“Communist militarism” and the “Monroe Doctrine” in the interpretation of soviet and british political leadership, mid-1920s

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

Drawing on sources that were previously either inaccessible to researchers or poorly studied, including analytical notes by diplomatic and military experts, testimonies of direct participants in the events, as well as materials from special periodicals, the meaning and content of two concepts, “communist militarism” as interpreted by some leaders of the Comintern and the “Monroe Doctrine” as interpreted by representatives of the British establishment, are examined for the first time by means of comparative analysis. While analysing the policies of both Moscow and London in Central, East, and especially South Asia, the author seeks to identify common and specific features of both concepts in terms of their theoretical significance and practical feasibility during the so-called “era of pacifism” of the mid-1920s. Primary attention is paid to the problem of the formation of the Asian vector of foreign policy, which the Soviet leadership faced, in comparison with the desire of the British ruling circles to adapt the Empire to the realities of the industrial age.

Full Text

Restricted Access

About the authors

Evgeny Yu. Sergeev

Institute of World History, Russian Academy of Sciences

Author for correspondence.
Email: Eugene.sergeev59@gmail.com
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-7834-5824
Scopus Author ID: 56445046700

доктор исторических наук, профессор, главный научный сотрудник

Russian Federation, Moscow

References

  1. Вертинский А.В. Комиссия Саймона и борьба в политических кругах Великобритании вокруг индийской конституционной реформы (1927–1930 гг.) // Из истории буржуазной дипломатии и меж- империалистических противоречий в первой половине ХХ в. Томск, 1986. С. 57–73.
  2. Глазами разведки. СССР и Европа, 1919–1938 годы. Сборник документов из российских архивов / сост. М. Уль, В. Хаустов, В. Захаров. М., 2015.
  3. Гус М.С. Британский империализм и Восток. Харьков, 1926.
  4. Жирова Н.С. Сотрудничество индийской партии «Гадар» с Коминтерном (1922–1943). Липецк, 2016.
  5. Исэров А.А. Монро доктрина 1823 г. // Большая российская энциклопедия (БРЭ). URL: https://old.bigenc.ru/world_history/text/2228217 (дата обращения: 22.03.2024).
  6. Маздур И. Британский империализм в Индии и подготовка интервенции против СССР. М., 1933.
  7. Малкин С.Г. Патрулируя империю: колониальный контроль и военная мысль Великобритании в эпоху Интербеллума. Самара, 2024.
  8. Мамаева Н.Л. Коминтерн и Гоминьдан. 1919–1929. М., 1999.
  9. Миняжетдинов И.Х. Коминтерн в «английском» Ираке: в поисках правильного ракурса // Коминтерн и Восток: к 100-летию Коминтерна / отв. ред. Н.Г. Романова, К.В. Орлова. М., 2021. С. 77–114.
  10. Попов В.И. Дипломатические отношения между СССР и Англией (1929–1939 гг.). М., 1965.
  11. Сергеев Е.Ю. Большая игра 1856–1907: мифы и реалии российско-британских отношений в Центральной и Восточной Азии. М., 2012.
  12. Сергеев Е.Ю. Комитет имперской обороны – главный орган координации внешней политики Великобритании // Европейские сравнительно-исторические исследования / ред. А.А. Улунян, Е.Ю. Сергеев. Вып. 4. М., 2014. С. 129–143.
  13. Сергеев Е.Ю. Обманчивый рассвет: Советский Союз и Великобритания в 1925–1932 гг. М., 2024.
  14. Судейкин А.Г. Колониальная политика лейбористской партии Великобритании между двумя мировыми войнами. М., 1976.
  15. Уолтон К. Британская разведка во времена холодной войны. Секретные операции МИ-5 и МИ-6. М., 2016.
  16. Черникова Л.П. Троцкий и идея мировой революции в контексте будущего Китая // Коминтерн и Восток: к 100-летию Коминтерна / отв. ред. Н.Г. Романова, К.В. Орлова. М., 2021. С. 218–261.
  17. Chernikova L.P. Trotsky i ideya mirovoi revoliutsii v kontekste budutschego Kitaya [Trotsky and the Idea of World Revolution in the context of China’s Future] // Comintern i Vostok: k stoletiyu Cominterna [The Comintern and the Orient: Devoted to the Centennial of the Comintern] / red. N.G. Romanova, K.V. Orlova. Moskva, 2021. S. 218–261. (In Russ.)
  18. Glasami razvedki. SSSR i Evropa, 1919–1938 gody. Sbornik dokumentov iz rossiiskikh arhkivov [Through the Eyes of Intelligence. Collection of Documents from Russian Archives] / sost. M. Ul’, V. Khaustov, V. Zakharov. Moskva, 2015. (In Russ.)
  19. Gus M.S. Britanskii imperialism i Vostok [British Imperialism and the Orient]. Kharkov, 1926. (In Russ.)
  20. Iserov A.A. Monroe doctrina 1823 g. [Monroe Doctrine 1823] // Bol’shaya rossiiskaya entsiklopediya (BRE) [Great Russian Encyclopedia (GRE). URL: https://old.bigenc.ru/world_history/text/2228217 (access date: 22.03.2024). (In Russ.)
  21. Malkin S.G. Patruliruya imperiyu: kolonial’nyi kontrol’ i voennaya mysl’ Velikobritanii v epokhu Interbelluma [Policing the Empire: Colonial Control and Military Thought of Great Britain in the Interbellum Epoch]. Samara, 2024. (In Russ.)
  22. Mamaeva N.L. Comintern i Gomin’dan [The Comintern and Guomindang]. 1919–1929. Moskva, 1999. (In Russ.)
  23. Mazdur I. Britanskii imperialism v Indii i podgotovka interventsii protiv SSSR [British Imperialism and the Preparations for Intervention against the USSR]. Moskva, 1933. (In Russ.)
  24. Minyazhetdinov I.Kh. Comintern v “angliiskom” Irake: v poiskakh pravil’nogo rakursa [The Comintern in “British” Iraq: In Search of the Optimal Angle] // Comintern i Vostok: k stoletiyu Cominterna [The Comintern and the Orient: Devoted to the Centennial of the Comintern] / red. N.G. Romanova, K.V. Orlova. Moskva, 2021. S. 77–114. (In Russ.)
  25. Popov V.I. Diplomaticheskie otnosheniya mezhdu SSSR i Angliei [Diplomatic Relations between the USSR and England] (1929–1939). Moskva, 1965. (In Russ.)
  26. Sergeev E.Yu. Bol’shaya igra 1856–1907: Mify i realii rossiisko-britanskikh otnoshenii v Tsental’noi i Vostochnoi Asii [The Great Game 1856–1907: Myths and Realities of Russo-British Relations in Central and East Asia]. Moskva, 2012. (In Russ.)
  27. Sergeev E.Yu. Komitet imperskoi oborony – glavnyi organ koordinatsii vneshnei politiki Velikobritanii [Committee of Imperial Defence – The Main Coordinative Body of British Foreign Policy] // Evropeiskie sravnitel’no-istoricheskie issledovaniya [European Comparative Studies] / red. A.A. Ulunian, E.Yu. Sergeev. Iss. 4. Moskva, 2014. S. 129–143. (In Russ.)
  28. Sergeev E.Yu. Obmanchivyi rassvet: Sovietskii Soyuz i Velikobritaniya v 1925–1932 gg. [Illusory Dawn: The Soviet Union and Great Britain in 1925–1932]. Moskva, 2024. (In Russ.)
  29. Sudeikin A.G. Kolonial’naya politika leiboristskoi partii Velikobritanii mezhdu dvumya mirovymi voinami [Colonial Policy of Great Britain’s Labour Party in the Interim of Two World Wars]. Moskva, 1976. (In Russ.)
  30. Vertinskii A.V. Komissiya Saimona i bor’ba v politicheskikh krugakh Velikobritanii vokrug indiidkoi konstitutsionnoi reform [Simon’s Commission and the Struggle around Indian Constitutional Reform in Great Britain’s Political Circles] (1927–1930) // Iz istorii burzhuaznoi diplomatii i mezhimperialisticheskikh protivorechii v pervoi polovine XX v. [From the History of Bourgeois Diplomacy and Interimperialistic Contradictions in the First Half of the 20th Century]. Tomsk, 1086. S. 57–73. (In Russ.)
