Selective recovery and recycling of lithium: prospects for the use of membrane methods

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

In recent years, the interest of researchers in the problem of lithium extraction (production) has increased due to the drastic increase in its demand: according to the Scopus database, about 3000 scientific articles were published on this problem in 2021. The efforts of many specialists are aimed at the development of new, more economical and environmental-friendly membrane technologies for lithium extraction, replacing the reagent methods used. This review presents up-to-date information about traditional and promising methods of lithium recovery from natural solutions and solutions obtained during recycling of used batteries. The main attention is paid to membrane methods. Known approaches are classified and analyzed, experimental and theoretical aspects of Membrane Ion Separation are described, and known separation mechanisms and their mathematical models are discussed. Baro- and electromembrane methods relatively well developed at the laboratory level are considered, which are focused on the separation of lithium ions and other single-charged cations from mixed solutions containing large amounts of magnesium and calcium. The results of using commercial and laboratory membranes are compared. The newest approaches, which allow efficient separation of lithium ions from a mixture of single-charged cations, including the promising hybrid electrobaromembrane methods, are analyzed. Bibliography — 295 references.

About the authors

Dmitrii Yur'evich Butylskii

Kuban State University

Lasâad Dammak

University Paris-Est Creteil

Christian Larchet

University Paris-Est Creteil

Natalia Dmitrievna Pismenskaya

Kuban State University

Viktor Vasil'evich Nikonenko

Kuban State University

Email: nikon@iemm.univ-montp2.fr

References

  1. M.F.Lagadec, R.Zahn, V.Wood. Nat. Energy, 4, 16 (2019)
  2. C.Grosjean, P.H.Miranda, M.Perrin, P.Poggi. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 16, 1735 (2012)
  3. A.Anlauf. Fairn. Just. Nat. Res. Polit., 176 (2016); https://library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12657/46735/oa-9781317269885.pdf?sequence=1#page=177
  4. P.Friedlingstein, M.W.Jones, M.O Sullivan, R.M.Andrew, J.Hauck, G.P.Peters, W.Peters, J.Pongratz, S.Sitch, C.LeQuere, D.C.E. Bakker, J.G.Canadell, P.Ciais, R.B.Jackson, P.Anthoni, L.Barbero, A.Bastos, V.Bastrikov, M.Becker, L.Bopp, E.Buitenhuis, N.Chandra, F.Chevallier, L.P.Chini, K.I.Currie, R.A.Feely, M.Gehlen, D.Gilfillan, T.Gkritzalis, D.S.Goll, N.Gruber, S.Gutekunst, I.Harris, V.Haverd, R.A.Houghton, G.Hurtt, T.Ilyina, A.K.Jain, E.Joetzjer, J.O.Kaplan, E.Kato, K.KleinGoldewijk, J.I.Korsbakken, P.Landschutzer, S.K.Lauvset, N.Lefevre, A.Lenton, S.Lienert, D.Lombardozzi, G.Marland, P.C.McGuire, J.R.Melton, N.Metzl, D.R.Munro, J.E.M.S.Nabel, S.-I.Nakaoka, C.Neill, A.M.Omar, T.Ono, A.Peregon, D.Pierrot, B.Poulter, G.Rehder, L.Resplandy, E.Robertson, C.Rodenbeck, R.Seferian, J.Schwinger, N.Smith, P.P.Tans, H.Tian, B.Tilbrook, F.N.Tubiello, G.R.vanderWerf, A.J.Wiltshire, S.Zaehle. Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 11, 1783 (2019)
  5. A.R.Quinteros-Condoretty, S.R.Golroudbary, L.Albareda, B.Barbiellini, A.Soyer. Proc. CIRP, 100, 73 (2021)
  6. A.A.Makarov, T.A.Mitrova, V.A.Kulagin. In Global and Russian Energy Outlook 2019. (Moscow: ERI RAS Moscow School of Management SKOLKOVO, 2019). P. 210; https://www.eriras.ru/data/994/rus
  7. S.P.Filippov, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. Russ. Chem. Rev., 90, 627 (2021)
  8. J.F.Song, L.D.Nghiem, X.-M.Li, T.He. Environ. Sci. Water Res. Technol., 3, 593 (2017)
  9. P.W.Gruber, P.A.Medina, G.A.Keoleian, S.E.Kesler, M.P.Everson, T.J.Wallington. J. Ind. Ecol., 15, 760 (2011)
  10. D.E.Garrett. Handbook of Lithium and Natural Calcium Chloride. (The Nederlands: Elsevier, 2004)
  11. F.Meng, J.McNeice, S.S.Zadeh, A.Ghahreman. Miner. Process. Extr. Metall. Rev., 42, 123 (2021)
  12. J.Rioyo, S.Tuset, R.Grau. Miner. Process. Extr. Metall. Rev., 43, 97 (2022)
