Vol 7, No 4 (2025)
ОБЩЕСТВО. КУЛЬТУРА. ЧЕЛОВЕК
Ritualization of media consumption as an element of constructing cultural identity
Abstract
The article examines the phenomenon of media consumption as a practice of constructing cultural identity. The theoretical basis is based on concepts developed within the framework of cultural anthropology and sociology, presented in the works of such researchers as S. Cottle, N. Couldry, B. Larsen, S. Lux, T. Trillo, T. Taft, E. Fromm, F. Eliot. The article presents the author’s interpretation of the possibilities of using media consumption as a ritual practice of forming cultural identity. The purpose of the article is to substantiate the possibilities of interpreting media consumption as a specific form of ritual practice that is suitable for constructing cultural identity. Ritual consumption of media is manifested through practice. Cultural identity is created through rituals, and the transformation of rituals inevitably leads to the transformation of identity. Ritual practices of media consumption are performative phenomena that serve to maintain and mobilize collective feelings and solidarity, based on symbolization and conventions regarding social reality. The concept of media rituals emphasizes the constructivist nature of the existing social reality and the specific place of media in it. Media ritual addresses the problem of understanding social space and creating appropriate frameworks for understanding context. In the context of new media, the ritualization of media consumption takes this process to the next level, where ritual and neurosis may be indistinguishable to an outside observer. Outwardly, the manifestation of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) can resemble a ritualistic action. The emergence of new communication technologies inevitably leads to the formation of new ritualistic practices of interaction between people. Likes, subscriptions, and reposts are meaningless and impossible without new media technologies. These can be both new ritualistic actions and new manifestations of neuroses associated with OCD. Ritual relates to identity on an everyday level, when individual actions acquire a collective or social dimension. Ritual practice is viewed as an element in the formation of cultural identity and a sense of belonging to a given culture. Some outdated ritual forms are easily adapted to the new conditions of social media, creating opportunities for the revitalization of archaic practices.
5-13
The philosophy of responsibility and freedom in education: a look at the school of A. Neill
Abstract
In the modern philosophical discussion of education, the question of the relationship between freedom and responsibility occupies a key place, especially in the context of a humanistic approach. This work explores the philosophical roots and practical application of the concept of freedom and responsibility in the pedagogical system of A. Neill, an outstanding representative of humanistic pedagogy of the XX century. Analyzing his ideas through the prism of philosophical categories, the author seeks to understand their logic and significance for modern humanistic education, as well as to determine the place of Neill's pedagogy within the framework of ethical philosophy. The research is based on the assumption that Neill's pedagogy is a practical realization of the idea of an inextricable link between freedom and responsibility in personal development. Freedom is seen here not as the opposite of responsibility, but as a necessary condition for its emergence. Responsibility is understood as an internal incentive formed in the process of self-improvement.
14-21
The existential focus of Russian identity: three steps to yourself
Abstract
The problem of authenticity, even when reduced to the problem of identity, is among the most crucial for human life and its understanding. Today, however, socio-anthropological practices and theories that attempt to downplay the role of stable identities are also influential. This situation is particularly acute for the generation that migrated from Soviet to post-Soviet society, with visible human losses. Belonging to this generation, the author sets himself a challenging task: having affirmed the value of stable self-identification, to present a philosophical reconstruction of his own experience of this kind. The existential approach is employed to elucidate the “red” version of Russian identity in the paper. With respect to the identification procedure, the claims of the political factor are limited, and the ambiguity of the social factor is noted. The inconsistency and stubbornness of Russian man are explained by the belief in ontological contingency and the absolutization of its consequences. As a methodological aid, the author uses a blend of dialectics and hermeneutics. The reasoning which is constructed forms a conceptual thread that could be called a “step-by-step return to oneself”. The verifiability of the calculations is ensured, to the extent possible, by correlating them with initial intuitions and with judgments from the cited references.
22-30
ФИЛОСОФИЯ И МЕТОДОЛОГИЯ НАУКИ
From "accumulation" to navigation: how scientific communities adapt to fragmented epistemology
Abstract
The article examines the transformation of epistemological practices in the digital age and under social instability. It focuses on the phenomenon of "metric legitimation", where algorithms and engagement indicators replace traditional forms of expertise. The shift from accumulation to navigation is analyzed, with knowledge functioning as both access service and social signal. The precariat is shown as a key indicator of these changes, relying on situational and horizontal forms of verification. The risks of "epistemological compression" are highlighted, along with the need for hybrid procedures to preserve critical distance and the sustainability of scientific knowledge.
31-39
The scientific school and the ethical regulation of research activity
Abstract
This article focuses on constructing a verbal sketch of a theoretical model for the holistic process of ethical regulation in research activity. Particular attention is paid to the role played in this process by the ethical traditions and attitudes inherent to a scientific school. The article's content reflects the following: the meaning of the concept of a scientific school, which is heuristically valuable for the conducted research; the features of ethical regulation in research activity, as well as corporate and professional ethical codes as instruments for its implementation; the author's perspective on the internal discretionary and external imperative frameworks of ethical regulation in research activity.
40-49
The framework of being from the point of view of the world coordinate system based on limit dynamic equilibriums
Abstract
The main issue of the methodology for studying the self-organization of things in the world is the combination of the nonlinearity of the world, caused by the ubiquitous nonequilibrium states and processes in it, with its extraordinary stability and optimality. This is possible in the case of the interaction of a specific thing with three areas: the environment, the level of structural equilibrium of the world, the area of rhythms through their equilibrium boundaries, which also allows them to connect with their limit equilibria. The set of limit dynamic equilibria arising in the processes of self-organization of things creates a coordinate system of the world. The main characteristics of the "equilibrium dynamic boundary of a thing", "area of formation of the equilibrium boundary of a thing" and "limit equilibria of a thing" are considered, as well as the projections of the equilibrium boundary onto the three above-mentioned areas: "boundary-environment", "boundary-structure", "boundary-rhythm". An attempt is made to link this coordinate system with being, for which purpose the concept of "framework of being" is introduced, composed of the limits of all specific things, substances, levels of the world corresponding to the attributes of being. The attributes of being are substance, essence, being, existence, presence. The limit states of the framework of being allow us to clarify the main categories of being (its aspects), since the history of philosophy is characterized by their confusion.
50-62
Neural interfaces as a tool for the transformation of the "phenomenal body": from embodiment to excorporation
Abstract
This paper presents an interdisciplinary analysis of the impact of neural interfaces (NIs) on the fundamental structures of human self-awareness, specifically the construct of the "phenomenal body". The core thesis of the research is that the phenomenal body – the subjectively experienced unity and ownership of bodily experience – is not a static given but is sustained by a dynamic equilibrium of proprioceptive, vestibular, and interoceptive signals that ensure ontological security and the authenticity of the "Self". The article argues that neural interfaces, by establishing a direct bypassing pathway for sensorimotor control and perception, act as a catalyst for a profound transformation of this construct. We trace the trajectory of this transformation: from embodiment – a traditional state characterized by the inseparable link between consciousness and the biological body – to excorporation – a new modality of corporeality in which an individual's sense of self migrates, expands, or is partially transferred to external, synthetic, or virtual agents.Within the framework of the paper, the mechanisms of this deconstruction are analyzed: the disruption of the proprioceptive loop, the modulation of affective homeostasis, and the redefinition of the boundaries between "self" and "non-self". The study is theoretical and philosophical in nature, drawing on the conceptual apparatus of phenomenology, neuroscience (in particular, Antonio Damasio's theory of somatosensory homeostasis), and Science and Technology Studies (STS). The conclusion discusses the ethical and existential implications of this shift, which concern issues of identity, agency, and the new configuration of human existence in the age of symbiosis with technology.
63-69
Organoid concept of technology
Abstract
The phenomenon of technology is examined in the context of developers implementing a human-machine approach to the co-evolution of actual being with the structures of potential being. This approach realizes a new reading of ontology through the categorical structures of the anthropology of the extended human. Cognitive artifacts are introduced into the body of the extended human. They assume important functions of communication and coordination between the individual and the external environment. As a result, a new architecture of cognitive structures, dominated by fuzzy logic thinking, is formed within the body of the extended human through artificial intelligence technologies. The primary carriers of this logic are chat bots and AI agents. Their growing role has raised questions about the prospects for them to acquire subject status. However, the bias of AI agents, despite the potential for using theory of mind, has shifted this question to the context of the simulation hypothesis. This hypothesis implies that developers will have to be personally responsible for the developments they implement and their use.
70-77
Neuroethics ambivalence: between neuroscience ethics and neuroscience ethics
Abstract
Modern science, penetrating the mysteries of existence, reveals its multidimensionality and complexity, necessitating the introduction of new concepts that adequately describe its achievements. These include the concept of ambivalence, which is a dialectical relationship of the mutual transition of opposites, capable of existing outside the context of dialectical contradiction. The scientific novelty of this study stems from the use of achievements of the post-Marxist stage of dialectic development. The goal of this study is to find a relevant description of the subject of neuroethics. The ambivalence of neuroethics is a special case of the ambivalence of professional ethics, which requires not only the conscientious performance of professional work but also its ethical justification as aimed at the benefit of the individual and humanity. The uniqueness of neuroethics lies in the fact that neuroscience significantly influences the understanding of morality, transforms established notions, and represents an attempt, albeit hypothetically, to answer philosophical questions using concrete scientific results from the study of brain function. This last circumstance elevates neuroethics to the rank of applied ethics, the solution to whose problems has no historical precedent. The ambivalence of neuroethics as applied ethics is characterized by the contradictory interaction of natural science and humanities knowledge, which problematizes the substantial existence of morality and raises questions about the limits of human freedom. Neuroscientific research can be interpreted as limiting and narrowing the scope of morality. But such a view only scratches the surface; in essence, we are talking about a reconsideration of the foundations of morality, forcing a new answer to the question of human freedom and its limits. Advances in neuroscience and the possibility of their use in neurotechnology increase the effectiveness of manipulation technologies and pose a serious threat to human freedom. Thus, the neuroscientific foundations of ethics necessarily presuppose philosophical reflection. Ethics is a conscious philosophical justification of morality and constitutes an obstacle to unlimited, unjustified influence on the human brain. The study of brain function and its results should contribute to the human good, and only on this basis can a professional code of conduct be developed for scientists engaged in brain research. Today, social and humanities expertise is not a luxury, but a vital necessity. In the context of communicative rationality, humanities expertise must represent a communicative discourse that will not only be interdisciplinary but also located within the space of citizen science.
78-87
ФИЛОСОФЫ РОССИИ: ЖИЗНЬ И ТВОРЧЕСТВО
Borisov's approach to the study of reflection in scientific cognition
Abstract
The cognitive potential of rational philosophy is revealed in the analysis of the internal mechanisms of the development of scientific knowledge. The relevance of reflection research in science is determined by challenges from the dominant naturalistic and sociological trends. The classification of types of reflection proposed by V.N. Borisov is used in the analysis of various ways of substantiating science. The programs of substantiation of science by I. Kant and B. Russell are compared according to the types of reflexive procedures. Transcendental reflection refers the methods of physical cognition to philosophical metatheory. Scientific reflection reveals the methods of physics through psychological sciences. Different levels of reflection on cognitive procedures correspond to different relationships between scientific disciplines. The article substantiates the universality of classical rationality, the principles of the unity of scientific knowledge and the normative nature of philosophy in the development of natural science.
88-96
To the question of interpretation of F. Bacon's empiricism and I. Kant's transcendentalism in V.A. Kutyrev's anthropoconservatism
Abstract
The paper examines the concept of anthropoconservatism developed by V.A. Kutyrev. For this purpose, a critical analysis of V.A. Kutyrev's interpretation of F. Bacon's empiricism and I. Kant's transcendentalism is carried out. In his opinion, these philosophers play the role of key figures whose ideas played a crucial role in the turn of European humanity towards a technogenic civilization. At the same time, it was Bacon who filled scientific knowledge with a certain utilitarian content, acting as the forerunner of the technogenic era. We concretize Bacon's civilizational project of building paradise on Earth by means of science. It is also pointed out that V.A. Kutyrev underestimated Descartes' rationalism, the development of whose ideas ultimately led to the emergence of Artificial Intelligence, which plays the role of a man-made God in Bacon's man-made paradise. Further, the interpretation of I. Kant's transcendentalism is considered within the framework of Kutyrev's anthropoconservatism, first of all, Kant's Copernican turn and his doctrine of the "thing in itself", which ultimately lead European humanity to virtual reality technologies and initiate the exploration of outer space, the rationale for the feasibility of which is subsequently carried out within the framework of Russian cosmism by N.F. Fedorov and K.E. Tsiolkovsky, whom V.A. Kutyrev calls the first theoretical traitors to the Earth and "Luciferians". Disagreement is expressed with such an interpretation of Kant's work, in which we agree with B. Russell, who claimed that Kant carried out a "Ptolemaic counterrevolution" by placing the knowing subject at the center of his epistemology, while Copernicus removed man from the center of the Universe, placing the Sun there. By limiting the possibilities of the human mind, Kant casts doubt on the possibility of implementing Bacon's civilizational project, acting as an anthropoconservative. The movement towards virtual reality technologies occurred not thanks to, but in spite of Kant, as a result of his followers' attempts to refute the doctrine of the "thing in itself". Here we agree with A. Kozhev. It was Hegel, not Kant, who built a consistent philosophy of death. In the final part of the work, an exit to general ontological problems is made, which leads to the substantiation of the cardinal truth "We will all die!" However, as a free being, a person can choose the strategy of anthropoconservatism, striving to prolong his existence as much as possible, or the opposite Nietzschean strategy, when the highest value is given not to existence, but to development.
97-105
GRADUATE STUDENT TRIBUNE
Mechanisms of formation and consequences of gender stereotypes
Abstract
The purpose of this article is to study the mechanisms of reproduction of gender stereotypes through family, educational and media institutions in European society at the end of the XX – beginning of the XXI century, their impact on women's lives in the context of modern socio-cultural changes. The study demonstrates that traditional biases embedded at the level of social institutions exert considerable influence on the distribution of social roles and interactions between the sexes. The relevance of this topic lies in identifying factors impeding full development of women in professional, educational, and personal domains, and developing measures to eliminate these barriers. The scientific novelty of the research resides in its systematic analysis of the mechanisms of reproducing gender stereotypes and assessing their impact on women's lives. This will enable the formulation of strategies to overcome stereotypes and create inclusive spaces for all social groups. The methodological basis of the study consists of theoretical-methodological approaches from philosophy and social psychology, enabling identification of the mechanisms underlying the formation of gender stereotypes. Special attention was given to empirical studies examining processes of socialization and the role of family, educational, and media institutions in fostering gender prejudices. The investigation revealed that gender stereotypes are deeply integrated into societal consciousness and negatively affect women's professional and personal growth. They lead to diminished self-esteem, choice of low-paid professions, and limited career aspirations. Formation of stereotypes begins during early childhood and continues through reinforcement by educational systems, mass media, and societal norms. The findings emphasize the necessity for critical reassessment of current practices regarding the creation of gender expectations and social roles. Recognizing the significance of women's contributions to society and ensuring equal rights and opportunities for all citizens is essential. Liberation from historical prejudices and stereotypes opens new horizons for the development of harmonious and equitable social relations.
106-117
Problematics and conceptual framework of philosophy of education
Abstract
The relevance of this research topic stems from the complex interplay of stochastic and deterministic processes in the development of modern society, which inevitably impact the development strategies of many state institutions. Among these, education is one of the fundamental institutions, crucial for the future development of both individuals and society as a whole. The contradictions that emerge in the context of rapid change, reformist reforms, and sharp challenges in foreign and domestic policy compel us to turn to the critical apparatus of philosophical thought. The essence and conceptual apparatus of philosophy allow us to extrapolate its heuristic potential to education by approaching metaphysical questions about the role of values in education and in the formation of the individual and society. Using sociocultural tools, philosophy can analyze the functioning of the education system in society and outline the contours of its changes, as well as the stages of change in the form and structure of education. The reflexive apparatus of a worldview, its capacity for universal paradigmatic generalizations, allows us to identify key patterns in the worldview, as well as the particularities of its manifestation in the organization of the educational process; the forecasting apparatus and creative potential of philosophy have the ability to design and strategize the future goals and results of education. The philosophy of education is called upon to identify and illuminate the challenges facing modern education and to outline ways to overcome them. The scientific novelty of this work lies in its comprehensive methodological approach to education from the perspective of philosophy, using its conceptual apparatus as an epistemological tool of cognition. The purpose of this research is to uncover the potential of philosophy in its essential and conceptual manifestations for studying and understanding the education system within the context of contemporary societal development trends, distinguishing between education as an autonomous sphere of science and its philosophical reception as the philosophy of education. The approaches employed involve epistemological, axiological, and historical-philosophical analysis, allowing us to identify the problems and lines of research in education, as well as the ideological aspects of its understanding. The results of the study demonstrate that education as a philosophy of education and education as pedagogy, while autonomous, exist in a dialectical relationship, constituting a unity and opposition within the current sociocultural reality. Philosophy of education serves as a metatheoretical foundation, defining goals, values, and meanings, while educational methods in the field of pedagogy are practical tools for solving institutional problems. The prospects and practical significance of this work lie in providing a philosophical discourse on education that reveals it as a complex problem, identifying significant values for the development of individuals, states, nations, and people, as well as institutional mechanisms for managing education. Recommendations emphasize the need to recognize the epistemological productivity of the conceptual apparatus of educational philosophy, which emerges through axiological, systemic, processual, and results-based approaches.
118-126
