Everyday Life vs. Politics: The Image of Joan of Arc in the Cinema of the Twentieth

封面

如何引用文章

全文:

开放存取 开放存取
受限制的访问 ##reader.subscriptionAccessGranted##
受限制的访问 订阅存取

详细

The article draws on a unified corpus of historical feature films released in the twentieth century and centred on a single subject, namely the story of Joan of Arc (1412?–1431), the heroine of the Hundred Years’ War. In modern historiography (études johanniques) such comprehensive studies practically have not yet been conducted: researchers prefer to analyze each film separately, thereby missing possible connections and intersections of their creators’ ideas. In this article, the author aims to examine the extent to which these films conform to one of the most important principles of historical drama, that is, the principle of authenticity, which requires that the daily life of a particular historical era be portrayed on the screen with the utmost accuracy. These observations lead the author to conclude that, in most cases, realism is not a priority for the makers of films about Joan of Arc. Rather, their task is to follow the current historical moment in which a particular screenplay is conceived and implemented. At the beginning of the twentieth century, on the eve of the official canonisation of the Maid of Orleans (1920), the films about her had a distinctly hagiographical character, but over the following decades their semantic load kept changing, ranging from criticism of the European judicial system to criticism (or exaltation) of the existing political system.

全文:

受限制的访问

作者简介

Olga Togoeva

Institute of World History, Russian Academy of Sciences

编辑信件的主要联系方式.
Email: togoeva@yandex.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-7854-3222

доктор исторических наук, главный научный сотрудник

俄罗斯联邦, Moscow

参考

  1. Абрамович С.Л. Владимир Ильич Райцес. Памятные записки // Средние века. 1997. № 60. С. 346–362.
  2. Бойцов М.А. Скромное обаяние власти (К облику германских государей XIV–XV вв.) // Одиссей. Человек в истории – 1995. М., 1995. С. 37–66.
  3. Козлов Л.К. Исторический фильм // Кино. Энциклопедический словарь / гл. ред. С.И. Юткевич. М., 1987. С. 156–157.
  4. Крылова Ю.П. Исследование французских средневековых дворов в новейшей историографии Франции, Бельгии, Нидерландов, Швейцарии // Электронный научно-образовательный журнал «История». 2023. T. 14. Вып. 3 (125). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840025025–6–1/ (дата обращения: 30.01.2024).
  5. Майзульс М.Р. Воображаемый враг. Иноверцы в средневековой иконографии. М., 2022.
  6. Райцес В.И. «Свидание в Шиноне». Опыт реконструкции // Казус. Индивидуальное и уникальное в истории – 2003 / под ред. М.А. Бойцова, И.Н. Данилевского. Вып. 5. М., 2003. С. 42–59.
  7. Тогоева О.И. «Дева со знаменем». История Франции XV–XXI веков в портретах Жанны д’Арк. М., 2023.
  8. Тогоева О.И. Еретичка, ставшая святой. Две жизни Жанны д’Арк. М.; СПб., 2016.
  9. Abramovich S.L. Vladimir Il’ich Rajces. Pamyatnye zapiski [Vladimir Ilyich Raitses. Memories] // Srednie veka [Middle Ages]. 1997. № 60. S. 346–362. (In Russ.)
  10. Bojczov M.A. Skromnoe obayanie vlasti (K obliku germanskih gosudarej XIV–XV vv.) [The modest charm of power (To the appearance of the German sovereigns of the 14th-15th centuries)] // Odissej. Chelovek v istorii – 1995 [Odyssey. A man in history – 1995]. Moskva, 1995. S. 37–66. (In Russ.)
  11. Kozlov L.K. Istoricheskii fil’m [Historical film] // Kino. Enciklopedicheskii slovar’ [Cinema. Encyclopedic dictionary] / gl. red. S.I. Yutkevich. Moskva, 1987. S. 156–157. (In Russ.)
  12. Krylova Yu.P. Issledovanie franczuzskikh srednevekovykh dvorov v noveishei istoriografii Francii, Bel’gii, Niderlandov, Shvejczarii [The French Medieval Courts in the Latest Historiography of France, Belgium, the Netherlands and Switzerland] // Elektronnyj nauchno-obrazovatel’nyj zhurnal “Istoriya” [Electronic scientific and educational Journal “History”]. 2023. T. 14. Vyp. 3 (125). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840025025–6–1/ (access date: 30.01.2024). (In Russ.)
  13. Majzul’s M.R. Voobrazhaemyi vrag. Inovertsy v srednevekovoi ikonografii [An imaginary enemy. Gentiles in medieval iconography]. Moskva, 2022. (In Russ.)
  14. Rajces V.I. “Svidanie v Shinone”. Opyt rekonstruktsii [“Rendez-vous in Chinon”. A reconstruction attempt] // Kazus. Individual’noe i unikal’noe v istorii [Casus. Individual and unique in history] / pod red. M.A. Bojczova, I.N. Danilevskogo. Vyp. 5. Moskva, 2003. S. 42–59. (In Russ.)
  15. Togoeva O.I. “Deva so znamenem”. Istoriya Francii XV–XXI vekov v portretah Zhanny d’Ark [“The Maiden with a banner”. The history of France of the 15th-21st centuries in the portraits of Joan of Arc]. Moskva, 2023. (In Russ.)
  16. Togoeva O.I. Eretichka, stavshaya svyatoi. Dve zhizni Zhanny d’Ark [Heretic turned Saint. Two lifes of Joan of Arc]. Moskva; Sankt-Peterburg, 2016. (In Russ.)
  17. Amiel V. Les représentations de Jeanne d’Arc au cinéma // De l’hérétique à la sainte. Les procès de Jeanne d’Arc revisités / ed. par F. Neveux. Caen, 2012. P. 297–303.
  18. Aziza C. Le péplum: L’Antiquité au cinéma. Paris, 1998.
  19. Bouzy O. Jeanne d’Arc, les signes au roi et les entrevues de Chinon // Guerre, pouvoir et noblesse au Moyen Age. Mélanges en l’honneur de Philippe Contamine. Paris, 2000. P. 131–138.
  20. Brown E.A.R., Famiglietti R.C. The Lit de Justice. Semantics, Ceremonial, and the Parlement of Paris, 1300–1600. Sigmaringen, 1994.
  21. Cohen C. Le western. Paris, 2005.
  22. Contamine Ph., Bouzy O., Hélary X. Jeanne d’Arc. Histoire et dictionnaire. Paris, 2012.
  23. Du bon usage des grands hommes en Europe / sous la dir. de J.-N. Jeanneney, P. Joutard. Paris, 2003.
  24. Harmand A. Jeanne d’Arc, ses costumes, son armure. Essai de reconstruction. Paris, 1929.
  25. Harty K.J. Jeanne au cinéma // Fresh Verdicts on Joan of Arc / eds B. Wheeler, C.T. Wood. London; New York, 1996. P. 237–264.
  26. Harty K.J. The Reel Middle Ages: American, Western and Eastern European, Middle Eastern and Asian films about Medieval Europe. Jefferson; London, 1999.
  27. Heimann N.M. Joan of Arc in French Art and Culture (1700–1855). From Satire to Sanctity. Aldershot; Burlington, 2005.
  28. Hilaire Y.-M. Jeanne d’Arc, dès romantiques à nos jours // Histoire du Christianisme. 2008. № 43. P. 60–67.
  29. Mas E. Procès de canonisation de Jeanne d’Arc // Bulletin de l’Association des Amis du Centre Jeanne d’Arc. 1998. № 22. P. 51–72.
  30. Michaud-Fréjaville F. A Orléans, six siècles de commémoration // Histoire du Christianisme. 2008. № 43. P. 68–71.
  31. Michaud-Fréjaville F. Cinema, Histoire: autour du thème “johannique” // Cahiers de Recherches Médiévales. 2005. № 12. P. 285–300.
  32. Pessiot M. Illustre ou infortunée. Figures de Jeanne d’Arc au début du XIXe siècle // Jeanne d’Arc. Les tableaux de l’Histoire, 1820–1920. Paris, 2003. P. 17–33.
  33. Pinel V. “Joan of Arc” de Victor Fleming, ou l’hagiographie spectaculaire // Etudes cinématographiques. 1962. № 18–19. P. 58–64.
  34. Procès de condamnation de Jeanne d’Arc / eds par P. Tisset, Y. Lanhers: in 3 vols. Paris, 1960–1971.
  35. Procès en nullité de la condamnation de Jeanne d’Arc / ed. par P. Duparc: in 5 vols. Paris, 1977–1988.
  36. Prost A. Jeanne à la fête. Identité collective et mémoire à Orléans depuis la Révolution française // La France démocratique. Mélanges offertes à Maurice Agulhon / réunis et publ. par C. Charle, J. Lalouette, M. Rigenet, A.-M. Sohn. Paris, 1998. P. 379–393.
  37. Raytses V. La première entrevue de Jeanne d’Arc et de Charles VII à Chinon. Essai de reconstruction d’un fait historique // Bulletin de l’Association des Amis du Centre Jeanne d’Arc. 1989. № 13. P. 7–17.
  38. Renoux C. Faut-il canoniser Jeanne d’Arc? Les chemins de la béatification de la Pucelle d’Orléans (1429–1869) // Bulletin de la Société archéologique et historique de l’Orléanais. 2011. № 165. P. 5–65.
  39. Robé C. Taking Hollywood Back: The Historical Costume Drama, the Biopic, and Popular Front U.S. Film Criticism // Cinema Journal. 2008. T. 48 (2). P. 70–87.
  40. Rosenstone R.A. “Like writing history with lighting”: film historique/vérité historique // Vingtième Siècle. Revue d’histoire. 1995. T. 46. P. 162–175.
  41. Rosenstone R.A. History on Film/Film on History. London; New York, 2006.
  42. Sémolué J. “La Passion de Jeanne d’Arc”, prise de conscience de Carl Dreyer // Etudes cinématographiques. 1962. № 18–19. P. 38–52.
  43. Steinberg H. “Das Mädchen Johanna” de Gustav Ucicky, ou Jeanne et Gebbels // Etudes cinématographiques. 1962. № 18–19. P. 53–57.
  44. Swann P. The British Documentary Film Movement, 1926–1946. Cambridge, 1989.
  45. Tailleur R. L’Ouest et ses miroirs // Le Western. Approches, mythologies, auteurs, filmographies / sous la dir. de R. Bellour. Paris, 1993. P. 18–54.

版权所有 © Russian Academy of Sciences, 2024

##common.cookie##