Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Access granted  Restricted Access Subscription Access

No 6 (2025)

Cover Page

Full Issue

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Special Theme of the Issue: Housing and Communal Services in the North: Living Environment in the Conditions of Remoteness and Deficit

Northern Dimension of Housing and Communal Services: An Anthropological Perspective

Goncharov N.S., Davydov V.N.

Abstract

This article is an introduction to the issue’s special theme on “Housing and Communal Services in the North: Living Environment in the Conditions of Remoteness and Deficit”, featuring contributions by Nikolai Goncharov, Vasilisa Bobrova, Vladimir Davydov, and Olga Shulgina. The proposed selection of articles is aimed at the ethnographic study of public utility in the Arctic and Subarctic. The unifying goal of the publications is to determine the place of public utility in the system of subsistence of the communities of the Arkhangelsk Oblast’, Taimyr, the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) and Chukotka. Based on their own field materials, the authors study regional gaps and affordances of public utility, problematizing the very concept of this sector of the economy, considering the heterogeneity of sources of electricity, heat and water, studying the hybridization of local and centralized systems, and analyzing solid waste disposal strategies in the Arctic. The conclusions made in the article, reflecting the specifics of the relationship between people and public utility, allow us to reconsider the set of adaptive strategies and responses of the permanent population of the North to emerging socio-economic and ecological challenges.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):7–13
pages 7–13 views

Heterogeneity of the Public Utility Services: Ethnography of Sources of Electricity, Heat, and Water in Yakutia and the Arkhangelsk Region

Goncharov N.S.

Abstract

Drawing on ethnographic field materials, I revise the generic approach to defining public utility, that does not take into account the heterogeneity of local conditions and keeps the specialized public utility and the users of its services as separate entities. Cases of providing the population of Arkhangelsk Region’s Lensky District and Republic of Sakha’s (Yakutia’s) Ust-Yansky District with electricity, heat, and water show that in the northern regions of Russia, there are many gaps in the official public utility services that local residents fill as they see fit. Dependence on the centralized resources of unreliable organizations deconstructs the passivity of “consumers”, turning them into an agent subject. Despite the different natural conditions and the degree of inclusion in the country’s transportation system, residents of the areas under study use similar strategies to compensate for the “gaps” in the activities of specialized actors, aimed at concentrating, hybridizing, supplementing, and adjusting the services of official public utility. Critically using P. Edwards’ multi-scale approach to infrastructure, I suggest the term “immanent public utility” as a concept that helps generalize the complex of practices through which the population of the North receives important resources for subsistence.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):14–36
pages 14–36 views

Taimyr’s Ecological Challenges: Local Strategies for Recycling Municipal Solid Waste

Bobrova V.V.

Abstract

The article discusses the issue of landfills and recycling municipal solid waste in settlements of the Arctic. In the conditions of the Far North, aggravated by severe climates, landscape features, and insufficiently developed infrastructure for waste disposal, this issue is crucial and often difficult to solve in practice. The article is conceived as an attempt to consider the local experience of Taimyr residents in regard to waste disposal. Responding to arising challenges, local residents devise various strategies for solving the issue and dealing with the increase in the amount of municipal solid waste, the organization of technological landfills, the logistics of waste removal, and the lack of recycling plants. These strategies range from arranging specialized places for recycling to mobilizing volunteer movements for cleaning. The article draws on field materials collected over the past few years in the Taimyr Dolgano-Nenets municipal district of the Krasnoyarsk Krai in the following settlements: Khatanga, Kresty, Novaya, Kheta, Katyryk, Zhdanikha, Novorybnaya, Ust-Avam, Volochanka, Levinskiye Peski.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):37–50
pages 37–50 views

Housing and Communal Services and Subsidiary Economy in Chukotka: Dynamics of Materiality of the Northern Village

Davydov V.N.

Abstract

Drawing on field materials collected in 2018–2023, the article examines the features of the functioning of housing and communal services and subsidiary farming in remote villages of Chukotka. The focus of the study is the strategy of connecting local systems to centralized ones, which allows us to conclude that the economy of northern villages has a hybrid structure, where private farming largely exists due to the availability of state-funded infrastructure. I show how local people gain access to state-provided resources — electricity, heating networks, water supply and building materials, acquiring resources for running a subsidiary farm, constructing and maintaining greenhouses, sheds, garages and other buildings that act as “plugins” built into the housing and communal services structure. The peculiarity of the projects implemented in the North is manifested in their fundamental incompleteness, and for their implementation it is necessary to supplement them with other projects. In this context, the infrastructure supported by state funding gives the local population a certain freedom for creativity. A private subsidiary farm is able to carry out its daily tasks in remote conditions largely due to the functioning of the housing and communal services.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):51–65
pages 51–65 views

Lorino Hot Springs: Soviet Experience of Land Development and Unutilized Opportunities in Chukotka

Shulgina O.M.

Abstract

Drawing on archival materials, local periodicals, photographs from the Soviet period, as well as field materials collected in 2023–2025, I examine the principal goals and reasons for the development of the Lorino Hot Springs area in the Chukotskii district of the Chukotka Autonomous Region over a period since the mid-1930s. I argue that the infrastructure built around the thermal springs came to be beneficial in the fields of food and energy security, agriculture and greenhouses, recreation and tourism (a pioneer camp, a sanatorium and a hotel were located in the immediate vicinity of the village). I further discuss various Soviet projects (for example, that of hot water supply for the village of Lorino), which were envisaged but never implemented, as well as the current state and meaning of the hot springs area in the life of the local community.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):66–80
pages 66–80 views

Discussion

Difficult Heritage: A Moral Reboot

Melnikova E.A.

Abstract

The article examines the complex issues within the field of “difficult heritage,” tracing its development in both practical application and academic analysis. It argues that current research approaches are often driven by political and ideological agendas, hindering a more nuanced understanding of how societies grapple with the past. While diverse interpretive models have emerged, the field remains largely rooted in moral judgments and ethical imperatives. I propose critical questions to stimulate discussion and move beyond the confines of existing “difficult heritage studies”, which are often burdened by moralistic perspectives. By prompting a shift in focus, this work aims to encourage a more subtle analysis of the multifaceted ways we engage with difficult past.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):81–96
pages 81–96 views

Difficult Heritage: Terms, Interpretations, Discussions

Grinko I.A., Serikova A.Y., Mochalova M.A., Khlevniuk D.O., Melnikova E.A.

Abstract

The publication is a critical discussion of the article “Difficult Heritage: A Moral Reboot” [Trudnoe nasledie: moral’naia perezagruzka] by Ekaterina Melnikova who examines the use of the concept of “difficult heritage,” tracing its development in both practical application and academic analysis. In the article, the author argues that current research approaches are often driven by political and ideological agendas, hindering a more nuanced understanding of how societies grapple with the past. While diverse interpretive models have emerged, the field remains largely rooted in moral judgments and ethical imperatives. Melnikova proposes a number of critical questions to stimulate discussion and move beyond the confines of existing “difficult heritage studies” which, in her view, are often burdened by moralistic perspectives. The participants in this discussion suggest their own views and takes on the issues raised in Melnikova’s article.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):97–118
pages 97–118 views

Human Ethology

How Robots Enter Our Lives: Latest Research on Proxemic Behavior

Fedenok J.N., Burkova V.N.

Abstract

Due to the enormous technological progress, experts predict that in the near future people will share public spaces, streets and buildings with mobile autonomous robots. They already help people with their daily tasks at home and at work. In addition to technical functions, robots are expected to have social capabilities. Developers strive to create robots that will not disturb, irritate or frighten people. But what should these new robots be like in order to comfortably, reliably and effectively cooperate with people? Should a robot take into account and obey human norms of spatial behavior? Should such interactions take place within the framework of socially and culturally acceptable norms? The solution to these questions is the central research goal of a young scientific discipline Human-Robot Interaction. This review examines modern research of proxemic interaction between robots and humans.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):119–145
pages 119–145 views

Facial Expressions in an Ordinary Conversation among Kabardinians: A Facial Analysis Employing the FaceReader System

Mezentseva A.A., Rostovtseva V.V., Dronova D.A., Butovskaya M.L.

Abstract

The aim of this study was to investigate the facial expressions of men and women that occur during conversation and independently of the emotional context. The experiment involved 115 young Kabardian men and women. Participants engaged in a 20-second conversation on a neutral topic in front of a camera in a separate room, while the experimenter stood at some distance and controlled the recording start and stop. The video recordings were subsequently analyzed using the FaceReader system for recognizing emotional expressions, which captures visible skin surface changes by breaking them down into 20 functional movement units (Action Units, AU). The results showed that both men and women demonstrated low-intensity movements during the conversation, which did not reach the visibility threshold for an untrained observer. However, certain sex differences were identified among these movements. Women exhibited more expressive movements in the areas of the eyes, nose, and lips, compared to men. Furthermore, female facial expressions differed from male ones in terms of greater diversity of expressions both in combinations of movement elements (AU) and in the number of those combinations.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):146–167
pages 146–167 views

Research Articles

Research Infrastructures of Russian Laboratories: Before and After Sanctions

Popova E.V.

Abstract

The article dives into biographies of Russian scientific labs in the context of infrastructure work, where infrastructure work is taken to mean practical activities aimed at developing scientific infrastructure and solving the problems arising along the process. This helps focusing on mobilization procedures (rather than on “structures”) that are built into relations with institutions of science management, practices of lab operation, material resources, and individual research strategies. I attempt to explore the infrastructural makeup of the Russian scientific lab and the changes it has been undergoing in the period marked by economic and political transformations and alterations in the access to global technological markets as a result of sanction policies. The research draws on the comparative analysis of two case studies based on field interviews with lab managers and staff, conducted in 2012–2024. Trying to trace the biographies of these labs from the point of their origins through the present day, I argue that the infrastructure of the regular Russian lab is essentially prone to instability, which requires specific forms of adaptation to the ever-changing conditions. That adaptation, however, may be seen as instrumental in the success of reshaping lab work – particularly after 2022 when stricter sanctions began to be imposed – and developing new collaborations with Asian institutions. The cases under examination, nevertheless, show that there has been certain shift toward applied studies at the expense of more fundamental studies in the lab work, followed, for instance, by a move away from more traditional research themes in physics or chemistry toward more interdisciplinary medical research.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):168–191
pages 168–191 views

Creating the Russian Geographical Society through the Lens of Interpersonal Communication: People and Their Apartments

Kopelev D.N., Loskutova M.V., Sergeeva K.A.

Abstract

This article examines the establishment of the Russian Geographical Society (RGS) through the lens of network analysis. The reconstruction of this process reveals a multifaceted network model that enabled various social groups to create a new intellectual and political institution. This institution was rooted in the paradigm of national development, commonly associated with the Tsar Nicholas I, which emphasized the study of the geography of sovereign space and the “Russian people”. Despite its outward homogeneity, the internal structure of this public institution was composed of heterogeneous elements. Its founders came from diverse social and professional backgrounds and held differing perspectives on the future direction of the RGS. However, they were acutely attuned to prevailing social trends and adeptly adapted to their objectives, recognizing that their primary focus was the geography of the Russian territory and its people. These priorities became central to their collective efforts, uniting them around shared professional interests while diminishing institutional hierarchies and paternalistic structures. In modeling the system surrounding the RGS, we identified event participants as key nodes within this network, with communication revolving around their interactions in the society. All participants operated within their own unique sphere of communication. However, the unifying factor for the RGS was its shift away from academic exclusivity toward broader social engagement. This approach involved actors from various professional fields, each contributing to the shared goal of studying Russia’s geographical space.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):192–211
pages 192–211 views

The “Collective Irresponsible”: On Attempts at Building a “Society” in a St. Petersburg Commune

Kotelnikov A.V.

Abstract

The article presents research of one of about two dozen (known to the author) St. Petersburg communes based on living together in large apartments. The commune is considered by the concepts of scale by Marilyn Strathern and the concept of nonscalability by Anna Tsing. Scaling refers to the homogenization of practices and actors by integrating them into a broader system of practices. Most communards avoid scaling practices, representing themselves not as a commune as a whole, but as individuals, abandoning the system of those on charge of in favor of an individual choice of one occupation or another and creating the interior decor of the commune as fundamentally stylistically heterogeneous. At the same time, communards who strive to scale establish common rules and “unifying” rituals. Their attempts are ignored or ironically deconstructed, but no objections are raised against them, so they become only the practices of individual communards. In the described commune, the reverse scaling process takes place – the de-scaling of scaling practices. Scaling practices not only fail, but, if they persist, they themselves become nonscalable. Some informants describe this situation with the emic term “collective irresponsible”.
Ethno review. 2025;(6):212–233
pages 212–233 views

Book Reviews and Critiques

pages 234–237 views
pages 238–242 views
pages 243–248 views

Согласие на обработку персональных данных

 

Используя сайт https://journals.rcsi.science, я (далее – «Пользователь» или «Субъект персональных данных») даю согласие на обработку персональных данных на этом сайте (текст Согласия) и на обработку персональных данных с помощью сервиса «Яндекс.Метрика» (текст Согласия).