  13. C.Dessemond, F.Lajoie-Leroux, G.Soucy, N.Laroche, J.-F.Magnan. Minerals, 9, 334 (2019)
  14. P.Christmann, E.Gloaguen, J.-F.Labbe, J.Melleton, P.Piantone. In Lithium Process Chemistry. (The Nederlands: Elsevier, 2015). P. 40
  15. U.S.Geological Survey. In Mineral Commodity Summaries. (Natl. Miner. Inf. Cent., USA, 2022)
  16. Cypress Development Corp. In Clayton Valley Lithium Project. (Nevada, USA, 2022); https://www.centurylithium.com/projects/nevada/clayton-valley-lithium-project-nevada/
  17. Y.Zhang, Y.Hu, L.Wang, W.Sun. Miner. Eng., 139, 105868 (2019)
  18. A.H.Hamzaoui, A.M'nif, H.Hammi, R.Rokbani. Desalination, 158, 221 (2003)
  19. F.Heredia, A.L.Martinez, V.SurracoUrtubey. J. Energy Nat. Resour. Law, 38, 213 (2020)
  20. S.Zavahir, T.Elmakki, M.Gulied, Z.Ahmad, L.Al-Sulaiti, H.K.Shon, Y.Chen, H.Park, B.Batchelor, D.S.Han. Desalination, 500, 114883 (2021)
  21. A.Siekierka, M.Bryjak, A.Razmjou, W.Kujawski, A.N.Nikoloski, L.F.Dumee. Membranes, 12, 343 (2022)
  22. B.Swain. Sep. Purif. Technol., 172, 388 (2017)
  23. C.B.Tabelin, J.Dallas, S.Casanova, T.Pelech, G.Bournival, S.Saydam, I.Canbulat. Miner. Eng., 163, 106743 (2021)
  24. S.H.Park, J.H.Kim, S.J.Moon, J.T.Jung, H.H.Wang, A.Ali, C.A.Quist-Jensen, F.Macedonio, E.Drioli, Y.M.Lee. J. Membr. Sci., 598, 117683 (2020)
  25. N.N.R.Ahmad, W.L.Ang, Y.H.Teow, A.W.Mohammad, N.Hilal. J. Water Process Eng., 45, 102478 (2022)
  26. T.Zhang, W.Zheng, Q.Wang, Z.Wu, Z.Wang. Desalination, 546, 116205 (2023)
  27. Y.Sun, Q.Wang, Y.Wang, R.Yun, X.Xiang. Sep. Purif. Technol., 256, 117807 (2021)
  28. X.Li, Y.Mo, W.Qing, S.Shao, C.Y.Tang, J.Li. J. Membr. Sci., 591, 117317 (2019)
  29. D.Bradley, L.Munk, H.Jochens, S.Hynek, K.Labay. US Dep. Inter. US Geol. Surv., 1 (2013); https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2013/1006/OF13-1006.pdf
  30. H.Guo, G.Kuang, H.Wang, H.Yu, X.Zhao. Minerals, 7, 205 (2017)
  31. N.K.Salakjani, P.Singh, A.N.Nikoloski. Miner. Process. Extr. Metall. Rev., 42, 268 (2021)
  32. W.-S.Chen, C.-H.Lee, H.-J.Ho. Appl. Sci., 8, 2252 (2018)
  33. W.Wang, W.Chen, H.Liu. Hydrometallurgy, 185, 88 (2019)
  34. A.Karrech, M.R.Azadi, M.Elchalakani, M.A.Shahin, A.C.Seibi. Miner. Eng., 145, 106085 (2020)
  35. N.Linneen, R.Bhave, D.Woerner. Sep. Purif. Technol., 214, 168 (2019)
  36. T.Tran, V.T.Luong. In Lithium Process Chemistry. (The Nederlands: Elsevier, 2004). P. 81
  37. B.C.Peek. In NI 43-101 Technical Report. (Clayton Valley, Nevada, USA, 2021). P. 78; https://noramlithiumcorp.com/site/assets/files/3886/2021-09-21-ni-43-101-report.pdf
  38. J.J.Riordan, A.D.Thompson, E.V.Coetzee, S.Nupen. In NI 43-101 Technical Report. (DRA Pacific, Australia, 2020). P. 228; https://minedocs.com/20/Falchani_PEA_03192020.pdf
  39. C.Pelletier, S.Boudreau, F.Baril, W.R.McBride, E.Poirier, O.Joyal. In NI 43-101 Technical Report. (WSP, Canada, 2022). P. 438; https://www.cecorp.ca/wp-content/uploads/161-14192-03_RPT-01_R1_V1_CELC_Rose-FS-2022.pdf
  40. H.Samari, R.Moritz, J.T.Harvey, T.Lane. In NI 43-101 Technical Report. (Nye County, USA), 2021. P. 208; https://nvlithium.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Bonnie-Claire-PEA-Technical-Report-Final.pdf
  41. I.Ezama, C.R.Hoyos, P.Cortegoso,T.Braun. Tailings and Mine Waste Conference, 8 (2018); https://dxi97tvbmhbca.cloudfront.net/upload/user/image/Ezama-Hoyos-Cortegoso-Braun-Spent_Brine_Disposal-TMW_Paper20191128190251287.pdf (access date 07.04.2023)
  42. M.King, M.Dworzanowski. In NI 43-101 Technical Report. (Neo Lithium corp., Catamarca, Argentina, 2021). pp. 368; https://minedocs.com/21/Tres-Quebradas-FS-11252021.pdf (access date 07.04.2023)
  43. V.Flexer, C.F.Baspineiro, C.I.Galli. Sci. Total Environ., 639, 1188 (2018)
  44. F.Reidel, P.Ehren, M.Dworzanowski. In NI 43-101 Technical report. (Atacama Water and Worley, Chile, 2022). pp. 416; https://lithiumpowerinternational.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/NI43-101_DFS2022_LR.pdf (access date 07.04.2023)
  45. M.Yu, B.Bai, S. Xiong, X.Liao. J. Clean. Prod., 321, 128935 (2021)
  46. Y.Chen, Y.Kang, Y.Zhao, L.Wang, J.Liu, Y.Li, Z.Liang, X.He, X.Li, N.Tavajohi, B.Li. J. Energy Chem., 59, 83 (2021)
  47. X.Zhang, Y.Xie, X.Lin, H.Li, H.Cao. J. Mater. Cycles Waste Manag., 15, 420 (2013)
  48. C.Peng, F.Liu, Z.Wang, B.P.Wilson, M.Lundstrom. J. Power Sources, 415, 179 (2019)
  49. Y.Zhao, T.Ruther, J.Staines. In Technical Report. (CSIRO, Australia, 2021). P. 111; https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Yanyan-Zhao-8/publication/350342227_Australian_landscape_for_lithium-ion_battery_recycling_and_reuse_in_2020_CURRENT_STATUS_GAP_ANALYSIS_AND_INDUSTRY_PERSPECTIVES_Produced_for_the_Future_Battery_Industries_CRC/links/605ab41e458515e83467fb46/Australian-landscape-for-lithium-ion-battery-recycling-and-reuse-in-2020-CURRENT-STATUS-GAP-ANALYSIS-AND-INDUSTRY-PERSPECTIVES-Produced-for-the-Future-Battery-Industries-CRC.pdf
  50. N.Bhandari, A.Cai, K.Yuzawa, J.Zhang, V.Joshi, F.Fang, G.Lee, R.Harada, S.Shin. In Technical Report. (The Goldman Sachs Group, USA, 2022). P. 33; https://www.goldmansachs.com/insights/pages/gs-research/batteries-the-greenflation-challenge/report.pdf
  51. S.Al-Thyabat, T.Nakamura, E.Shibata, A.Iizuka. Miner. Eng., 45, 4 (2013)
  52. O.Velazquez-Martinez, J.Valio, A.Santasalo-Aarnio, M.Reuter, R.Serna-Guerrero. Batteries, 5, 68 (2019)
  53. G.J.Doornbusch, M.Tedesco, J.W.Post, Z.Borneman, K.Nijmeijer. Desalination, 464, 105 (2019)
  54. N.Jacquet, S.Wurtzer, G.Darracq, Y.Wyart, L.Moulin, P.Moulin. J. Membr. Sci., 634, 119417 (2021)
  55. N.N.R.Ahmad, W.L.Ang, C.P.Leo, A.W.Mohammad, N.Hilal. Desalination, 517, 115170 (2021)
  56. M.Elimelech, W.A.Phillip. Science, 333, 712 (2011)
  57. W.-H.Zhang, M.-J.Yin, Q.Zhao, C.-G.Jin, N.Wang, S.Ji, C.L.Ritt, M.Elimelech, Q.-F.An. Nat. Nanotechnol., 16, 337 (2021)
  58. H.Strathmann. Desalination, 264, 268 (2010)
  59. A.W.Mohammad, Y.H.Teow, W.L.Ang, Y.T.Chung, D.L.Oatley-Radcliffe, N.Hilal. Desalination, 356, 226 (2015)
  60. P.Y.Apel, O.V.Bobreshova, A.V.Volkov, V.V.Volkov, V.V.Nikonenko, I.A.Stenina, A.N.Filippov, Y.P.Yampolskii, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. Membr. Membr. Technol., 1, 45 (2019)
  61. C.Li, D.L.Ramasamy, M.Sillanpaa, E.Repo. Sep. Purif. Technol., 254, 117442 (2021)
  62. J.-M.AranaJuve, F.M.S.Christensen, Y.Wang, Z.Wei. Chem. Eng. J., 435, 134857 (2022)
  63. H.B.Park, J.Kamcev, L.M.Robeson, M.Elimelech, B.D.Freeman. Science, 356, eaab0530 (2017)
  64. B.E.Logan, M.Elimelech. Nature (London), 488, 313 (2012)
  65. J.R.Varcoe, P.Atanassov, D.R.Dekel, A.M.Herring, M.A.Hickner, P.A.Kohl, A.R.Kucernak, W.E.Mustain, K.Nijmeijer, K.Scott, T.Xu, L.Zhuang. Energy Environ. Sci., 7, 3135 (2014)
  66. A.Y.Alent'ev, A.V.Volkov, I.V.Vorotyntsev, A.L.Maksimov, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. Membr. Technol., 3, 255 (2021)
  67. A.Yaksic, J.E.Tilton. Resour. Policy, 34, 185 (2009)
  68. T.Sata, T.Sata, M.Yang. J. Membr. Sci., 206, 31 (2002)
  69. W.Wang, R.Liu, M.Tan, H.Sun, Q.J.Niu, T.Xu, V.Nikonenko,Y.Zhang. J. Membr. Sci., 582, 236 (2019)
  70. F.G.Helfferich. In Ion Exchange. (NewYork: McGraw-Hill, 1962). P. 465; https://books.google.ru/books?hl=ru&lr=&id=F9OQMEA88CAC&oi=fnd&pg=PA1&dq=F.G.+Helfferich+Ion+Exchange+1962&ots=848ETU_P1x&sig=yCjHGOuhX57REDpVzOw_urIRl78&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false
  71. K.Kontturi, L.Murtomaki, J.A.Manzanares. In Electrochemistry and Membrane Science. (Oxford University Press, 2008). P. 304
  72. S.-T.Hwang, K.Kammermeyer. In Electromembrane Processes Membranes in Separation. Techniques of Chemistry. (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1975). P. 559
  73. V.I.Zabolotskii, V.V.Nikonenko. In Ion Transport in Membranes. (Moscow: Nauka, 1996). P. 390; https://echemistry.ru/literatura/prochee/zabolockij-v.i.-nikonenko-v.v.-perenos-ionov-v-membranah.-m.-nauka-1996.-392-s.html
  74. D.Y.Butylskii, N.D.Pismenskaya, P.Y.Apel, K.G.Sabbatovskiy, V.V.Nikonenko. J. Membr. Sci., 635, 119449 (2021)
  75. N.Pismenskaya, N.Melnik, E.Nevakshenova, K.Nebavskaya, V.NikonenkoInt. J. Chem. Eng., 2012, 1, 170 (2012)
  76. H.Strathmann. In Membrane Science and Technology. (The Nederlands: Elsevier Science, 2004). P. 360; https://books.google.ru/books?hl=ru&lr=&id=pcNF7HWbFPIC&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&ots=SMZ400_AYD&sig=BzeW8Mfwz8iCH1nzB_AgljQOuLQ&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false
  77. S.Burn, M.Hoang, D.Zarzo, F.Olewniak, E.Campos, B.Bolto, O.Barron. Desalination, 364, 2 (2015)
  78. X.Li, C.Zhang, S.Zhang, J.Li, B.He, Z.Cui. Desalination, 369, 26 (2015)
  79. Y.Xu, H.Peng, H.Luo, Q.Zhang, Z.Liu, Q.Zhao. Desalination, 526, 115519 (2022)
  80. M.A.Ashraf, J.Wang, B.Wu, P.Cui, B.Xu, X.Li J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 137, 49549 (2020)
  81. https://www.sterlitech.com/flat-sheet-membranes.html (access date 22.01.2023)
  82. Y.-F.Zhang, L.Liu, J.Du, R.Fu, B.Van der Bruggen, Y.Zhang. J. Membr. Sci., 523, 385 (2017)
  83. H.-Z.Zhang, Z.-L.Xu, H.Ding, Y.-J.Tang. Desalination, 420, 158 (2017)
  84. Y.Mizutani. J. Membr. Sci., 54, 233 (1990)
  85. F.Sheng, N.U.Afsar, Y.Zhu, L.Ge, T.Xu. Membranes, 10, 114 (2020)
  86. T.Sata, K.Mine, M.Higa. J. Membr. Sci., 141, 137 (1998)
  87. T.Sata. J. Membr. Sci., 167, 1 (2000)
  88. I.Louati, F.Guesmi, C.Hannachi, B.Hamrouni. Can. J. Chem. Eng., 94, 2386 (2016)
  89. J.Pan, J.Ding, R.Tan, G.Chen, Y.Zhao, C.Gao, B.V.der Bruggen, J.Shen. J. Membr. Sci., 539, 263 (2017)
  90. A.Somrani, A.H.Hamzaoui, M.Pontie. Desalination, 317, 184 (2013)
  91. D.Zhang, Y.Wang, X.Wang, B.Chen, Y.Wang, C.Jiang, T.Xu. Chem. Eng. Sci., 245, 116873 (2021)
  92. D.Lu, T.Ma, S.Lin, Z.Zhou, G.Li, Q.An, Z.Yao, Q.Sun, Z.Sun, L.Zhang. J. Membr. Sci., 635, 119504 (2021)
  93. F.Soyekwo, H.Wen, D.Liao, C.Liu. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 14, 32420 (2022)
  94. P.Xu, J.Hong, X.Qian, Z.Xu, H.Xia, Q.-Q.Ni. Desalination, 488, 114522 (2020)
  95. P.Xu, J.Hong, Z.Xu, H.Xia, Q.-Q.Ni. Sep. Purif. Technol., 270, 118796 (2021)
  96. C.Guo, N.Li, X.Qian, J.Shi, M.Jing, K.Teng, Z.Xu. Sep. Purif. Technol., 230, 115567 (2020)
  97. W.Li, C.Shi, A.Zhou, X.He, Y.Sun, J.Zhang. Sep. Purif. Technol., 186, 233 (2017)
  98. H.Peng, Q.Zhao. Adv. Funct. Mater., 31, 2009430 (2021)
  99. H.Strathmann. In Ullmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry. Wiley, Weinheim, Germany, 2011. P. 413
  100. T.Sata. J. Membr. Sci., 93, 117 (1994)
  101. X.-Y. Nie, S.-Y.Sun, Z.Sun, X.Song, J.-G.Yu. Desalination, 403, 128 (2017)
  102. M.Galizia, F.M.Benedetti, D.R.Paul, B.D.Freeman. J. Membr. Sci., 535, 132 (2017)
  103. C.Zhao, J.Zhang, G.He, T.Wang, D.Hou, Z.Luan. Chem. Eng. J., 233, 224 (2013)
  104. T.Bello, Z.Slouka. J. Membr. Sci., 610, 118291 (2020)
  105. V.D.Titorova, I.A.Moroz, S.A.Mareev, N.D.Pismenskaya, K.G.Sabbatovskii, Y.Wang, T.Xu, V.V.Nikonenko. J. Membr. Sci., 644, 120149 (2022)
  106. N.White, M.Misovich, A.Yaroshchuk, M.L.Bruening. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 7, 6620 (2015)
  107. T.Luo, S.Abdu, M.Wessling. J. Membr. Sci., 555, 429 (2018)
  108. V.I.Zabolotsky, A.R.Achoh, K.A.Lebedev, S.S.Melnikov. J. Membr. Sci., 608, 118152 (2020)
  109. S.Abdu, M.-C.Marti-Calatayud, J.E.Wong, M.Garcia-Gabaldon, M.Wessling. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 6, 1843 (2014)
  110. E.Evdochenko, J.Kamp, R.Femmer, Y.Xu, V.V.Nikonenko, M.Wessling. J. Membr. Sci., 611, 118045 (2020)
  111. L.Paltrinieri, K.Remmen, B.Muller, L.Chu, J.Koser, T.Wintgens, M.Wessling, L.C.P.MdeSmet, E.J.R. Sudholter. J. Membr. Sci., 587, 117162 (2019)
  112. G.Saracco. Chem. Eng. Sci., 52, 3019 (1997)
  113. Y.Zhao, K.Tang, Q.Liu, B.VanderBruggen, A.S.Diaz, J.Pan, C.Gao, J.Shen. RSC Adv., 6, 16548 (2016)
  114. J.Moreno, V.Diez, M.Saakes, K.Nijmeijer. J. Membr. Sci., 550, 155 (2018)
  115. J.Ying, M.Luo, Y.Jin, J.Yu. Desalination, 492, 114621 (2020)
  116. X.-C.Zhang, J.Wang, Z.-Y.Ji, P.-Y.Ji, J.Liu, Y.-Y.Zhao, F.Li, J.-S.Yuan. J. Environ. Chem. Eng., 9, 106635 (2021)
  117. P.-Y.Ji, Z.-Y.Ji, Q.-B.Chen, J.Liu, Y.-Y.Zhao, S.-Z.Wang, F.Li, J.-S.Yuan. Sep. Purif. Technol., 207, 1 (2018)
  118. Y.Qiu, H.Ruan, C.Tang, L.Yao, J.Shen, A.Sotto. ACS Sustain. Chem. Eng., 7, 13481 (2019)
  119. Y.Zhou, H.Yan, X.Wang, L.Wu, Y.Wang, T.Xu. Desalination, 425, 30 (2018)
  120. G.Martin, A.Schneider, W.Voigt, M.Bertau. Miner. Eng., 110, 75 (2017)
