The concept of “popular royalism” in the latest historiography of the French Revolution and the Napoleonic Era: pro and contra

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

In recent years, the concept of “popular royalism” has gained popularity in the historiography of the French Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars. The author of the article analyses the main tenets and criticisms of this concept based on the writings of the three main theorists, Paul Choplin, Álvaro Paris, and Andoni Artola. The term “popular royalism” appeared as a result of an incomplete discussion about the essence of counter-revolution in European countries in the late 18th – early 19th centuries. According to the authors of the concept, royalist and counter-revolutionary movements were not retrograde in nature and met the actual demands of different layers of society in the situation of civil war. The counter-revolution gave rise to an alternative way of politicization of the masses and contributed to the emergence of new models of their political participation. The royalists monopolised old sources of political legitimacy and adapted familiar discourses and images to new challenges. Drawing on the idea of legitimacy, they put forward a wide range of demands that were not only conservative but also innovative. Nevertheless, specific regional casess, especially from Italian history, show that the cross-class alliances led by the royalists were temporary and unsustainable. These alliances contributed to the Restoration, but only with foreign military intervention. Yet, since the national historiographical traditions are still very stable, the proposed new concept of popular royalist movements requires substantial clarifications, taking into account the specifics of the historical development of different countries and regions.

Full Text

Restricted Access

About the authors

Andrey А. Mitrofanov

Institute of World History, Russian Academy of Sciences

Author for correspondence.
Email: paxgallica@gmail.com
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-8480-5345
Scopus Author ID: 57219242225
ResearcherId: J-8249-2017; AAZ-9180-2021

кандидат исторических наук, старший научный сотрудник отдела новой и новейшей истории

Russian Federation, Moscow

References

  1. Бовыкин Д.Ю., Чудинов А.В. Французская революция. М., 2020.
  2. Митрофанов А.А. Повстанческое движение барбэ в Приморских Альпах и французские роялисты в 1800 г. // Французский ежегодник 2022. Т. 55. М., 2022. C. 118–137.
  3. Митрофанов А.А. Христианское воинство Бранды Лучони. Два века черной легенды // Французский ежегодник. 2023. Т. 56. C. 116–140.
  4. Чудинов А.В. «Солдаты свободы» или смертельный враг? Французы в Южной Италии 1798–1799 гг. // Известия Уральского федерального университета. Сер. 2. Гуманитарные науки. 2016. Т. 18. № 2 (151). С. 25–41.
  5. Bovykin D.Yu., Tchoudinov A.V. Frantsuzskaya revolyutsia [The French Revolution]. Moskva, 2020. (In Russ.)
  6. Mitrofanov A.A. Hristianskoe voinstvo Brandy Luchoni. Dva veka chernoi legendy [Massa cristiana of Branda Lucioni. Two centuries of black legend] // Frantsuzskii ezhegodnik [French Yearbook]. 2023. T. 56. Moskva, 2023. S. 116–140. (In Russ.)
  7. Mitrofanov A.A. Povstancheskoe dvizhenie barbe v Primorskikh Al’pakh i frantsuzskie royalisty v 1800 godu [The insurgent movement of the Barbets in the Alpes-Maritimes and the French royalists in 1800] // Frantsuzskii ezhegodnik [French Yearbook] 2022. T. 55. Moskva, 2022. S. 118–137. (In Russ.)
  8. Tchoudinov A.V. “Soldaty svobody” ili smertel’nyi vrag? Frantsuzy v Yuzhnoj Italii 1798–1799 gg. [“Soldiers of freedom” or mortal enemy? The French in Southern Italy, 1798–1799] // Izvestiya Ural’skogo federal’nogo universiteta [Bulletin of Ural Federal State University]. Ser. 2. Gumanitarny`e nauki [Humanities]. 2016. T. 18. № 2 (151). S. 25–41. (In Russ.)
  9. Albera M., Sanguinetti O. Il maggiore Branda de’ Lucioni e la “Massa cristiana”. Aspetti e figure dell’insorgenza anti-giacobina e della liberazione del Piemonte nel 1799. Torino, 1999.
  10. Aulard A. Histoire politique de la Révolution française, origines et développement de la démocratie et de la République (1789–1804). Paris, 1901.
  11. Bertaud J.-P. Les royalistes et Napoléon 1799–1816. Paris, 2009.
  12. Bevilacqua E. Le Pasque Veronesi. Monografia storica documentata. Verona, 1897.
  13. Beyond the Terror: Essays in French regional and social history 1794–1815 / eds G. Lewis, C. Lucas. Cambridge, 1983.
  14. Bonafini F. Verona 1797. Il Furore di una città. Verona, 1997.
  15. Broers M. Napoleonic Imperialism and the Savoyard Monarchy 1773–1821: state building in Piedmont. New York, 1997.
  16. Broers M. The Napoleonic Mediterranean. London; New York, 2017.
  17. Broers M. The parochial revolution: 1799 and the counter-revolution in Italy // Renaissance and Modern Studies. 1989. № 33 (1). Р. 159–174.
  18. Broers M. The politics of religion in Napoleonic Italy. The war against God, 1801–1814. London; New York, 2002.
  19. Broers М. Napoleon’s Other War. Bandits, rebels and their pursuers in the age of revolutions. Oxford, 2010.
  20. Cadet N. Honneur et violences de guerre au temps de Napoléon: la campagne de Calabre. Paris, 2015.
  21. Carta L. La Sardegna nel Settecento. Cagliari, 2023.
  22. Chopelin P. Royalismes et royalistes dans la France révolutionnaire // Annales historiques de la Révolution française. 2021. Vol. 403. P. 3–28.
  23. Chopelin P. Royalist Commitment in the Age of the Atlantic Revolutions (1770s–1820s): Some Initial Definitions and Guidelines for Future Research // Royalism, War and Popular Politics in the Age of Revolutions, 1780s–1870s. Cham, 2023. Р. 17–38.
  24. Clay S. Justice, vengeance et passé révolutionnaire: les crimes de la terreur blanche // Annales historiques de la Révolution française. 2007. № 350. Р. 109–133.
  25. Clay S. Les réactions du midi: conflits, continuités et violences // Annales historiques de la Révolution française. 2006. № 345. P. 55–91.
  26. Daudet E. Histoire de l’émigration pendant la Révolution française. T. I–II. Paris, 1904–1905.
  27. Daudet E. Histoire des conspirations royalistes du midi sous la révolution (1790–1793). Paris, 1881.
  28. Davis J.A. Naples and Napoleon. Southern Italy and the European Revolutions, 1780–1860. Oxford; New York, 2006.
  29. Dupuy R. De la Révolution à la Chouannerie: Paysans en Bretagne, 1788–1796. Paris, 1988.
  30. Echeverri M. Presentation: Monarchy, Empire, and Popular Politics in the Atlantic Age of Revolutions // Varia Historia. 2019. № 35 (67). P. 15–35.
  31. Folle controrivoluzionarie. Le insorgenze popolari nell’Italia giacobina e napoleonica / a cura di A.-M. Rao. Rome, 1999.
  32. Gaubert H. Conspirateurs au temps de Napoleon I-er. Paris, 1962.
  33. Gengembre G. La Contre-Révolution ou l’Histoire désespérante. Paris, 1989.
  34. Godechot J. La contre-révolution: Doctrine et action, 1789–1804. Paris, 1961.
  35. Guerci L. Uno spettacolo non mai più veduto nel mondo. La Rivoluzione francese come unicita e rovesciamento negli scrittori controrivoluzionari Italiani (1789–1799). Torino, 2008.
  36. Guichonnet P. Les monts en feu : la guerre en Faucigny, 1793. Annecy, 1994.
  37. Iafelice M. Barbets! La résistance à la domination française dans le pays niçois 1792–1814. Nice, 1998.
  38. La Contre-Révolution - Origines, histoire, postérité / sous la dir. J. Tulard. Paris, 1990.
  39. La Contre-Révolution en Europe (XVIII-e–XIX-e siècles): Réalités politiques et sociales, résonnances culturelles et idéologiques / sous la dir. J.-C. Martin. Rennes, 2001.
  40. Leuwers H. La Révolution française et l’Empire. Une France révolutionnée, 1787–1815. Paris, 2011.
  41. Lewis G. The Continuity of Counter-revolution in the Department of the Gard, 1789–1815. New York, 1978.
  42. Lucas C. Résistances populaires à la Révolution dans le sud-est // Mouvements populaires et conscience sociale XVI-e–XIX-e siècles. Paris, 1985. P. 473–485.
  43. Maistre J. Lettres d’un royaliste savoisien à ses compatriotes publiées, pour la première fois, en France d’après l’original, très rare, de l’année 1793 / par Joseph de Maistre et précédées d’une préface par René Muffat. Paris; Lyon, 1872.
  44. Martin J.-C. Contre-révolution, révolution et nation en France, 1789–1799. Paris, 1998.
  45. Martin J.-C. Un bicentenaire en cache un autre. Repenser la Terreur ? // Annales historiques de la Révolution française. 1994. № 297. Р. 517–526.
  46. Mazauric C. Autopsie d’un échec: la résistance à l’anti-Révolution et la défaite de la Contre-Révolution // Les résistances à la Révolution. Paris, 1987. P. 237–244.
  47. Middell M., Dupuy R., Höpel T. Widerstände gegen Revolutionen, 1789 bis 1989. Leipzig, 1994.
  48. Minart G. Les opposants à Napoléon. 1800–1815, l’élimination des royalistes et des républicains. Toulouse, 2003.
  49. Osen J.L. The royalist political thought during the French Revolution. Westport (CT), 1995.
  50. Papiers saisis à Bayreuth et a Mende, département de la Lozère. Paris, an X (1802).
  51. Pestel F. On counterrevolution. Semantic investigations of a counterconcept during the French Revolution // Contributions to the History of Concepts. 2017. Vol. 12. Iss. 2. P. 50–75.
  52. Rodolico N. Il Popolo agli inizi del Risorgimento nell’Italia Meridionale 1799–1801. Florence, 1926.
  53. Romagnani G.P. Dalle “Pasque veronesi” ai moti agrari del Piemonte // Folle controrivoluzionarie. Le insorgenze popolari nell’Italia giacobina e napoleonica / a cura di A.M. Rao. Roma, 1999. P. 89–122.
  54. Royalism, War and Popular Politics in the Age of Revolutions, 1780s–1870s. Cham, 2023.
  55. Sutherland D. France, 1789–1815: Revolution and Counterrevolution. London, 1985.
  56. Sutherland D. Murder in Aubagne: lynching, law, and justice during the French Revolution. New York, 2009.
  57. Sutherland D. The Chouans, the Social Origins of Popular Counter-Revolution in Upper Brittany, 1770–1796. Oxford, 1982.
  58. Thiulen L.I. Nuovo cocabolario filosofio-democratico indispensabile per ognuno che brama intendere la nuova lingua rivoluzionaria. Venezia, 1799.
  59. Turi G. Guerre civili in Italia: 1796–1799. Roma, 2019.
  60. Turi G. Viva Maria. Riforme, rivoluzione e insorgenze in Toscana (1790–1799). 2 ed. Bologna, 1999.
  61. Villefosse L., Bouissounouse J. L’opposition à Napoléon. Paris, 1969.

Copyright (c) 2024 Russian Academy of Sciences

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies