Organ Donation as Synergy: Ethical and Spiritual Aspects
- Authors: Globa A.A.1, Glyantsev S.P.2, Preobrazhenskaya K.V.3
-
Affiliations:
- Gorodnitsa St. George Monastery
- Vishnevsky National Medical Research Centre for Surgery
- Dostoevsky Russian Christian Academy for the Humanities
- Issue: Vol 36, No 2 (2025)
- Pages: 124-140
- Section: Symbols. Values. Ideals
- URL: https://journals.rcsi.science/0236-2007/article/view/290831
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.31857/S0236200725020079
- ID: 290831
Abstract
The article presents the ethical and spiritual aspects of understanding donation as an act of giving or sacrifice in the context of modern transplantology practice. Medical care related to organ donation and transplantation occupies a unique position: it is in this area that a deep and comprehensive discussion of ethical and moral (spiritual) issues is needed, as well as the formation of a field of mutual communication. Doctors, patients, donors and their family members face a major dilemma when it comes to transplanting vital organs, which are culturally endowed with important personal, spiritual and symbolic meaning. For example, a heart transplant is the replacement of a diseased organ that can no longer ensure normal human life with a healthy heart taken from another person. On the other hand, it is the transplantation of an organ that was the center of one person’s spiritual life to another person who is symbolically deprived of such a center. In the context of the statistical data that researchers obtain when studying the influence of the religious factor on the understanding and ethical interpretation of the practices of transplantation of vital organs in countries around the world, the symbolic image of donation as synergy can become the key to verbalizing those internal attitudes that are latently present in spiritual culture and are capable of giving impetus to such development of biomedical discussions that will be in harmony and consonance with religious teachings.
Full Text

About the authors
Alexander A. Globa
Gorodnitsa St. George Monastery
Author for correspondence.
Email: alexxandergloba@gmail.com
Ukraine, 1, Monastyrska St., Gorodnitsa, Novograd-Volynsky District, Zhytomyr Region, 11714
Sergey P. Glyantsev
Vishnevsky National Medical Research Centre for Surgery
Email: spglyantsev@mail.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0003-2754-836X
DSc in Medicine, Professor
Russian Federation, 27, Bolshaya Serpukhovskaya St., Moscow, 117997Kira V. Preobrazhenskaya
Dostoevsky Russian Christian Academy for the Humanities
Email: kira459@list.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-6320-3057
CSc in Philosophy, Associate Professor
Russian Federation, 15, Fontanka River Emb., Saint Petersburg, 191023References
- Amosov N.M. Golosa vremen [Voices of the Times]. Moscow: Vagrius Publ., 1999.
- Antonij, mitr. (Surozhskij). O medicinskoj ehtike (Zapis’ besed s rukovoditelem religioznoj programmy Russkoj sluzhby BBC “Voskresenie”, otcom protoiereem Sergiem Gakkelem 30 iyulya–10 dekabrya 1994 g. [On Medical Ethics (Recording of Conversations with the Head of the Religious Program of the BBC Russian Service “Resurrection”, Father Archpriest Sergey Gakkel July 30–December 10, 1994]. Nezavisimyj psikhiatricheskij zhurnal, 1995. N 1. P. 52–68.
- Aristotel’. Nikomahova etika [Nicomachean Ethics]. Aristotel’. Sochineniya v 4 t. T. 4. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1983. P. 53–294.
- Aristotel’. O dushe [About the Soul]. Aristotel’. Sochineniya v 4 t. T. 1. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 1976. P. 369–450.
- Got’e S.V., Klimusheva N.F. Psikhologicheskaya adaptaciya i reabilitaciya recipientov donorskikh organov [Psychological adaptation and rehabilitation of recipients of donor organs]. Vestnik transplantologii i iskusstvennykh organov. 2016. N 18(2). P. 37–45.
- Dvoreckij I.H. Drevnegrechesko-russkij slovar’ [Ancient Greek-Russian Dictionary]. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo inostrannyh i nacional’nyh slovarej, 1958. V 2 t. T. 1.
- Dekart R. Fragmenty perepiski o cerkovnykh tainstvakh [Fragments of Correspondence about Church Sacraments]. Vestnik RKHGI. 2001. N 4. P. 86–93.
- Klimusheva N.F., Baranskaya L.T., Shmakova T.V. Risk rasstrojstv lichnostnoj adaptacii u pacientov s transplantirovannymi vnutrennimi organami [The Risk of Personality Adaptation Disorders in Patients with Transplanted Internal Organs]. Ural'skij medicinskij zhurnal. 2009. N 6(60). P. 63–69.
- Mnogoobrazie religioznykh form sovremennoj Rossii [The Variety of Religious Forms of Modern Russia]. Kollektivnaya monografiya. Otv. redaktor V.A. Egorov. St. Petersburg: RKHGA Publ., 2022.
- Palama Gr. Sv. Triady v zashchitu svyashchenno-bezmolstvuyushchikh [Triads in Defense of the Sacredly Silent]. Moscow: Kanon Publ., 1995.
- Popova O.V. Dar i donorstvo v medicine: ot al’truisticheskikh praktik k ehticheskoj propasti [Gift and Donation in Medicine: from Altruistic Practices to an Ethical Abyss]. [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. Gorizonty gumanitarnogo znaniya. 2022. № 5. P. 3–21. URL: https://journals.mosgu.ru/ggz/article/view/1698 (date of access: 24.09.2024)
- Reznik A.O., Reznik O.N. Donorstvo organov i transplantaciya: kak ob ehtom govorit'? [Organ Donation and Transplantation: how to Talk about it?] Transplantaciya i donorstvo organov. Materialy kongressa. Tezisy dokladov. Pod redakciej akademika RAN S.V. Got’e. Vestnik transplantologii i iskusstvennykh organov. 2023. T. 25. Р. 24.
- Fasmer M. Ehtimologicheskij slovar’ russkogo yazyka [Etymological Dictionary of the Russian Language]: v 4 t. 4-e izd., stereotip. Moscow: Astrel' Publ. — AST, 2007. T. 2.
- Shtajner F. Interv’yu «OrganicheskiJ» daroobmen i transplantaciya organov, razvitie ehkonomicheskoj sociologii i moral’ v mire, upravlyaemom den’gamI» [Interview “Organic” gift Exchange and Organ Transplantation, the Development of Economic Sociology and Morality in a World Ruled by Money”]. Ehkonomicheskaya sociologiya. 2014. T. 15. N 1. P. 11–18.
- Ehntelekhiya [Entelechy]. Ehnciklopedicheskij slovar’ Brokgauza i Efrona: v 86 t. (82 t. i 4 dop.). St. Petersburg, 1904. T. XLA (80). S. 855.
- Mitchell B. Liester. Personality changes following heart transplantation: The role of cellular memory. Med Hypotheses. 2020 Feb; 135:109468
- Oliver М., Woywodt А., Ahmed А., Saif I. Organ donation, transplantation and religion. Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation. 2011. Vol. 26, Iss. 2. P. 437–444.
