Methods for assessing the quality of medical care in Russia and abroad: formation and modern aspects
- Authors: Shkarupa V.V.1, Kuzin A.A.1, Zobov A.Е.1, Ryzhikov A.A.1
-
Affiliations:
- Kirov Military Medical Academy
- Issue: Vol 26, No 1 (2024)
- Pages: 101-112
- Section: Review
- URL: https://journals.rcsi.science/1682-7392/article/view/255220
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.17816/brmma611712
- ID: 255220
Cite item
Abstract
The study presents the results of the analysis of available literary sources covering the historical and modern aspects of assessing the quality of medical care in the healthcare systems of the Russian Federation and some foreign countries and shows the relevance and feasibility of improving the methodology for assessing the quality of medical care in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. At present, many methods are used for assessing the quality of medical care in the healthcare system of the Russian Federation; however, none of them contains an exhaustive set of criteria that would allow assessing the quality of medical care provided in full. In the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, the methods used to assess the quality of medical care are also not perfect, which leads to a decrease in the effectiveness of management decisions and thereby a decrease in the effectiveness of military medical organizations and units. To this end, active development of assessment indicators and criteria for the quality of medical care, introduction of new assessment methods, including the use of automated data accounting and analysis tools, and improvement of the procedures and standards of medical care are necessary. The most promising area is the use of comprehensive methods for assessing the effectiveness and quality of medical care, which have recently become widespread. Their application provides comprehensive control over compliance with medical care requirements and allows us to investigate the conditions wherein it is indicated, assess the degree of patient satisfaction, and helps optimize the assessment procedure. In addition, to improve the effectiveness, continuity in the implementation of control measures performed at various levels both within the medical organization and with the participation of departmental and state control bodies must be ensured. To do this, close interaction of all control bodies must be organized, and their activities must be integrated into a single quality management system for medical care. The results of the assessment of the quality of medical care can help determine the main directions of the development of the medical and diagnostic process and optimize the work of medical personnel, which increases the importance of work aimed at improving the assessment methodology. In addition, the quality control of medical care in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation must be further improved.
Keywords
Full Text
##article.viewOnOriginalSite##About the authors
Vitaly V. Shkarupa
Kirov Military Medical Academy
Email: Dr.andrey98@yandex.ru
ORCID iD: 0009-0001-6162-1834
SPIN-code: 3549-1488
deputy head of department
Russian Federation, Saint PetersburgAlexander A. Kuzin
Kirov Military Medical Academy
Email: Dr.andrey98@yandex.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-9154-7017
SPIN-code: 6220-1218
MD, Dr. Sci. (Med.), professor
Russian Federation, Saint PetersburgAndrey Е. Zobov
Kirov Military Medical Academy
Author for correspondence.
Email: dr.andrey98@yandex.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-7791-8993
SPIN-code: 4281-2680
MD, Cand. Sci. (Med.)
Russian Federation, Saint PetersburgAlexander A. Ryzhikov
Kirov Military Medical Academy
Email: Dr.andrey98@yandex.ru
ORCID iD: 0009-0001-9837-6940
Deputy Head of the Department of Medical Information Systems
Russian Federation, Saint PetersburgReferences
- Belevitin AB, Shelepov AM, Tyts VV. Methodological principles of military medical administration theory: main terms and definitions. Bulletin of the Russian Military Medical Academy. 2010;(3):193–198. EDN: NCFPHH
- Abushinov VV, Esipov AV. Internal control of quality and safety of medical activity as a step to the construction of quality-based management of medical organization. Issues of expertise and quality of medical care. 2017;(6):3–15. (In Russ.).
- Starodubov VI. Public health and public health care: national guide. Moscow: GEOTAR-Media; 2014. 624 p. (In Russ.).
- Telnova EA. Quality of medical care as the main task of the health care system. Bulletin of Roszdravnadzor. 2010;(5):4–6. (In Russ.).
- Peshina EV, Leontiev IL, Makhinova NV. Modern health care management system: theory and practice: monograph. Yekaterinburg: USUE Publ.; 2010. 201 p. (In Russ.).
- Lukyantseva DV. Standardization in the sphere of medical services in the management of quality of medical care [dissertation]. Moscow; 2003. 169 p. (In Russ.).
- Atsel EA, Fomina AV. Estimation of quality of medical aid in public health services modernization. Modern studies of social issues. 2013;(1):11. doi: 10.12731/2218-7405-2013-1-37
- Shabrov AV, Chavpetsov VF. Proceedings of the science and practice conferences: «Modern system of medical care quality management». Saint Petersburg; 2010. 168 p. (In Russ.).
- Sharabchiev YT, Dudina TV. Availability and quality of medical care: components of success. Medical news. 2009;(12):6–12. (In Russ.).
- Nazarenko GB. Quality of medical care in Russia. Clinical medicine (Russian jornal). 2021;99(5-6):383–387. EDN: YVDXWL doi: 10.30629/0023-2149-2021-99-5-6-383-387
- Deming E. Exit from crisis. A new paradigm for managing people, systems and processes. Moscow: Alpina Publisher; 2011. 400 p. (In Russ.).
- Siburina TA, Indeikin EN, Lovenetsky AN. Health insurance abroad: problems, experience, prospects. Moscow: Soyuzmedininform; 1992. 103 p.
- Omelyanovsky VV, Maximova LV, Tatarinov AP. International experience of funding and organization of healthcare systems. Financial journal. 2014;(3):22–34. EDN: TAHDCX
- Kozminykh SV. Possibilities of using foreign experience of market models of health care in Russia. Bulletin of Volgograd Institute of Business. 2010;(3):52–57. EDN: NUDRZL (In Russ.).