  31. Walton C. Britanskaya razvedka vo vremena kholodnoi voiny. Sekretnye operatsii MI5 i MI6. Trans. from English [Empire of Secrets: British Intelligence, The Cold War, and The Twilight of Empire]. Moskva, 2016. (In Russ.)
  32. Zhirova N.S. Sotrudnichestvo indiiskoi partii “Gadar” s Kominternom (1922–1943) [Collaboration of the Indian “Gadar” Party with the Comintern (1922–1943)]. Lipetsk, 2016. (In Russ.)
  33. Andrew C. Defence of the Realm: the Authorized History of MI5. London, 2010.
  34. Campbell J. F.E. Smith. First Earl of Birkenhead. London, 1991.
  35. Das D. India from Curzon to Nehru and After. London, 1969.
  36. Fisher J. The Interdepartmental Committee on Eastern Unrest and British Responses to Bolshevik and Other Intrigues against the Empire during the 1920s // Journal of Asian History. 2000. Vol. XXXIV. № 1. P. 1–34.
  37. Gilderhus M.T. The Monroe Doctrine: Meanings and Implications // Presidential Studies Quaterly. 2006. Vol. XXXVI. № 1. P. 5–16.
  38. Haithcox J. M.N. Roy and Comintern Policy 1920–1939. Princeton (NJ), 1971.
  39. Henderson A., Dovgalevsky V. Anglo-Soviet Relations, 1918–1929 // Bulletin of International News. 1929. Vol. VI. № 7. P. 3–12.
  40. Hevia J. The Imperial Security State. British Colonial Knowledge and Empire-Building in Asia. Cambridge, 2012.
  41. Hillmer N. The Foreign Office, the Dominions and the Diplomatic Unity of the Empire, 1925–29 // Retreat from Power. Studies in Britain’s Foreign Policy of the Twentieth Century / ed. D. David. London; Basingstoke, 1981. Vol. 1. P. 64–77.
  42. Howard M. The Continental Commitment: The Dilemma of British Defense Policy in the Era of the Two World Wars. London, 1972.
  43. Howe S. Anti-Colonialism in British Politics: The Left and the End of Empire, 1918–1964. Oxford, 1993.
  44. Kapur H. Soviet Russia and Asia. A Study of Soviet Policy towards Turkey, Iran and Afghanistan. Geneva, 1966.
  45. Kennedy P. The Realities Behind Diplomacy. Background Influences on British External Policy 1865–1980. London, 1981.
  46. Kepel G. Jihad: The Trail of Political Islam. Cambridge (Mass.), 2002.
  47. Moreman T. “Small Wars” and “Imperial Policing”: The British Army and the Theory and Practice of Colonial Warfare in the British Empire, 1919–1939 // Journal of Strategic Studies. 1996. Vol. XIX. № 4. P. 105–131.
  48. Nehru J. Soviet Russia: Some Random Sketches and Impressions. Bombay, 1929.
  49. Nye J. Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics. New York, 2004.
  50. Orde A. Great Britain and International Security 1920–1926. London, 1978.
  51. Petrie D. Communism in India, 1924–27. Calcutta, 1927.
  52. Samra C.S. India and Anglo-Soviet Relations, 1917–1947. Bombay, etc., 1959.
  53. Soviet Union. Political Reports. 1917–1970 / ed. R. Jarman. Vol. 4. Oxford, 2004.
  54. Sylvest C. A Commanding Group? Labour’s Advisory Committee on International Questions 1918–1931 // The British Labour Party and the Wider World / eds P. Cornthorn, J. Davis. London; New York, 2008. P. 48–63.
  55. Thomas J.H. Labour and the Empire // World Today. 1924. № 5. P. 487–489.
  56. Thomas M. Empires of Intelligence. Security Services and Colonial Disorder after 1914. Berkeley; Los Angeles, 2008.
  57. Thorpe A. Introduction // The British Labour Party and The Wider World / eds P. Cornthorn, J. Davis. London; New York, 2008. P. 1–24.
  58. Veeser C. A World Safe for Capitalism Dollar Diplomacy and America’s Rise to Global Power. New York, 2002.

Copyright (c) 2024 Russian Academy of Sciences

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies