Email this article 
James Harrington and His Perception of History: From Narrative to Theory
- Authors: Kozlov D.V.1
-
Affiliations:
- Irkutsk State University
- Issue: No 6 (2023)
- Pages: 18-33
- Section: Theory and methodology of history
- URL: https://journals.rcsi.science/0130-3864/article/view/251142
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.31857/S013038640028924-4
- ID: 251142
Cite item
Open Access
Access granted
Subscription Access
Abstract
In the article, the author tracks the dynamics of the views on history of the well-known seventeenth-century English politician and philosopher James Harrington, considering and analysing them in the broad context of changing attitudes to history in Europe during the Renaissance and Early Modern period. The author maintains that in Harrington's texts one can find a combination of traditional approaches, characterised by an attitude to history as a set of historical arguments in favour of different political positions, and new approaches, associated with an awareness of the differences between the past and the present and the impossibility of direct application of historical models to the present. He examines a number of discussions between Harrington and his contemporaries devoted to analysing various historical events and processes. In particular, the author examines the different assessments of the political structure of Greek Sparta and ancient Israel. He demonstrates the influence these assessments had on the complex formation of Harrington's and his contemporaries' attitudes towards different models of political government, such as the republic. The author examined the novelty of Harrington's position in terms of analysing the causes of the Civil War in seventeenth-century England. New interpretations of the dynamics of societies' political development proposed by Harrington are largely related to his vision of the interaction between economic conditions (balance of land ownership) and political power in its various forms (monarchy, aristocracy, republic). A key conclusion of the study is that Harrington's historical approaches combine, in an intriguing and imaginative way, mere historical description as a narrative practice with a desire to create and develop a political theory that claims to analyse the dynamics of historical events and to elaborate the various political positions associated with the republican tradition.
References
- Брагина Л.М. Итальянский гуманизм. Этические учения XIV–XV веков. М., 1977.
- Бэкон Ф. История правления короля Генриха VII / пер. с англ. В.Р. Рокитянский и др.; ст. и общ. ред. М.А. Барг; коммент. В.Р. Рокитянский. М., 1990.
- Макиавелли Н. Государь. М., 1990.
- Макиавелли Н. Раccуждения о первой декаде правления Тита Ливия // Макиавелли Н. Сочинения. СПб., 1998.
- Покок Д.Г.А. Момент Макиавелли. Политическая мысль Флоренции и атлантическая республиканская традиция. М., 2020.
- Сапрыкин Ю.М. Политическое учение Гаррингтона: из истории идейно-политической борьбы в годы Английской буржуазной революции XVII века. М., 1975.
- Baron H. In Search of Florentine Civic Humanism: in 2 vols. Vol. 2. Essays on the Transition from Medieval to Modern Thought. Princeton, 1988.
- Blitzer С. An Immortal Commonwealth: The Political Thought of James Harrington. New Нaven, 1960.
- Boralevi L.С. James Harrington's “Machiavellian” anti-Machiavellism // History of European Ideas. 2011. Vol. 37. № 2. P. 113–119.
- Burrow J.W. A History of Histories: Epics, Chronicles, Romances & Inquiries from Herodotus and Thucydides to the Twentieth Century. Harmondsworth, 2007.
- Foxley R. Sparta and the English Republic // Classical Receptions. 2016. Vol. 8. № 1. P. 54–70.
- Harrington J. Pian Piano. Or, Intercourse between H. Ferne, Dr. in Divinity and J. Harrington, Esq. Upon occasion of the Doctors Censure of the Common-Wealth of Oceana. London, 1656/57.
- Harrington J. The Prerogative of Popular Government. London, 1657/58.
- Harrington J. The Stumbling-Block of Disobedience & Rebellion Cunningly imputed by P.H. unto Calvin, removed in a Letter to the said P.H. from J.H. London, 1658.
- Harrington J. The Art of Law-giving: in 3 vols. Vol. II. London, 1659.
- Harrington J. A Letter Unto Mr. Stubs in answer to his Oceana weighed, &c. London, 1659.
- Harrington J. Politicaster: Or, a Comical Discourse, in Answer unto Mr. Wren’s Book, Intituled, Monarchy Asserted, Against Mr. Harrington’s Oceana. London, 1659.
- Harrington J. Valerius and Publicola: or, the True Form of a Popular Commonwealth Extracted E purs Naturalibus. London, 1659.
- Harrington J. The Oceana and other works of James Harrington Esq; Collected, Methodiz’d, and Review’d, with an Exact Account of his Life prefixed, by John Toland. To which is added, an Appendix, containing all the Political Tracts wrote by this Author, Omitted in Mr. Toland’s Edition. London, 1737.
- Harrington J. The Political Works of James Harrington: in 2 vols. Vol. 1 / ed. J.G.A. Pocock. Cambridge, 1977.
- Heylyn P.H. The Stumbling-Block of Disobedience and Rebellion, Cunningly laid by Calvin in the Subjects way, Discovered, Censured, and Removed. London, 1658.
- Heylyn P.H. Certamen Epistolare, or the Letter-Combate. London, 1659.
- Hobbes T. The Elements of Law Natural and Politic / ed. F. Tonnies. Cambridge, 1928.
- Hyde E. Earl of Clarendon, Selections from the History of the Rebellion & the Life by himself / ed. H. Trevor-Roper. Oxford, 1978.
- Nelson E. The Hebrew Republic: Jewish Sources and the Transformation of European Political Thought. Cambridge, 2010.
- Pocock J.G.A. The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law. Cambridge, 1957.
- Pocock J.G.A. Politics, Language and Time: Essays in Political Thought and History. Cambridge, 1971.
- Rawson E. The Spartan Tradition in European Thought. Oxford, 1969.
- Skinner Q. Reason and Rhetoric in the Philosophy of Hobbes. Cambridge, 1996.
- Smith N. Literature and Revolution in England, 1640–1660. New Haven, 1994.
- Stubbe H. A Letter to an officer of the Army concerning a select senate mentioned by them in their proposals to the late Parliament. The necessity and prudentialness of such a Senate is here asserted by reason and history. Whereunto are added sundry positions about government, and an essay towards a secure settlement. London, 1659.
- Stubbe H. The Common-Wealth of Oceana put into the Balance and Found too Light. Or an Account of the Republic of Sparta, with occasional Animadversions upon Mr. James Harrington and the Oceanistical Model. London, 1660.
- Tawney R.H. Harrington’s Interpretation of His Age // Proceedings of the British Academy. 1941. Vol. 27. P. 199–223.
- Wren M. Monarchy asserted, or The State of monarchicall and popular Government; in Vindication of the Considerations upon Mr. Harrington’s Oceana. 2nd ed. London, 1660.
- Wren M. Considerations on Mr. Harrington’s Common-wealth of Oceana. London, 1657.
Supplementary files