  121. K.H.Chan, M.Malik, G.Azimi. Resour. Conserv. Recycl., 178, 106076 (2022)
  122. S.Gmar, A.Chagnes, F.Lutin, L.Muhr. Recycling, 7, 14 (2022)
  123. A.Siekierka, F.Yalcinkaya. Sep. Purif. Technol., 299, 121695 (2022)
  124. Y.Song, Z.ZhaoSep. Purif. Technol., 206, 335 (2018)
  125. M.Shi, L.A.Diaz, J.R.Klaehn, A.D.Wilson, T.E.Lister. ACS Sustain. Chem. Eng., 10, 11773 (2022)
  126. E.Guler, W.vanBaak, M.Saakes, K.Nijmeijer. J. Membr. Sci., 455, 254 (2014)
  127. L.Ge, B.Wu, D.Yu, A.N.Mondal, L.Hou, N.U.Afsar, Q.Li, T.Xu, J.Miao, T.XuChinese. J. Chem. Eng., 25, 1606 (2017)
  128. D.V.Golubenko, Y.A.Karavanova, S.S.Melnikov, A.R.Achoh, G.Pourcelly, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. J. Membr. Sci., 563, 777 (2018)
  129. M.Ahmad, A.Yaroshchuk, M.L.Bruening. J. Membr. Sci., 616, 118570 (2020)
  130. W.Jiang, L.Lin, X.Xu, H.Wang, P.Xu. J. Membr. Sci., 572, 545 (2019)
  131. J.Balster, O.Krupenko, I.Punt, D.Stamatialis, M.Wessling. J. Membr. Sci., 263, 137 (2005)
  132. J.Kerres, W.Cui, R.Disson, W.Neubrand. J. Membr. Sci., 139, 211 (1998)
  133. I.Ali, M.A.Raza, R.Mehmood, A.Islam, A.Sabir, N.Gull, B.Haider, S.H.Park, R.U.Khan. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 21, 7338 (2020)
  134. T.Chakrabarty, M.Kumar, K.P.Rajesh, V.K.Shahi, T.S.Natarajan. Sep. Purif. Technol., 75, 174 (2010)
  135. D.V.Golubenko, R.R.Shaydullin, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. Colloid Polym. Sci., 297, 741 (2019)
  136. I.Stenina, D.Golubenko, V.Nikonenko, A.Yaroslavtsev. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 21, 5517 (2020)
  137. Y.Zhao, Y.Liu, C.Wang, E.Ortega, X.Wang, Y.F.Xie, J.Shen, C.Gao, B.VanderBruggen. J. Mater. Chem. A, 8, 4244 (2020)
  138. N.U.Afsar, M.A.Shehzad, M.Irfan, K.Emmanuel, F.Sheng, T.Xu, X.Ren, L.Ge, T.Xu. Desalination, 458, 25 (2019)
  139. M.B.Bajestani, A.Moheb, M.Dinari. Desalination, 486, 114476 (2020)
  140. Z.Zhao, G.Liu, H.Jia, L.He. J. Membr. Sci., 596, 117685 (2020)
  141. G.Zante, M.Boltoeva, A.Masmoudi, R.Barillon, D.Trebouet. J. Membr. Sci., 580, 62 (2019)
  142. Z.Qian, H.Miedema, S.Sahin, L.C.P.M.deSmet, E.J.R.Sudholter. Desalination, 495, 114631 (2020)
  143. E.P.Horwitz, R.Chiarizia, H.Diamond, R.C.Gatrone, S.D.Alexandratos, A.Q.Trochimczuk, D.W.Crick. Solv. Extr. Ion Exch., 11, 943 (1993)
  144. A.Munchinger, K.-D.Kreuer. J. Membr. Sci., 592, 117372 (2019)
  145. H.J.Cassady, E.C.Cimino, M.Kumar, M.A.Hickner. J. Membr. Sci., 508, 146 (2016)
  146. T.Hoshino. Desalination, 359, 59 (2015)
  147. T.Ounissi, L.Dammak, C.Larchet, J.-F.Fauvarque, E.S.B.H.Hmida. J. Mater. Sci., 55, 16111 (2020)
  148. T.Ounissi, R.B.Ammar, C.Larchet, L.Chaabane, L.Baklouti, L.Dammak, E.S.B.H.Hmida. Membranes, 12, 244 (2022)
  149. X.Yan, S.Anguille, M.Bendahan, P.Moulin. Sep. Purif. Technol., 222, 230 (2019)
  150. M.A.Malik, M.A.Hashim, F.Nabi. Chem. Eng. J., 171, 242 (2011)
  151. A.J.B.Kemperman, D.Bargeman, T.V.D.Boomgaard, H.Strathmann. Sep. Sci. Technol., 31, 2733 (1996)
  152. A.Razmjou, G.Eshaghi, Y.Orooji, E.Hosseini, A.H.Korayem, F.Mohagheghian, Y.Boroumand, A.Noorbakhsh, M.Asadnia, V.Chen. Water Res., 159, 313 (2019)
  153. H.Zhang, J.Hou, Y.Hu, P.Wang, R.Ou, L.Jiang, J.Z.Liu, B.D.Freeman, A.J.Hill, H.Wang. Sci. Adv., 4, (2018)
  154. P.P.Sharma, V.Yadav, A.Rajput, H.Gupta, H.Saravaia, V.Kulshrestha. Desalination, 496, 114755 (2020)
  155. A.Gonzalez, M.Grageda, A.Quispe, S.Ushak, P.Sistat, M.Cretin. Membranes, 11, 575 (2021)
  156. R.Parnamae, S.Mareev, V.Nikonenko, S.Melnikov, N.Sheldeshov, V.Zabolotskii, H.V.M.Hamelers, M.Tedesco. J. Membr. Sci., 617, 118538 (2021)
  157. Y.Zhao, X.Xiang, M.Wang, H.Wang, Y.Li, J.Li, H.Yang. Desalination, 512, 115126 (2021)
  158. D.Ipekci, N.Kabay, S.Bunani, E.Altok, M.Arda, K.Yoshizuka, S.Nishihama. Desalination, 479, 114313 (2020)
  159. S.Bunani, K.Yoshizuka, S.Nishihama, M.Arda, N.Kabay. Desalination, 424, 37 (2017)
  160. W.R.Torres, C.H.D.Nieto, A.Prevoteau, K.Rabaey, V.Flexer. J. Membr. Sci., 615, 118416 (2020)
  161. C.H.D.Nieto, K.Rabaey, V.Flexer. Sep. Purif. Technol., 252, 117410 (2020)
  162. P.Agarwal, I.Tomlinson, R.E.Hefner, S.Ge, Y.Rao, T.Dikic. J. Membr. Sci., 572, 475 (2019)
  163. V.Freger Environ. Sci. Technol., 38, 3168 (2004)
  164. S.Bason, Y.Oren, V.Freger. J. Membr. Sci., 367, 119 (2011)
  165. A.Yaroshchuk, M.L.Bruening, E.E.LiconBernal. J. Membr. Sci., 447, 463 (2013)
  166. A.Yaroshchuk. Sep. Purif. Technol., 22-23, 143 (2001)
  167. D.L.Oatley-Radcliffe, M.Walters, T.J.Ainscough, P.M.Williams, A.W.Mohammad, N.Hilal. J. Water Process Eng., 19, 164 (2017)
  168. P.M.Biesheuvel, S.Porada, M.Elimelech, J.E.Dykstra. J. Membr. Sci., 647, 120221 (2022)
  169. V.V.Nikonenko, A.B.Yaroslavtsev, G.Pourcelly. In Ionic Interactions in Natural and Synthetic Macromolecules. John Wiley & Sons, 2012. P. 267
  170. X.-L.Wang, T.Tsuru, S.Nakao, S.Kimura. J. Membr. Sci., 135, 19 (1997)
  171. D.-X.Wang, M.Su, Z.-Y.Yu, X.-L.Wang, M.Ando, T.Shintani. Desalination, 175, 219 (2005)
  172. A.Szymczyk, P.Fievet. J. Membr. Sci., 252, 77 (2005)
  173. S.Ilyas, R.English, P.Aimar, J.-F.Lahitte, W.M.deVos. Colloids Surf. A: Phys.-Chem. Eng. Asp., 533, 286 (2017)
  174. A.Yaroshchuk, M.L.Bruening, E.Zholkovskiy. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci., 268, 39 (2019)
  175. R.Wang, S.Lin. J. Membr. Sci., 620, 118809 (2021)
  176. V.Fila, K.Bouzek. J. Appl. Electrochem., 33, 675 (2003)
  177. M.Tedesco, H.V.M.Hamelers, P.M.Biesheuvel. J. Membr. Sci., 510, 370 (2016)
  178. A.Campione, L.Gurreri, M.Ciofalo, G.Micale, A.Tamburini, A.Cipollina. Desalination, 434, 121 (2018)
  179. J.Kamcev, R.Sujanani, E.-S.Jang, N.Yan, N.Moe, D.R.Paul, B.D.Freeman. J. Membr. Sci., 547, 123 (2018)
  180. S.Mareev, A.Gorobchenko, D.Ivanov, D.Anokhin, V.Nikonenko. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 24, 34 (2022)
  181. A.E.Yaroshchuk. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci., 85, 193 (2000)
  182. A.Moliton. In Basic Electromagnetism and Materials. (New York: Springer, 2007). P. 39; https://picture.iczhiku.com/resource/eetop/ShiyazkGGeZurCvc.pdf
  183. S.Bandini, D.Vezzani. Chem. Eng. Sci., 58, 3303 (2003)
  184. E.Glueckauf. In Proceeding of the First International Symposium on Water Desalination. (Washington, 1965). P. 143; https://books.google.ru/books?id=JChow5kkCmYC&printsec=frontcover&hl=ru&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false (access date 07.04.2023)
  185. M.S.Hall, V.N.Starov, D.R.Lloyd. J. Membr. Sci., 128, 23 (1997)
  186. R.Vacassy. J. Membr. Sci., 132, 109 (1997)
  187. J.Schaep. Sep. Purif. Technol., 22-23, 169 (2001)
  188. A.Szymczyk, H.Zhu, B.Balannec. J. Phys. Chem. B, 114, 10143 (2010)
  189. Y.I.Dirir, Y.Hanafi, A.Ghoufi, A.Szymczyk. Langmuir, 31, 451 (2015)
  190. A.Yaroshchuk, Y.Zhu, M.Bondarenko, M.L.Bruening. Langmuir, 32, 2644 (2016)
  191. O.Kedem, A.Katchalsky. Trans. Faraday Soc., 59, 1918 (1963)
  192. S.Koter. Desalination, 198, 335 (2006)
  193. K.S.Spiegler, O.Kedem. Desalination, 1, 311 (1966)
  194. O.Kedem, V.Freger. J. Membr. Sci., 310, 586 (2008)
  195. A.E.Yaroshchuk. J. Membr. Sci., 198, 285 (2002)
  196. A.Filippov, T.Philippova. Colloids Interfaces, 6, 34 (2022)
  197. J.Happel, H.Brenner. In Mechanics of Fluids and Transport Processes. (The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1991). P. 564; https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-94-009-8352-6
  198. A.N.Filippov. Colloid J., 80, 716 (2018)
  199. A.N.Filippov. Colloid J., 80, 728 (2018)
  200. A.N.Filippov. Colloid J., 84 33243 (2022)
  201. A.N.Filippov, S.A.Shkirskaya. Colloid J., 81 597 (2019)
  202. A.N.Filippov, N.A.Kononenko, N.V.Loza, D.S.Kopitsyn, D.A.Petrova. Electrochim. Acta, 389, 138768 (2021)
  203. A.N.Filippov, Y.O.Koroleva, A.K.Verma. Membr. Membr. Technol., 2, 230 (2020)
  204. A.N.Filippov, T.S.Philippova. Membr. Membr. Technol., 3 15 (2021)
  205. Z.V.P.Murthy, L.B.Chaudhari. Chem. Eng. J., 150, 181 (2009)
  206. H.Kelewou, A.Lhassani, M.Merzouki, P.Drogui, B.Sellamuthu. Desalination, 277, 106 (2011)
  207. Z.Kovacs, M.Discacciati, W.Samhaber. J. Membr. Sci., 332, 38 (2009)
  208. A.M.Hidalgo, G.Leon, M.Gomez, M.D.Murcia, E.Gomez, J.A.Macario. Membranes, 10, 408 (2020)
  209. F.Wu, L.Feng, L.Zhang. Desalination, 362, 11 (2015)
