. Economic and legal sciences. 2013. No. 1–2. P. 36 (in Russ.).
- Vinogradov A. Some love colder. Already four people were allowed to freeze themselves in liquid nitrogen, hoping for a future resurrection // Ross. gaz. 2007. 31 August (in Russ.).
- Gabdullina E. The law did not notice the loss of his father. The Constitutional Court is considering the right to support for children conceived from the sperm of the deceased // Kommersant. 2024. 23 October (in Russ.).
- Eremeeva O. I., Sayfullina N. A. To the question of the concept and legal status of a human embryo // Innovative Science. 2016. No. 3 (in Russ.).
- Kleandrov M. I. Legal status of a human embryo // Problems of formation, preservation, restoration and promotion of health (medical, biological, environmental, psychological and pedagogical, socio-economic, philosophical, legal aspects of valeology): sat. scientific works. M.; Tyumen, 1995. No. IX. Pp. 181– 185 (in Russ.).
- Lebedeva D. A. Legal model for the regulation of cry preserved embryos // Medical Law and Practice. 2022. No. 3–4 (in Russ.).
- Mokhov A. A. Unborn child – subject of legal relations? // Fami- ly and Housing Law. 2019. No. 4. Pp. 14–78 (in Russ.).
- Nevinnaya I. Not a woman’s business. A robot is being created that can carry and bear children. Is it real? // Ross. gaz. – week. 2024. 7 November (in Russ.).
- Ofman E. M. Abuse of the right to pregnant women // Personnel. Labor Law for a personnel officer. 2010. No. 4. Pp. 13–19 (in Russ.).
- Panichkin V. B. Death as a basis for termination of legal capacity: a comparative analysis of the law of Russia and the USA. URL: https://online11.consultant.ru/cqi/online.cqi?req=doc&ts=8EU5JtTuYZO83Pwt1&cacheid=9C7FB2A0E1FE9F5055BAFBBB16AFB634&mode=spl… (in Russ.).
- Pisarenko D. Canned people. Sperm, egg, brain – then the whole body // Arguments and facts. 2006. No. 22 (in Russ.).
- Rogovaya M. Survivors in the permafrost // Kommersant- Nauka. 2023. November (in Russ.).
- Trubetskoy E. N. Lectures on the Encyclopedia of Law. M., 1917. P. 166 (in Russ.).
- Chebysheva K. Clients believe in immortality. They promise to wake them up in 50 years … // Labor. 2006. 17 May (in Russ.).
- Shindyapin S. E. On the issue of the moment of recognition of the legal capacity of a human embryo // Herald of TSU. 2014. No. 12 (140) (in Russ.).
- Yarosh A. V. The legal status of the embryo as an object of family values // State and Law. 2021. No. 5. Pp. 136–143 (in Russ.).
Supplementary files