- Mishina OS, Starodubov VI. Trends in health care management in Russia and abroad. Health care abroad. 2011;(5):12–15. (In Russ.).
- Khalfin RA, Tadjiev IY. Health system in the USA. Part 1. Manager zdravoohranenia. 2012;(9):35–47. EDN: PDSFWB
- Khalfin RA, Tadjiev IY. Health system in the USA. Part 2. Manager zdravoohranenia. 2012;(10):47–57. EDN: PKWJAD
- Emanuel AV. Elements of the quality management system on the basis of ISO 9001-2008 and ISO 9004-2010: review. Quality management in the sphere of health care and social development. 2012;(1):112–121. EDN: OXACYL
- Gulyayev VA, Kryukov AYe, Shein AF, Velichko IV. The problems of medical care quality control in Russian Federation armed forces. Military Medical Journal. 2006;327(2):9–13. EDN: HVSVNT
- Kartashov VT. Management of quality of medical aid in military dispensary-clinical institutes. Military Medical Journal. 2008;329(10):1–11. EDN: JVBJXB
- Kuvshinov KE, Ryzhman NN, Reutskii IA, Butsenko SA. The internal quality control of medical care in military medical organizations. Military Medical Journal. 2015;336(2):4–10. EDN: WCBFFJ
- Furmanov EE, Ivchenko EV. Modern approaches to examination of quality of the medical aid rendered by the military man, in the conditions of transition of budgetary establishments to new system of planning and budget execution. Bulletin of the Russian Military medical academy. 2011;(1):178–180. EDN: NRCIUJ
- Shelepov AM, Tyts VV. The federal law “On the principles of health protection of the citizens of the Russian Federation” and the problems of its realization in the armed forces. Bulletin of the Russian Military medical academy. 2012;(3):236–242. EDN: PKBRLF
- Assessment of economic efficiency of medical service activity in peacetime: methodical materials of VMedA. Leningrad, 1992. 72 p. (In Russ.).
- Kuzmina MA, Zuev AV, Sertakova OV. Internal control of the quality and safety of healthcare: the socio-economic dimension. Economics and society: contemporary models of development. 2022;12(2):129–138. EDN: BMCDLX doi: 10.18334/ecsoc.12.2.116257
- Kuzmina MA, Zuev AV, Sertakova OV. Problems of ensuring internal quality control and safety of medical care. Remedium. 2023;27(1):36–41. EDN: IJKRXE doi: 10.32687/1561-5936-2023-27-1-36-41
- Taigibova TT. Improvement of mechanisms of quality management of medical services. Young scientist. 2014;(6):496–499. EDN: SBZVOF (In Russ.).
- Bedoreva IYu, Grigorkina ZB, Gubina EV, Kirilova IA. Methodological approaches to the organization of internal control of the quality and safety of medical activity in a medical organization. Acta biomedica scientifica. 2022;7(1):198–207. EDN: KPXBAP doi: 10.29413/ABS.2022-7.1.23
- Viktorov VN. The integration of the systems of internal control of the quality and safety of medical activity and quality management of medical organizations. Manager zdravoohranenia. 2017;(5):25–32. EDN: YTWCGV
- Lee MV, Beniova SN, Kiku PF, et al. Independent assessment of the quality of medical care in a multidisciplinary hospital. Manager zdravoohranenia. 2021;(9):21–33. EDN: APNWWQ doi: 10.21045/1811-0185-2021-9-21-33
- Arustamyan GN. Clinical and economic analysis and its role in the quality of medical care management. E-journal public administration. 2011;(29):1–12. EDN: PCDERN (In Russ.).
- Kolomiychenko ME. Quality assessment of medical care by integral index. Bulletin of Semashko National Research Institute of Public Health. 2021;(2):82–89. EDN: VRDNMN doi: 10.25742/NRIPH.2021.02.010
- Samoylova AV. Organization of quality and safety control of medical activities and tools for reducing risks in the provision of medical care. Вестник Росздравнадзора. 2023;(1):6–19. EDN: MATGLE
- Zheleznyakova IA, Seryapina YuV, Mikhailov IA, et al. Methodological approaches to the development of medical care quality control at medical organizations. Medical technologies. Assessment and choice. 2020;(4):13–20. EDN: XETFJP doi: 10.17116/medtech20204204113
- Kosareva EA, Dekhnich SN, Klykov AI. Problematic issues of quality control of medical care in the healthcare system of the Russian Federation. Vestnik of the Smolensk State medical academy. 2021;20(1):186–195. EDN: IZEVFA doi: 10.37903/vsgma.2021.1.28
- Kharisov AM, Berseneva EA, Bereznikov AV, et al. To the question of the organization of internal quality control of medical care in medical organizations. Bulletin of Semashko National Research Institute of Public Health. 2020;(2):4–15. EDN: RSGAML doi: 10.25742/NRIPH.2020.02.001
- Morozov SYu, Kamynina NN, Vorykhanov AV, et al. Evaluation of the effectiveness of internal quality control of medical care during control and supervision activities in medical organizations. City-healthcare. 2021;2(3):6–16. EDN: OOXUIX doi: 10.47619/2713-2617.zm.2021.v2i3;6-16
- Khusainova DK, Zigangareeva GG, Shulaeva LM. The timeliness as the main characteristic of the medical care’s medical quality. Manager zdravoohranenia. 2021;(6):35–41. EDN: KWQAUQ doi: 10.21045/1811-0185-2021-6-35-41