  210. Y.Zhang, L.Zhang, L.Hou, S.Kuang, A.Yu. AIChE J., 65, 1076 (2019)
  211. B.DeJaegher, W.DeSchepper, A.Verliefde, I.Nopens. J. Membr. Sci., 642, 119975 (2022)
  212. P.Y.Apel, S.Velizarov, A.V.Volkov, T.V.Eliseeva, V.V.Nikonenko, A.V.Parshina, N.D.Pismenskaya, K.I.Popov, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. Membr. Membr. Technol., 4, 69 (2022)
  213. R.Femmer, A.Mani, M.Wessling. Sci. Rep., 5, 11583 (2015)
  214. R.Femmer, M.C.Marti-Calatayud, M.Wessling. J. Memb. Sci., 520, 29 (2016)
  215. E.Evdochenko, J.Kamp, R.Dunkel, V.V.Nikonenko, M.Wessling. J. Membr. Sci., 636, 119533 (2021)
  216. H.Zhu, A.Szymczyk, B.Balannec. J. Membr. Sci., 379, 215 (2011)
  217. B.DeJaegher, W.DeSchepper, A.Verliefde, I.Nopens. Sep. Purif. Technol., 259, 118028 (2021)
  218. M.K.Urtenov, A.M.Uzdenova, A.V.Kovalenko, V.V.Nikonenko, N.D.Pismenskaya, V.I.Vasil'eva, P.Sistat, G.Pourcelly. J. Membr. Sci., 447, 190 (2013)
  219. W.R.Bowen, M.G.Jones, J.S.Welfoot, H.N.S.Yousef. Desalination, 129, 147 (2000)
  220. G.Jing, W.Du, Y.Guo. Desalination, 291, 78 (2012)
  221. M.Asghari, A.Dashti, M.Rezakazemi, E.Jokar, H.Halakoei. Rev. Chem. Eng., 36, 265 (2020)
  222. J.Jawad, A.H.Hawari, S.J.Zaidi. Chem. Eng. J., 419, 129540 (2021)
  223. D.Rall, D.Menne, A.M.Schweidtmann, J.Kamp, L.V.Kolzenberg, A.Mitsos, M.Wessling. J. Membr. Sci., 569, 209 (2019)
  224. D.Rall, A.M.Schweidtmann, M.Kruse, E.Evdochenko, A.Mitsos, M.Wessling. J. Membr. Sci., 608, 118208 (2020)
  225. H.Al-Zoubi, N.Hilal, N.A.Darwish, A.W.Mohammad. Desalination, 206, 42 (2007)
  226. B.DeJaegher, E.Larumbe, W.DeSchepper, A.Verliefde, I.Nopens. Sep. Purif. Technol., 249, 116939 (2020)
  227. Y.Oren, A.Litan. J. Phys. Chem., 78, 1805 (1974)
  228. V.V.Nikonenko, V.I.Zabolotskii, N.P.Gnusin. Sov. Electrochem., 16, 472 (1980)
  229. S.Mafe, V.M.Aguilella, J.Pellicer. J. Membr. Sci., 36, 497 (1988)
  230. N.A.Mishchuk, S.V.Verbich, F.Gonzales-Caballero. Colloid J., 63, 586 (2001)
  231. M.I.Ponomarev, L.K.Zhiginas, R.D.Chebotareva, V.D.Grebenyuk. Elektrokhimiya, 19, 387 (1983)
  232. A.Chapotot, G.Pourcelly, C.Gavach. J. Membr. Sci., 96, 167 (1994)
  233. G.Pourcelly, P.Sistat, A.Chapotot, C.Gavach, V.Nikonenko. J. Membr. Sci., 110, 69 (1996)
  234. A.Filippov, D.Afonin, N.Kononenko, Y.Lvov, V.Vinokurov. Colloids Surfaces A Physicochem. Eng. Asp., 521, 251 (2017)
  235. I.Y.Kharkats. Sov. Electrochem., 21, (1986); https://www.osti.gov/biblio/5239221
  236. M.A.K.Urtenov, E.V.Kirillova, N.M.Seidova, V.V.Nikonenko. J. Phys. Chem. B, 111, 14208 (2007)
  237. A.R.Achoh, V.I.Zabolotsky, K.A.Lebedev, M.V.Sharafan, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. Membr. Membr. Technol., 3, 52 (2021)
  238. D.V.Golubenko, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. J. Membr. Sci., 635, 119466 (2021)
  239. A.Gorobchenko, S.Mareev, V.Nikonenko. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 23, 4711 (2022)
  240. A.D.Gorobchenko, V.V.Gil, V.V.Nikonenko, M.V.Sharafan. Membr. Membr. Technol., 4, 423 (2022)
  241. L.M.Robeson. J. Membr. Sci., 320, 390 (2008)
  242. D.F.Sanders, Z.P.Smith, R.Guo, L.M.Robeson, J.E.McGrath, D.R.Paul, B.D.Freeman. Polymer, 54, 4729 (2013)
  243. J.-M.Restrepo-Florez, M.Maldovan. Sep. Purif. Technol., 228, 115762 (2019)
  244. Y.Yampolskii, N.Belov, A.Alentiev. J. Membr. Sci., 598, 117779 (2020)
  245. D.V.Golubenko, G.Pourcelly, A.B.Yaroslavtsev. Sep. Purif. Technol., 207, 329 (2018)
  246. G.Zante, M.Boltoeva, A.Masmoudi, R.Barillon, D.Trebouet. J. Fluor. Chem., 236, 109593 (2020)
  247. S.Yang, F.Zhang, H.Ding, P.He, H.Zhou. Joule, 2, 1648 (2018)
  248. M.S.Palagonia, D.Brogioli, F.LaMantia. Desalination, 475, 114192 (2020)
  249. T.Ounissi, L.Dammak, J.-F.Fauvarque, E.S.B.H.Hmida. Sep. Purif. Technol., 275, 119134 (2021)
  250. H.Kazemzadeh, J.Karimi-Sabet, J.T.Darian, A.Adhami. Sep. Purif. Technol., 251, 117298 (2020)
  251. P.Wang, M.Wang, F.Liu, S.Ding, X.Wang, G.Du, J.Liu, P.Apel, P.Kluth, C.Trautmann, Y.Wang. Nat. Commun., 9, 569 (2018)
  252. Q.Wen, D.Yan, F.Liu, M.Wang, Y.Ling, P.Wang, P.Kluth, D.Schauries, C.Trautmann, P.Apel, W.Guo, G.Xiao, J.Liu, J.Xue, Y.Wang. Adv. Funct. Mater., 26, 5796 (2016)
  253. Y.I.Dytnerskii, A.E.Savkin, V.D.Sobolev, N.V.Churaev. Theor. Found. Chem. Eng., 15, 208 (1982)
  254. Y.V.Karlin, V.Y.Chuikov, Y.I.Dytnerskii. Russ. J. Electrochem., 32, 641 (1996); https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=13244675
  255. A.Yaroshchuk. Membr. Technol., 1997, 5 (1997)
  256. S.Lazarev, S.Kovalev, K.Shestakov. Acta Period. Technol., 236 (2019)
  257. S.I.Lazarev, S.V.Kovalev, I.V.Khorokhorina, M.I.Mikhailin. Chem. Pet. Eng., 56, 475 (2020)
  258. O.Bobreshova, I.Aristov, P.Kulintsov, E.Balavadze. J. Membr. Sci., 177, 201 (2000)
  259. N.Ishibashi, K.Hirano. J. Electrochem. Soc. Jpn., 27, E193 (1959)
  260. Q.Li, H.Liu, Y.Ji, Z.Cui, F.Yan, M.Younas, J.Li, B.He. Desalination, 535, 115825 (2022)
  261. O.V.Bobreshova, P.I.Kulintsov, I.V.Aristov, E.M.Balavadze. Russ. J. Electrochem., 32, 164 (1996); https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=13242966
  262. Patent RU 2398618 (2010); https://patents.google.com/patent/RU2398618C2/ru
  263. N.V.Shel'deshov, V.V.Chaika, V.I.Zabolotskii. Russ. J. Electrochem., 44, 1036 (2008)
  264. P.Geng, G.Chen. In Nanofiltration. IntechOpen, 2018. P. 133
  265. H.M.Huotari, G.Tragrdh, I.H.Huisman. Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 77, 461 (1999)
  266. S.Lentsch, P.Aimar, J.L.Orozco. J. Memb. Sci., 80, 221 (1993)
  267. L.Ge, B.Wu, Q.Li, Y.Wang, D.Yu, L.Wu, J.Pan, J.Miao, T.Xu. J. Membr. Sci., 498, 192 (2016)
  268. Q.Li, H.Liu, B.He, W.Shi, Y.Ji, Z.Cui, F.Yan, Y.Mohammad, J.Li. J. Membr. Sci., 641, 119880 (2022)
  269. A.G.Kislyi, D.Y.Butylskii, S.A.Mareev, V.V. Nikonenko Membr. Membr. Technol., 3, 131 (2021)
  270. A.K.Brewer, S.L.Madorsky, J.W.Westhaver. Science, 104, 156 (1946)
  271. A.K.Brewer, S.L.Madorsky, J.K.Taylor, V.H.Dibeler, P.Bradt, O.L.Parham, R.J.Britten, J.G.Reid. J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand., 38, 137 (1947)
  272. K.Wagener, H.D.Freyer, B.A.Bilal. Sep. Sci., 6, 483 (1971)
  273. L.N.Moskvin, A.N.Katruzov, V.S.Gurskij, P.Y.Apel, V.I.Kuznetsov, V.V.Shirkova. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 302, 841 (1988); https://inis.iaea.org/search/search.aspx?orig_q=RN:20028684
  274. S.M.Correa, G.Arbilla, M.S.Carvalho. Sep. Sci. Technol., 33, 1551 (1998)
  275. J.Broome, S.Raymond. Nature (London), 214, 849 (1967)
  276. E.R.Ramirez. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 76, 6237 (1954)
  277. A.Klemm. Angew. Chem., 70, 21 (1958)
  278. K.Kontturi, P.Forssell, A.Ekman. Sep. Sci. Technol., 17, 1195 (1982)
  279. A.Ekman, P.Forssell, K.Kontturi, G.Sundholm. J. Membr. Sci., 11, 65 (1982)
  280. P.Forssell, K.Kontturi. Sep. Sci. Technol., 18, 205 (1983)
  281. K.Kontturi, T.Ojala, P.Forssell. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 1, Phys. Chem. Condens. Phases, 80, 3379 (1984)
  282. K.Kontturi, H.Pajari. Sep. Sci. Technol., 21, 1089 (1986)
  283. K.Kontturi, A.-K.Kontturi, L.Pettersson, S.Karvinen, L.Niinisto, H.V.Volden, J.Weidlein, R.A.Zingaro. Acta Chem. Scand., 40a, 555 (1986)
  284. K.Kontturi. Sep. Sci. Technol., 21, 591 (1986)
  285. K.Kontturi. Sep. Sci. Technol., 23, 227 (1988)
  286. L.M.Westerberg. Sep. Sci. Technol., 23, 235 (1988)
  287. C.Tang, A.Yaroshchuk, M.L.Bruening. Chem. Commun., 56, 10954 (2020)
  288. C.Tang, M.P.Bondarenko, A.Yaroshchuk, M.L.Bruening. J. Memb. Sci., 638, 119684 (2021)
  289. C.Tang, A.Yaroshchuk, M.L.Bruening. Membranes, 12, 631 (2022)
  290. V.V.Sarapulova, E.L.Pasechnaya, V.D.Titorova, N.D.Pismenskaya, P.Y.Apel, V.V.Nikonenko. Membr. Membr. Technol., 2, 332 (2020)
  291. G.M.Geise, M.A.Hickner, B.E.Logan. ACSAppl. Mater. Interfaces, 5, 10294 (2013)
  292. Z.Ji, Q.Chen, J.Yuan, J.Liu, Y.Zhao, W.Feng. Sep. Purif. Technol., 172, 168 (2017)
  293. S.Yang, Y.Liu, J.Liao, H.Liu, Y.Jiang, B.V.D.Bruggen, J.Shen, C.Gao. ACSAppl. Mater. Interfaces, 11, 17730 (2019)
  294. N.U.Afsar, X.Ge, Z.Zhao, A.Hussain, Y.He, L.Ge, T.Xu. Sep. Purif. Technol., 254, 117619 (2021)
  295. F.Sheng, L.Hou, X.Wang, M.Irfan, M.A.Shehzad, B.Wu, X.Ren, L.Ge, T.Xu. J. Membr. Sci., 594, 117453 (2020)

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies